Priest Evgeny Veselov

Icon Veneration — Dispute between Orthodox Christians and Baptists

Kostroma, January 30, 2024
این متن به زبان های دیگر نیز موجود است:

Participants in the dispute:

On the Orthodox side — Priest Evgeny Veselov, Alan Bedoev (speaker), and others.

On the Baptist side — religious scholar Dmitri Furtsev (Yaroslavl; speaker), Pastor Sergei Antonovich Didovets, and others.

*For ease of reading, the text has undergone minimal literary editing.

Audio version of the dispute: https://rutube.ru/video/7ddaab88377ff075d45dc3d1856ed009/

Report of the Orthodox side (Alan Bedoev)

The theme of the veneration of holy icons for the majority of Protestants is one of the most painful, unbearable of the doctrines of the Orthodox Church. And even at our previous meetings, though in passing, people always touched on this theme.

Therefore, at the outset, I should like to express gratitude that you agreed to discuss this theme with us, because it is truly very, very important.

So, at the foundation of the Orthodox doctrine of the veneration of sacred things in general lies the understanding that matter as such has the capacity both to be sanctified and, in like manner, to be defiled. In other words, it can receive, preserve, and transmit the uncreated divine grace of the Holy Spirit.

When God created heaven and earth, all of it was full of grace — there are no doubts here — impregnated with divine light, and man, being on such an earth, was in joy and complete peace. But when man once sinned and fell away from God, he thereby defiled the earth and brought upon it a curse.

It is written: “cursed is the ground for your sake” (Genesis 3:17) — the book of Genesis tells us. The earth came to bring forth noisome grass — “thorns and thistles shall it bring forth to you,” this remarkable book tells us. There appeared sicknesses, death, earthquakes, floods, dangerous beasts, and calamities of that kind.

And every day, to this day, man defiles the earth with his sins; and these natural cataclysms — we see that they increase from year to year. According to Holy Scripture, incredible natural phenomena will take place during the reign of the Antichrist, since precisely at that time man will sin in a special frenzied way. In detail this is said in chapters 6 and 16 of the book of Revelation.

You remember God Himself warned the Israelites, saying that if they would keep His commandments, God would bless them — and, in particular, by the fact that the earth would abundantly give its fruits. But if they turned away from Him, certain misfortunes would happen to them, including ones of a natural character. In detail it is said in the book of Deuteronomy, chapter 11, verses 13 to 18 — I may say I quote literally.

From this follows the evident conclusion that the spiritual state of a man directly influences the matter surrounding him, which because of his holy life is either blessed and sanctified, or because of his sins defiled and cursed.

God created matter precisely so — capable of receiving and transmitting divine grace, or a curse. This is a spiritual law.

If a man lives holily, then his spirit is sanctified and filled with the grace of God; from his spirit his soul is sanctified, and from the soul the body. Here it is important that precisely the body also can be holy. As it is said: “Now may the God of peace Himself sanctify you completely; and may your whole spirit, soul, and body be preserved blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ” (1 Thessalonians 5:23).

It is also written: “your bodies are members of Christ,” “your bodies are the temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you” (1 Corinthians 6:15; 1 Corinthians 6:19).

From the body of a holy man his clothing is already sanctified, the earth on which he walked, vessels — for example, the things with which he was in contact. And the holier a man is and the more he is filled with the Holy Spirit, the more he sanctifies the matter around himself.

By the action of the law indicated there exists the possibility of receiving the grace of God — often wonder-working — by means of those material objects (for example, garments) with which a holy man was in contact.

Thus we know from the Gospel that a woman who had suffered twelve years with a grievous illness touched the hem of the garment of Christ and received instant healing (Matthew 9:20–21; Mark 5:25–29; Luke 8:43–44). Here is the question: what healed this woman? Some matter, of itself? No — the grace of God, which was upon that garment and which, properly speaking, that garment radiated. Elisha once stopped the river by means of the mantle of the holy prophet Elijah (2 Kings 2:14). The sick and the possessed were healed by means of handkerchiefs and aprons taken from the body of Paul being laid upon them (Acts 19:12).

And again the question: were there some wonder-working handkerchiefs, or what? No — it was the grace of God that acted through the material, the material sacred thing.

The same takes place now. Thousands, tens of thousands of all manner of healings, wonders by means of the sacred things venerated by the church. Why go far — take even our wonder-working Feodorovskaya icon of the Mother of God. An enormous number of testimonies — there is even a whole site to which people send testimonies. An enormous number, an enormous block; from all over Russia people come and receive healing from cancer. Someone for decades could not have children; they come, with prayer and reverence venerate this icon and receive healing, become happy parents, and so on.

Here, for example, of what I read lately. A woman — she had a tumor; she traveled almost the whole of Russia; the doctors simply could not help. To no treatment, to no chemotherapy would the sickness yield. And she heard in Moscow that there is such a wonder-working icon; she came with pilgrims, with prayer and reverence venerated the icon and was miraculously healed. She describes it on the site; it is open; and now she testifies to everyone she possibly can, writes letters of thanks, thanks God. And of such stories there truly are very, very many.

Another way of sanctifying material objects is all manner of Theophanies or, in Russian, the manifestations of God. From Holy Scripture we know: when God showed Himself in visible form, the matter where this took place was sanctified. And here — attention — God demanded the due veneration of such matter. A striking example is the history of Moses. When God appeared to him in the bush that did not burn, Moses heard the following words: “Moses, take your sandals off your feet, for the place where you stand is holy ground” (Exodus 3:5).

From the point of view of an ordinary Protestant, a Baptist — well, sand is sand: why take off one’s shoes? But no — we see God in this respect is very categorical and directly requires of His servant a reverent attitude toward the earth, toward the material sacred thing that God sanctified. Not only God — it happened that angels also, when they appeared to men — matter was likewise sanctified.

When the captain of the Lord’s host appeared to Joshua, he — Joshua — heard the same words: “Take your sandals off your feet, for the place where you stand is holy” (Joshua 5:13–15). These places were sanctified because they were in contact with the real manifestation of God or His Angels. Which again speaks of the reality of the law by which matter is capable of receiving Divine grace.

Such matter — earth, clothing, vessels, and the rest — that came into contact with God, Angels, or holy people is called in the Church a sacred thing, which God obliges us to venerate duly.

And the word of God is literally overflowing with examples of this kind. Everyone, probably, knows the history of Uzzah, who with a daring hand touched the Ark of the Covenant, which he had no right to touch (2 Samuel 6:6–7). It would seem matter, a work of human hands; but God took this daring as personal disrespect toward Himself. And as a result it became the last day of the life of that man. God slew him.

This is not some secondary thing. God deprived a man of life for disrespectful treatment of a sacred thing. That is what the word of God tells us. We also know that every thing dedicated to God is a sacred thing. The tabernacle was sacred, because it was the place of worship. The Jerusalem temple was sacred. Of David it is said he was “a man after God’s own heart” (1 Samuel 13:14; Acts 13:22). But he rendered systematic veneration to the Jerusalem temple. As it is said in the psalm: “But as for me, I will come into Your house in the multitude of Your mercy; in fear of You I will worship toward Your holy temple” (Psalm 5:7).

Let us go further. All the temple and priestly objects were sacred things. Exodus, chapter 30, verses 26–29: “and you shall anoint them (that is, with the anointing oil): the tabernacle of meeting and the ark of the Testimony, the table and all its utensils, the lampstand and its utensils, and the altar of incense, the altar of burnt offering with all its utensils, and the laver and its base. And you shall sanctify them, (and attention) that they may be most holy; whatever touches them must be holy” (Exodus 30:26–29). Yet again we assure ourselves of the spiritual law of the capacity of matter to be a conductor of Divine grace.

The Ark of the Covenant was a special sacred thing, before which Joshua fell on his face to the earth (Joshua 7:6). And lay there for several hours. Generally, in discussing this theme, it is important to point at our dear Baptist friends themselves. The majority of them, of course, deny the veneration of sacred things — but in practice are their true venerators.

Well, here a living example, a banal one. If to your assembly there comes a man in rainy weather and hangs his umbrella on the cross which you have located on the first floor, then probably only the laziest will not reproach him for blasphemous behavior. Or now one of us, caring for the satisfaction of his neighbor, takes out of his bag a fat herring wrapped, instead of newspaper, in texts from Holy Scripture, and offers us to eat. Such a man, probably, will suffer very strongly — at least from such threatening glances.

Or if now a brother should take the word of God and stuff it under the table as a prop, so that it be convenient to sit. The same — probably each of our Baptist friends will make him a remark. That is, the veneration of sacred things goes on among the Baptists too. Here it is important to note that the veneration is not directed straight to God, but precisely to the material sacred thing. More precisely, the veneration goes to God by means of the material sacred thing. And can one call Joshua and Moses idolaters because they bowed and venerated the temple and the Ark of God? Does not this say that, bowing to the temple, in reality these men thereby venerated God Himself?

In the same way the Orthodox, venerating the Gospel, venerating sacred things, venerating the temple of God, thereby venerate the Lord Himself. This is one of the ways of venerating God.

Let us go further. We pass to the theme of the veneration of icons. Here it must be said at once: there is such a thesis — that icons were invented somewhere in the fifth century, that originally the apostolic Church did not know them. Well, of course, that thesis is false. Icons have been in the Church always, from the first century. Even in the catacombs, where the first Christians gathered (it was the time of Nero, the first century, the sixties), they find no small number of images of the apostle Peter, the Mother of God, Christ.

And so as not to speak without evidence, there is such a most authoritative Baptist figure — Sergei Sannikov, doctor of theology. He is considered simply the highest authority. He has a book, “Twenty Centuries of Christianity.” In this book this Baptist figure himself brings an enormous number of all manner of ancient images. Especially noteworthy is the image of Christ found not far from the sea of Galilee. It is the very latest find. Swiss and English scholars date it, without doubt, to the first century. This is modern Turkey, not far from Chalcedon; found in the catacombs where the first Christians were. This image is dated to the first century.

Baptist: Is that from the catacomb church?

Orthodox: Yes — it is in the catacombs where the Christians were under the emperor Nero.

This is already the third century. Various frescoes that were found in the Roman catacombs, when there were persecutions of the Christians. Here is how the places looked where the first Christians served the Lord.

We see that here the images are — a fragment from the Gospel — here, for example, the Good Shepherd. The second century. We see the lamb on the neck. In general, all this is in open access. Whoever wishes, I can even send the link, including to your Baptist figure.

The icon in the church — this concerns secular science. This the archaeologists found and so on. Also the voice of the Church confirms it. The ancient fathers and teachers of the Church point to us that in the Christian temples of their time, and in earlier times, there were icons, and they explain their purpose.

For example, the second century. Clement of Alexandria says of the Christian that “he, fixing his gaze on the image, directs his thoughts to the many patriarchs who before him attained perfection, to the very many prophets, to the Angels, and to the Lord Himself, all of whom teach us that we also may have everlasting life, conformable to these lofty images.”

The second century. Minucius, Felix, Tertullian, and Origen describe that the pagans always reproached the ancient Christians for divinizing the cross of the Lord — which gives us the understanding that the first Christians venerated the Crucifixion of the Lord.

The third century. Methodius of Patara writes: “the images of the Angels — that is, of God, the Principalities and Powers — made of gold, we make in His honor and glory.”

Basil the Great — this is already the fourth century — writes: “I accept from the holy apostles, prophets, martyrs; I call upon their intercession before God, that through them — that is, by their intercession — the merciful God may show me mercy and grant me remission of sins. Therefore I venerate their icon-images and worship before them, especially because they have been handed down by the holy apostles and are not forbidden, but are depicted in all our churches.”

Of course, until the fourth century icon-painting was not so widely spread for the well-known reason — the reason of the harsh persecutions — but already by the fourth century icons became absolutely universal. And we see here that Basil the Great does not say icons were created in his time. No — he says we accepted this tradition from the apostles themselves.

Now, concerning the very act of veneration. It is known that Holy Scripture indeed forbids bowing to idols and to other visible likenesses of created beings — that is, taking them for gods. But, of course, this is indeed so — yet this does not relate to the true veneration of God, the Angels, and the saints, which, properly speaking, is directed not at soulless matter, but at the very subject of the depiction.

Here it is important that the definition of the Seventh Ecumenical Council narrates that the honor, the prayer, the address, the doxology rendered to the image — that is, to the icon — ascends to the prototype, that is, to the one depicted on this icon. That is, in other words, the Orthodox does not pray to, does not extol a bit of wood with paints, but that man depicted on this icon, who, without doubt, is alive and is with God and whom the church glorified as a saint.

And just as it often happens that we kiss a portrait and thereby manifest love for them, so the Orthodox Christians, censing incense before the icon, praying, kissing, thereby manifest love to the prototype.

It is also necessary to point to the very concept of veneration and worship in the Orthodox confession. The point is that not every worship is identical. And that same Seventh Ecumenical Council clearly distinguished: there is venerative worship — as we, for example, venerate, even when we greet one another, sometimes we incline the head. Jacob, for instance, it is written, seven times fell before Esau. We venerate sacred things, venerate the Gospel. This is venerative worship, which in Greek is called “proskynesis.” And there is divine worship, “latreia.” Such worship we render only to God and to Him alone.

And here (attention!) the Orthodox doctrine determines that the Orthodox venerate the icon exclusively with venerative worship, not divine. That is, we venerate icons, but do not pray to them as gods, but simply venerate them as certain sacred things.

Let us go further. The purpose of icons in the church.

The first thesis — the icon helps us to kindle love for God and His saints. I remember how one of my former associates — a Pentecostal — reproached me indeed seriously for the veneration of icons: behold, there is a living God, and you commit adultery with Him with a piece of wood; why do you venerate the works of human hands, when there is the Lord — this, conditionally speaking, offends His feelings.

But let us examine on a concrete example whether it is so. Many men — the banal example that is usually brought; I shall tell it — men often carry with them photographs of their wives or brides. And now imagine that the wife of such a man, seeing her photograph, her image at her husband, began to take offense and scold him for committing adultery with her, the living one, with a soulless image made of paper and paint.

Perfect absurdity — because anyone will understand that precisely love for the wife impelled this man to make her photograph, to carry it, to look at it more often, indeed, in the moments when he travels somewhere on business, to kiss it, and so on.

The wife will not only not accuse him of betraying her with a soulless object, but on the contrary will rejoice that her husband loves her so much that he made this image. We see that the very venerative attitude toward the photograph of a beloved person is, of course, not betrayal, but, on the contrary, shows love — as I said earlier.

The second thesis — the icon is needed for preaching. The same Ecumenical Council declared that icons accord with the narration of gospel preaching.

The icon is indeed the Gospel in paints. For on it are often depicted many gospel fragments — the incarnation of God, the Baptism, the Resurrection, the walking of Peter on the waters; the gospel commandments are depicted, which were realized in the life of the saints. And the power of such preaching is sometimes very powerful, because a man often perceives through images far better than through words. There is a Russian proverb: “better once to see than a hundred times to hear.” It is a worldly proverb, but in this case it may be applied.

From history we also know that many saints were converted to Christianity in this way. Mary of Egypt, for example — now a very great saint, formerly a harlot. She turned to Christianity when she saw the image of the Most Holy Mother of God. It was her purity, her majesty, that turned her consciousness, and she became a Christian.

Even our Russian prince Vladimir finally decided to pass over to Orthodoxy after the Greek Byzantine missionaries showed him the icon of the Last Judgment. So it truly is a preaching of the Gospel.

Let us go further. The third aspect. Icons are needed to arouse in man the religious feeling and to remind him of God. The same Seventh Ecumenical Council pointed to this purpose of icons, saying: “as often as the representations are seen on the icons, so often those who gaze upon them are moved to remember and love their prototypes.”

In an Orthodox church everything reminds of God. Everywhere are painted gospel histories, people who — I repeat — fulfilled the Gospel with their life. And in such a place it is truly very, very easy to pray.

One may, of course, say: I need no props; I have Jesus always with me — but we know man is a two-component being, and sometimes he perceives faith also through bodily senses. One cannot escape this, unfortunately.

Fourth: Icons are needed also for the keeping of the commandment: “Remember those who rule over you, who have spoken the word of God to you, whose faith follow, considering the outcome of their conduct” (Hebrews 13:7). And by means of icons the church truly remembers its instructors, shepherds, teachers, confessors of the faith, ascetics of piety, who shone in it through history. And again tries to imitate their life.

And fifth: Icons are needed to sanctify churches and homes. As I said, the icon is a sacred thing that has its sanctifying action, thanks to the saint depicted on it and to the prayer with which the priest sanctifies it.

Therefore it seems to us, and we know (“it seems” is a bad word) — we see that the veneration of icons has direct foundation in the word of God; it is not idolatry, and it is not betrayal of Jesus Christ, but on the contrary is a confirmation of our love for God. For now I should like to finish here. Thank you.

Baptist pastor: Thank you. At once let us pass to the report from our side.

Orthodox: Yes.

Baptist pastor: Afterwards there will be questions. I am writing everything down for myself, yes — there are many questions.

Report of the Baptist side (Dmitri Furtsev)

I too have historical facts here, and I think such sources as there are in the Catholic Church — no fewer, I think, far more there of various historical and other arguments.

Well, I shall begin with the fact that, as in any normal church, there is catechesis. That is, the doctrine — you have all gone through it; someone perhaps as a catechumen. And in our doctrine the second commandment, and I think we understand identically the purpose of the commandments altogether, because the Lord tells us through His word that life according to the commandments He calls holiness and righteousness.

So. The second commandment says — you all know it perfectly; I say it not in order to reproach you with something, but that the Word may sound. Perhaps, brothers, someone will be ready too, so that I do not leaf through the whole Bible — you were ready to say that place I shall name.

So, for now I have open here the book of Exodus, chapter 20 — the Decalogue known to all, the Ten Words, given to Moses through the ministry of angels by the Lord Himself on Mount Sinai.

“You shall not make for yourself a carved image — any likeness of what is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them nor serve them; for I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and fourth generations of those who hate Me, but showing mercy to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.”

We see here sounds such a direct principle of monotheism — that is, faith in one God (“mono” — one, “Theos” — God) — with the utmost clarity and precision.

The prohibition of idols is, of course, not a prohibition of sculptures, statues, images in general, but against the making of images for worship. I wished to distinguish two terms — veneration and worship.

Of course, taking out photographs, seeing beloved people… Even when my combat commander sent me from the army his photograph, I even kissed it — although now, it seems, it is not accepted — but I was so glad to see him, after… this year it will be 35 years since the withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan… That I even kissed his image. It does not mean I addressed him there and said: “Servant of God Alexander, how are you fighting there? Four drones flew here,” or something of that kind. No.

Therefore no one is against images. All our doctrinal literature says the Evangelical Christians-Baptists do not consider the visual arts impermissible in the religious sphere. We are aware that the visual arts were used for decorative purposes from the times of the Old Covenant and at the building of the Jerusalem temple (1 Kings 6:29–35) — I think you will look at home yourselves. We consider it permissible to use images of the Cross as a symbol of our redemption in prayer houses, and possible the use of illustrations on biblical themes in Christian literature — otherwise we should have to throw out all our children’s Bibles, which so abound in them.

However, we consider absolutely unacceptable for ourselves the use of intermediary objects directly in communion with God in personal prayer and public worship.

We consider the Bible forbids not only the direct deification of any objects, but also any prayerful veneration of images.

The book of Exodus, as we have already read — and let us touch one more passage, brothers; you may read it — this is Deuteronomy, chapter 4, verses 15–19: a warning against idolatry. Whoever wishes — please, the word is yours, while I pass to the next thought.

“Take careful heed to yourselves, for you saw no form when the Lord spoke to you at Horeb out of the midst of the fire, lest you act corruptly and make for yourselves a carved image in the likeness of any figure: the likeness of a male or a female, the likeness of any animal that is on the earth, the likeness of any winged bird that flies in the air, the likeness of anything that creeps on the ground, the likeness of any fish that is in the waters beneath the earth…”

That is enough, I think; all have understood anyway. Of course, in the historical context — whoever has really studied biblical exegesis knows what the author wished to say to the historical readers — first of all, all this relates to gods, or rather to the false gods of the surrounding peoples. Because we know all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God — that everlasting life in Christ. And that the Lord had to call Abraham, to create a definite people, so that our Lord Jesus Christ could come in the flesh. He could not come in that people among which there stood some demonic worship, because behind every cult, every false religion, stand demonic powers. And, of course, in such a people the Savior, the Messiah, Yeshua, Isa al-Masih could not come.

It is important to note that the word of the New Covenant definitely says Christ is the only mediator of the believer in relations with God. The First Epistle to Timothy, from the holy pastoral epistles, chapter 2, verse 5.

Baptist: (From the hall): “For there is one God and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Timothy 2:5).

Baptist: (Speaker): I am grateful. Consequently, in the presence of the image of the mediator there is no need whatsoever. I shall tell you — I am even ready to kiss any saint, but not to pray to him. Of course, we have various cases too. “Imitate me, as I also imitate Christ” — that is not a call to pray to him, and not to Christ.

He says “imitate me, as I also imitate Christ.” So. Well, with us for the common people (I can send you afterwards a video five years old, which I made for the newly begun and altogether unchurched people). There are simple questions:

Here is the question: “The veneration of icons is not idolatry. Why do you categorically oppose the veneration of icons?” This is written for a broad circle of readers: “The Baptists answer” — it is the catechetical section of the Russian Union of ECB (Evangelical Christians-Baptists).

What does our doctor of theology say: “First, the veneration of icons in folk religion…

(After all, not everyone is acquainted with the works of John of Damascus. We shall come to him; [people] have read and know who the ecumenical teachers are. At the most they have read the lives of Basil the Great, John Chrysostom, Gregory the New Theologian).

“… the veneration of icons in folk religion often bears the character of unconscious idolatry. They have no such lofty theological thought that it relates to the prototype. They perceive it literally. That is sad, of course, when people in practice worship material objects, having no conception of the true God.”

Comment: The authors of the quotation depart from the initial thesis. If some indeed worship icons wrongly, the Orthodox Church does not teach that. After all, some interpret the Bible heretically or use it, for example, for divination. But is that a reason to give up the Bible? The Church, through icons, commands the faithful to recall God and His saints as often as possible, that by their example they may be strengthened in prayer and in imitation of their Christian life. What is bad here?

Friends, I am also a historian by education. My coursework was “The spiritual component on the field of Kulikovo.” My supervisor was the hegumen Boris. A man with I do not know how many Moscow higher educations, who edited me. And I believe that for the common people, as in the times of Christ, some material sacred thing is needed, for their consciousness, for their consciousness. But most of all, of course, this is more as exceptional cases. Because there is such a spiritual law which the apostle Paul says to his disciple in the pastoral epistle: “all is sanctified by the word of God and prayer” (1 Timothy 4:5).

Here we have now called the angels at the meal; by prayer we have sanctified our meal, our converse. All is sanctified by the word of God and prayer. It does not mean it has become of God. Of course, a certain grace-bearing energy undoubtedly issues forth. And even scholars measure the soul by certain physical parameters. And say that when a man prays, from him issue certain impulses, frequencies, which act beneficially both on him and on those around.

That is still further with us — I think much will be revealed to us in the Kingdom of Heaven, what is now hidden from us. However, so — “bears in practice the character of the worship of material objects, having no conception of the true God.”

I am very glad that in the ROC there have now appeared many Sunday schools — and, moreover, for adults. Because the people are, in fact, though baptized, often not enlightened. Again, I am very glad. And they proposed to me to be a catechist in any deanery of the Yaroslavl metropolia. They even said to me: brother, we bless you; a thousand rubles for your two-three lessons. You may propose voluntary donations. Why? Because in reality people need the spiritual component of our faith to be explained — God, that God is a Spiritual Being. No one has ever seen Him, as we read in chapter 4 of the Gospel of John. And we read also that Jesus Christ manifested God to us in visible form. One of the first heresies — the Docetists — what did they do?

We all read the First catholic Epistle of John. What is there to see but love. God is love. However it was called forth by serious problems in the early church. And there were appearing, raising their head, carrying away many disciples, troubling with gnostic teachings — in that they said Christ came in an apparent body.

Therefore the apostle John writes in chapter 4 of his First catholic Epistle: “By this you know the Spirit of God (and the spirit of error): every spirit that does not confess that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is not of God, but is the spirit of the Antichrist” (1 John 4:2).

We think this was somewhere sometime. Friends, here I read the First catholic Epistle of John. And at once I came upon those people, bearers of this ancient heresy — that Christ came as it were in an apparent body, like a phantom.

Orthodox priest: Forgive me, but may we be closer to the theme?

Baptist: (Speaker): Very well… Second, God does not take pleasure in self-willed worship. That is, there is, as it were, no such call for us to venerate, all the more to worship spiritually… And in the practice of Christ there was none, nor of the apostles — there was no such practice [i.e. the practice of venerating icons — ed.]. Well, and… As I have already said, those places of Scripture…

Comment: In the practice of Christ and the apostles there was not much of what is now with the Baptists and other evangelicals. They had no songs with demonstration on a big screen; there were no musical groups of glorification, religious dances and hand-clappings; they were dressed differently; they built their preaching differently; they did not know the principle of “Scripture only,” and in addition to faith for salvation they required the keeping of the gospel commandments. It is clear the outward forms of religious veneration developed with time — that is a natural process. The worship of the times of King Solomon differs substantially from the worship of the times of the prophet Moses. In what place of Scripture is it required to glorify God only and exclusively in those forms that are prescribed in Scripture itself? It is an invented requirement, which the Baptists themselves do not follow either.

Our second theme was… Well, if we finish this a little, because there were historical references. Therefore the basic doctrines, disputes, and heresies with us are from the sixth to the eighth century. There was the iconoclast movement. They accused even more not that… the Protestants were not yet there. The Muslims accused. They too are a monotheistic religion. Though it is false, not acknowledging… [Christ as God — ed.]. They accused the eastern church of idolatry. They say they worship in church pictures, statues, portraits. The iconoclasts spoke against the use of any images. Emperor Leo III issued in 730 an edict forbidding the use of icons in the Eastern church. The cause consisted in that icons led to idolatry condemned by the Bible.

The monks furiously opposed the edict. Under Pope Gregory II the Western church encouraged the use of icons. And the successor Gregory III… the successor excommunicated from the church all who ever carried out of the church and destroyed or damaged even one image of Christ, the Virgin Mary, or the saints. Emperor Charlemagne also encouraged the adornment of churches with images, but resolutely opposed the worship of these images. Until the empress Theodora ordered the icons to be returned to the church and the iconoclasts driven out.

The iconoclasts proposed to replace artistic images with the Cross or the Bible, considering them the only permissible, in quotation marks, icons.

The theological grounding of the position of the venerators of icons was given in the works of John of Damascus, a Palestinian monk, as you have already heard, at the Seventh Ecumenical Council. Since he was one of the last, as some consider, fathers of the church, a great theologian, he put forward the following theological arguments: icons are only imitation, a copy of the original, or else a reminder of the original. Christ was the icon of God the Father — Colossians 1:15, that is, image. It would be wrong to worship icons, but they serve along with the Bible and the cross for teaching and reminding of God.

With such an interpretation it was accepted. In theory this theological position calls forth no reproaches from the Protestant churches. But in practice it served the development of idolatry and led to violations of Scripture. Only one God deserves worship, and the decision of the Nicene Council of 787 turned out unsuccessful and gave an impetus to the worship of images and relics, which received their greatest development in the Western Church.

We shall now say a couple of words about the worship of relics. Relics and reliquaries. Places of Scripture, Psalm 115:17: “The dead do not praise the Lord, nor any who go down into silence” — that is, the dead do not praise God.

And David also prayed, “who shall glorify You in the grave” — who shall glorify. Also Acts, chapter 8, verse 2: “And devout men carried Stephen to his burial.” See how all are gathered here; I so wish to think that we are all devout men. “And made great lamentation over him.” But you remember Moses — it was said that no one should even find him, so as not to make of him an idol for worship. But Moses was a man not so simple. Remember those throngs. Josephus describes that his face became shining, that even other peoples joined. Then went the first proselytes, looking at the face of Moses coming out after converse with God. Christ also says in Matthew 23:27 “of the impurity of human remains.”

Comment: Addressing the Jews, the Lord speaks of the ritual Old Testament impurity, comparing it with the inward sinful impurity of the Pharisees. However, in the New Covenant the attitude precisely to ritual, legal impurity is different: “I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that there is nothing unclean of itself; but to him who considers anything unclean, to him it is unclean” (Romans 14:14). And further: “To the pure all things are pure; but to those who are defiled and unbelieving nothing is pure; but even their mind and conscience are defiled” (Titus 1:15). It is even strange that the Baptist does not know these quotations.

Nowhere in the New Covenant do we find the idea that the remains of Christians outstanding or glorified by special holiness could bring blessing. It is not prescribed to expect blessing from objects connected in any way with departed righteous men.

Of course, one cannot pass a special place in biblical history — when the body of a dead man, whom they wished to bury, and there the whole people then fell into idolatry. And when the enemy went against them, they, not keeping the tradition, threw him — one may say dropped him into the first vault they came to — this is 2 Kings 13:21, where his body came into contact with the bones of the prophet Elisha, and he came to life.

Of all the commentaries I liked the one under the editorship of Platon Kharchoaa — he is not Orthodox, but he gathered the best commentaries; he did not interpret all himself; he was simply a collector. In that it was a wonder — to the end that even from the grave Israel might recall the prophet, and of what he admonished them. And he admonished them to turn to God, to repent.

Comment: Of course, the Baptist Kharchoaa pleased our speaker. But the matter here is not in the allegorical or typological interpretation of this event, but in a simple fact. Indeed, the dead man came to life from contact precisely with the bones of the prophet — that is, the Lord chose the bones of the prophet as an object for His glorification. If the aim of God had been otherwise, there would have been found a prophet who would have explained this event to the Jews in the Baptist way. But no — the Lord did not wish so to abase the prophet Elisha, in contrast to the Baptists.

Friends, I am already finishing; forgive me. Of course, in the book of the Acts of the holy apostles, as we have already heard, the sick were healed by handkerchiefs, aprons from the body of the apostle Paul — the book of Acts, chapter 19, verses 11–12. As in the case of the bones of Elisha, here we deal with the description of a unique situation for the affirmation of the Gospel. God did and does — because “He is the same yesterday, today, and forever” (Hebrews 13:8).

Comment: Quite right. If such was the action of God in the days of the apostles, then now He desires to act in the same way. As is evident, the Baptist knows the teaching of Scripture, but does not wish to accept it in fullness.

He does — but that does not mean it is a general practice. Neither in the book of Acts, nor in the epistles of the apostle Paul, do we meet even once more with a situation where the power of God acted mediately through material objects.

Comment: In Scripture many things are mentioned only once — for example, the Sunday service (Acts 20:7) or the formula of baptism in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit (Matthew 28:19). But is that a reason for the Baptists to abolish the Sunday liturgical gatherings or to baptize not in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit? As we see, the speaker again proposes double standards: some (broad) — for himself, others (narrow) — for the Orthodox.

The New Covenant, describing the death of the first disciple Stephen, mentions that his remains, as we have said, were buried — that is, laid in a grave, as the bodies of all men.

So, in the Bible there is no such foundation for the cult of relics or the cult of reliquaries. There is respect, esteem — but even David, Psalm 16, verse 15, with spiritual eyes beheld the image of God. I too like objects dedicated to God, and, of course, we must surround ourselves with such objects, but not deify them. Because the most ancient apostasy from God — animism — is the deification of inanimate objects. It is one of the most ancient archaic religions. Well, I think that is enough, yes, Father Evgeny?

You know, even the students took my part, although everyone around was Orthodox — let him say his “private theological opinion.”

Discussion of the reports

Orthodox priest: I am glad that with you we have a common terminology. That, of course, lightens the matter in part.

Baptist: (Speaker): Yes, because I listened a little to the reviews of the previous discussion and somewhat clarified to the pastor that you are simply speaking of one and the same thing, but both are mistaken.

Laughter.

Orthodox priest: It is a great pity you were not there earlier — otherwise the three of us would have been mistaken.

Baptist: (Speaker): No — you misunderstand: you are speaking of one and the same thing, but somewhat in different words.

Orthodox priest: Now we are speaking substantially of different things, without doubt.

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, yes.

Orthodox priest: So — well, since both our reports have finished, I should like, while this one is still in our memory — warm, hot, I would even say — to clarify. Dmitri, you began with the second commandment, with the Law of Moses. Do I understand you rightly that these ten commandments are kept literally in all times, and, if it is written “thou shalt not make an idol nor any likeness,” then we understand it so, and so on — altogether literally?

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, I have already read, if you were attentive, that we are not against the making of some…

Orthodox priest: No, no — the question is not about that. Precisely about this: do I understand rightly that all ten commandments, as they are written literally, are kept literally…

Baptist: (Speaker): No, they… there is something literal, but they have all been transformed through the teaching of Jesus Christ.

Orthodox: Excellent — I am glad you understand this; otherwise I would have asked you about the fourth commandment. It is good that you understand this. But then the question is such: since we understand all these commandments in the light of the teaching of Christ,

Baptist: (Speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: Even — I would say — not in the teaching of Christ, but in the light of Christ Himself; that will be still better. In particular, in the light of the event of the incarnation of God and the appearance of the Church. Do you agree with this?

Baptist: (Speaker): Please repeat once more.

Orthodox priest: These ten and the other Old Testament commandments we understand in the light of the teaching of Christ — or, more precisely, in the light of Christ Himself, the Person of Christ. The event of the incarnation of God and the birth of the Church.

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, as for the rest, they have lost their [significance], because a new institution appeared — the Church of the Lord Jesus Christ — while the moral law is for all times. Only, there is a broader understanding: if, according even to Archpriest Paul Slobodskoy’s “Law of God” of the Church abroad, say, the veneration of parents relates not only to parents, but in the church to priests — the leaders; in the hospital — to doctors; in the army — to commanders.

Orthodox priest: No — that does not relate to the matter; I ask something else here; we are not clarifying theological nuances, interpretations. What interests me, properly… The second commandment, you understand, does not sound thus by chance — because you quoted to us Deuteronomy, chapter 4, verses 15–19: “take careful heed to yourselves, for you saw no form when the Lord spoke there to you on Mount Horeb out of the midst of the fire,” and so on. This is very precise. So, the cause of the second commandment is that the Jews saw no form. But we Christians saw the image of Christ — why can we not depict Him as the Son of God? What hinders us?

Baptist: (Speaker): I think one may depict Him, of course — but you understand that in China they paint Christ narrow-eyed, in Africa dark-skinned; and in the Gospel not one physical parameter is described — neither the color of eyes, of hair, nor height, nor weight; none of this is there. That is, God wished to draw attention to something else — to His more spiritual and moral side, to His teaching.

Orthodox priest: Well, as for China, Japan, and the rest — all the same, agree: here I have never seen a Chinese icon of Christ. But if I were now given a Chinese icon of Christ, I am sure I should distinguish this icon from, say, your photograph or portrait of you, or of some other man. Even, without doubt. Why? Because an icon is a symbolic depiction, and it is not simply a depiction — but we see there is the inscription, as you know; the inscription shows us the spiritual essence; without the inscription, properly speaking, there is no icon at all.

Baptist: (Speaker): Yes — the icon loses canonicity.

Orthodox priest: Yes, you understand this. And concretely with Christ, besides, there is the cross-shaped halo. It is His alone, and no one else’s. In this halo are inscribed 9 bands — the Lord of the nine ranks of Angels. That is, our icon is deeply symbolic and presents to us theology in paints.

That which you say — that some do not understand — well, listen: some do not understand many things. One must teach — that is precisely what the Church does. Thus, whether He is narrow-eyed or not narrow-eyed, the question is not in what this artist by the strength of his skill depicted, but in that this is an icon of Christ, and that is evident; therefore this argument is altogether inessential. But as for the incarnation of God — here I have not heard your answer.

Baptist: (Speaker): What have you not heard?

Orthodox priest: If Christ became incarnate — the Son became incarnate — then the argument from Deuteronomy, Deuteronomy 4:15–19, is removed. “You saw no form; He cannot be depicted.” We saw the image of Christ — we depict Him. And we render Him the honor that relates, as Alan said, not to the image itself, in essence, but to the Prototype. No one ever venerates an icon as the Maker of heaven and earth.

Baptist: (Speaker): I agree with you — I agree, but listen to me. Of the four or more film adaptations of the gospel events what struck me most was the film “The Gospel of Luke” [“the Jesus film”], after the finding of the Qumran manuscripts, where it is closest to the historical details.

So I understand literally. And to that simple people in the villages — and not only, and in the cities, whoever watched and showed it — they told me: that is how we imagined Him. And literally this image, perhaps, stood in the head. But films were made also of “The Gospel of Mark,” “The Gospel of John,” “The Gospel of Matthew.” Everywhere there are positive and good traits, because there is the God-bearing word of God, which bears the very nature and person of Christ, and of God Himself and of the Holy Spirit. And it was a great labor for me to rid myself of the image of the actor of the English Shakespeare theater, so that I should not imagine in my mind… Therefore thou shalt not make thyself any likeness…

Orthodox priest: I am glad you sense the danger of the visible images of men in the place of Christ. But what is the speech about? We do not put the icon in the place of Christ — and you know this well. We put the icon in suitable places for the image of God in order, first, always to see God before the eyes.

We are sentient people; we have eyes, ears, and the rest. We, say, read Scripture. In Scripture are words. But words depict God verbally; a verbal icon of God likewise. We do not say that is bad. No — that is good. The very Son of God — He was an image; you know this.

Baptist: (Speaker): Of course.

Orthodox priest: Right. Must one worship the Son of God?

Baptist: (Speaker): Of course.

Orthodox priest: Of course. But if one must worship Him as the image of the invisible Father, then we see one may worship an image. But you say one may not.

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, that, of course, is not prescribed to us.

Orthodox priest: No, no — why? It is prescribed! Alan told us how Jacob bowed down to the ground seven times to Esau. And why did he bow? We know again: Esau was the image of God. And he rendered him honor as a creature of God. Is it not so? Did he bow not as to an image, but worship as to the living God?

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, I am, of course, very glad for you; however, God did not wish to transfer our attention from Himself to some material object.

Comment: The Baptist turns the conversation, because he does not wish to acknowledge that one may render due veneration to created beings — and the Bible confirms this repeatedly. One need only distinguish such veneration from the service proper to the one God.

Orthodox priest: I did not understand the thought.

Baptist: (Speaker): God did not wish to transfer our attention from Himself to some material object.

Orthodox priest: “I will come into Your house; I will worship toward Your holy temple” (Psalm 5:7)… Well, and what of it…

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, that, you understand, is a figurative expression — in the sense that he rejoices to go where God is present.

Orthodox priest: What figurative — he bows to the temple. We were told… Joshua, who fell and lay until evening before the Ark of the Covenant (Joshua 7:6)…

Baptist: (Speaker): I am glad myself: here I entered [into the Ipatiev monastery — ed.], saw it — I even wanted to cross myself.

Orthodox priest: And what hindered?

Baptist: (Speaker): I prayed…

Baptist: (From the hall): The word of God hindered.

Baptist: (Speaker): Without hands of men… I prayed, yes — without hands of men. I consider… I have, of course, a video; I shall send it afterwards to Alan; there I examine a book submitted for the degree of doctor of theology, in Cambridge itself. And there the work “The theology of icons” of an Evangelical Christian-Baptist, a believer.

Orthodox priest: Fairbairn?

Baptist: (Speaker): I do not remember his name. No — some Russian there. I do not know whence he took the money to study. Such it is; and, of course, it is acceptable — as if to observe with us in Pereyaslavl, I consider — if people are illiterate. Because those same ancient monasteries were the sources of enlightenment and mission of Ancient Rus. So. But people are illiterate. Here one wants to say: glory to God for the Soviet power. For what? For the fact that they almost liquidated one hundred percent illiteracy. Illiterate people remained none. Even gypsies — even they, I meet that they finished three grades at least; they can read and write.

And I agree: if the people are illiterate — here, in that very strict monastery, one may say, in the Nikitsky in Pereslavl-Zalessky, there is such a special kind of icon where the gospel events are depicted, and by them the teacher of a modern Sunday school may easily tell the Gospel itself. In principle, as one may tell the Creed.

Baptist: (From the hall): Simply a visual object.

Baptist: (Speaker): Yes. A visual object — all so. I agree that, of course, horror and fear take you when you look at the scene of the Last Judgment… So. And here, say, with us on Sovetskaya square, at the government of the Yaroslavl oblast, there is the church of Elijah the Prophet. I, by the way, brought its image to you.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Dmitri, somehow all this is off the theme… We must discuss all the questions…

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, of course, let us.

Orthodox priest: But perhaps I shall hear the answer to the question of the incarnation of God — because as I understand it, you are not against it: that worship of a man as the image of God is possible; worship of the Son of God as the image of the invisible Father is possible.

So, worship of an image is, in principle, possible. From this the question is not of the worship of an image as such, but of a hand-made image. And the foundation of the non-veneration of the hand-made image lies in two things. First, that which was already said in Deuteronomy — that the Jews saw no image; but we saw the image. So, this argument is removed.

Comment: The second thing is the absurd Protestant identification with idols (that is, false images) of every hand-made image in the context of the second commandment of Moses. It is clear that the prophet Moses himself, who made by God’s commandment the images of the cherubim in the tabernacle, could not consider them idols. Bowing, as was already said, were Joshua before the Ark of the Covenant, David before the temple, Jacob upon the top of his staff (Hebrews 11:21). All these were hand-made sacred things, not idols.

Baptist: (Speaker): Wait — who is “we” that saw the image?

Baptist: (From the hall): Yes, this too is interesting — who saw? Here you have seen? We now, in the modern world — how have you seen?

Orthodox priest: We Christians know of the incarnation of God. From this the icon dogmatically affirms for us the act of the incarnation of God.

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, so I shall paint it now — will that be an icon?

Baptist: (Speaker): We still have no reliable depictions of Jesus Christ…

Baptist: (From the hall): Here is the question — I paint it; will it be an icon?

Orthodox priest: No, it will not be an icon.

Baptist: (From the hall): Why?

Orthodox priest: Because an icon must have the signs of canonicity. Your drawing will hardly be such.

Baptist: (From the hall): But why did that sign of canonicity acquire some man who wrote?

Orthodox priest: Because it is not my opinion or your opinion — it is the teaching of the Church. For the Church it is important that the icon — I briefly showed you — has certain symbolic features. Without them it will be a child’s drawing. If you draw a child’s drawing like an icon, I shall not throw it underfoot…

Baptist: (From the hall): At the seventh councils all — precisely the episcopate — all said they would throw out all the icons. That is a historical fact. Shall I read it out?

Orthodox: (Speaker): They mean the Hierian council.

Baptist: (From the hall): There in forty years there were three councils. You know that, yes?

Orthodox priest: I am aware.

Baptist: (From the hall): At one they were abolished; the second was given by the hand of Irene; the monks were called too, so that there should be more than 350 than 380. And then the third simply, so as to leave it for the ignorant. That is, in forty years all these were such mishaps, yes? But we have just recalled the history figuratively.

Orthodox priest: If we shall speak of a council of bishops…

Comment: At first the Baptist began to speak of history, and then did not allow an answer to his own assertions. It is altogether surprising when Protestants try to teach us our own church history. It is they who are strangers to that history, while for us it is our flesh and blood. Not even touching the formal moments of the recognition of a council as Orthodox, let us say the following. If they accept the Hierian iconoclast council, let them accept also the worship of the Mother of God and of the saints established at it; certainly let them accept the first six Ecumenical Councils with their canonical rules. Let them accept also the episcopate having apostolic succession, because such were all the fathers of the council of 754. Let them accept the Orthodox Eucharist, because all these bishops celebrated it. Let them accept Orthodox churches and the rest that the participants of the Hierian council accepted. But no — the Protestants reject all this.

Baptist: (From the hall): Now — we do not see; one moment. Here, let us. The apostles were directly with Christ. Who of the apostles painted an icon or an image, so that it be handed down?

Orthodox: (From the hall): Luke painted… there is tradition that Luke painted…

Baptist: (From the hall): The question. Was Luke of the apostles? One moment. I said the twelve apostles, directly with Christ. Who of the twelve apostles painted?

Orthodox priest: Well, not all are artists, after all…

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, I put the question.

Orthodox priest: Well, not all are artists, after all…

Baptist: (From the hall): Because you said “we saw.” And then you will answer this question. So that the discussion may go further…

Baptist: (Speaker): We have no depiction of Christ from His lifetime. There are none. And the spiritual nature — this is still the relevance of the depiction.

Orthodox priest: “O foolish Galatians! Who has bewitched you that you should not obey the truth, before whose eyes Jesus Christ was clearly portrayed among you as crucified” (Galatians 3:1). Do you not know this text, or what?

Baptist: (Speaker): We know it perfectly.

Orthodox priest: Well, then what is the matter? If we see the spiritual icon of Christ, who hinders depicting Him in paints as well?

Baptist: (From the hall): But who painted it — I have not heard.

Orthodox priest: Various icon-painters wrote it.

Comment: The insistent question of the Baptist shows his deep misunderstanding of the meaning of the icon, and even his unwillingness to understand. The icon does not claim photographic accuracy, but is theology in paints. It reflects spiritual reality. Without creating a new faith, the veneration of icons merely affirmed the original faith in Christ — however, with a new force of persuasiveness for the senses: no longer only for hearing, but also for sight. So the new form did not change the dogmatic content of the faith. And if new forms of the preaching of the same faith are in principle impossible, why do the Baptists use television and the internet, use telephones and other modern technical novelties? They too were not with the apostles.

Baptist: (From the hall): May I read Galatians further? “My little children, for whom I labor in birth again until Christ is formed in you.” In you! And it is written in Colossians — “Christ in you, the hope of glory.” And let us look. Alan brought the example with the wife. When do we look at the photograph of the wife? When we are in communion with her in the kitchen or at home. Or when we are in separation from her? Most of all?

Orthodox: (Speaker): I always have it with me.

Baptist: (From the hall): It is always with you, but when do we look at her and somehow… kiss…

Orthodox: (Speaker): When in separation.

Baptist: (From the hall): When in separation. By this very thing we show that Christ is not yet formed in us. Why? Because we live with Him as it were in separation and understand He is far from us. But when…

Note that the apostle Paul writes this to the Church of Christ. “Until Christ is formed in you.” And is Christ not formed in them? Yes, at that moment not formed. Therefore, when we live by faith in the Lord, precisely then do we come into contact with the Lord — so that from everything visible, about Christ some thoughts — even when we read the word of God — so as somehow to draw the image, that Christ should begin to dwell and act in us, that He be formed in us.

Well, if one may say it in Russian: we would be… Christ would be in us, so to speak, as an icon — not an icon, that is, a depiction. Our life would become the depiction of Christ.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Can you say that about yourself?

Baptist: (From the hall): No, wait, let us. At once to personalities, yes?

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — I am simply interested… I have never seen such a man.

Baptist: (From the hall): Yes, I can say so. No, I can say so. Here is a simple example. We live with my wife, and I simply put a question to her: “Have you ever seen the manifestation of the Lord in me?” She says: “not once, but many times.”

Orthodox: (Speaker): But not always.

Baptist: (From the hall): Of course, not always. Many times she saw. I say — when in me there is the manifestation of the Lord — this… a man has positive qualities, has negative qualities, yes; this, I say, hold to, and the fleshly in me also manifests… There are also certain dissatisfactions, all. Well, I shall not say that Christ was formed in me by such dissatisfaction…

Orthodox: (Speaker): There…

Baptist: (From the hall): Yes, but now the apostle Paul teaches the church, that Christ, well, take the upper hand in us. Be formed. And when we carry the image with us and kiss it — Alan, you said everything right… That we see Him somehow differently. But when He begins to be formed in us — here one glance. It is written: pray unceasingly. We receive this nearness of the Lord. That is all. We do not need, when we see this nearness — we do not need at that moment the image.

Orthodox: (Speaker): May I ask a question? At once?

Baptist: (From the hall): Yes, yes, yes. Good.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Can you say that not you personally, but in your congregation all… always…

Orthodox priest: He spoke of himself…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Do all always see themselves (you or others) that Christ dwells in them in fullness?

Orthodox priest: Not always.

Orthodox: (Speaker): You said not always…

Orthodox priest: That is precisely why icons are needed…

Baptist: (From the hall): But His presence is always.

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — do you not get distracted from Him into vanity, do nothing?

Baptist: (From the hall): No, we get distracted. But His nearness is always 24 out of 7. When the Lord revealed Himself — He revealed Himself to me at twenty-two. He became for me living, real — that is all. From that moment it never passed that I should somehow see Him as it were afar off. He is always near.

Baptist: (From the hall): I shall continue. When this question — I speak with my son and say: son, now take my photograph, turn away from me and begin to speak. He says: what, papa? And I say: agree, it is somehow absurd. I am with you. Yes. Why do I need the photograph? I say: the same. When a man sees God within himself with spiritual eyes, he needs no other images.

Orthodox priest: Andrei, may I?

Baptist: (From the hall): Please.

Orthodox priest: Here we shall now part into different places. Well, you home, I home. And I speak with you by video link. So. And you look at me on the little screen, and I at you on the little screen. So you will address me, looking at the little screen. But if I there react to something, then, you see…

Second Baptist (from the hall): I shall come to you.

Orthodox priest: That is understandable — but looking at the little screen.

Second Baptist (from the hall): Yes.

Orthodox priest: Right?

Second Baptist (from the hall): Yes.

Orthodox priest: So also with God…

Second Baptist (from the hall): But God is omnipresent. He is precisely not in the little screen, and not in one place where we are.

Orthodox priest: In contrast with me and with you, God is an invisible Being. You also have a soul that speaks through your body — you know this. And I have a soul, but we do not see one another’s souls. But the manifestation of the soul in the body we sense. From this: when the body is near, I look at the body, and it is foolish to look at a material intermediary. But if the body is far, and I see your image on the video link — well, what hinders me from speaking to you, but looking here? So also the icon. It depicts the invisible God. Or an invisible saint. The Son of God became incarnate and ascended. We do not have Him here, standing among us. But with our souls we sense Him. Therefore we, addressing Him as to the invisible, before the material sacred things, kindle in our whole being love for Him.

Baptist: (From the hall): That you said rightly. That is us. But Christ did not command so. Herein is the point. That is us; but Christ did not command that. And this is ours. It pleased you so. I so, I so. But how far is it necessary to God?

Orthodox priest: May I ask a brief question?

Baptist: (From the hall): I always compare with Scripture.

Orthodox priest: A brief question. Very brief. Even two. We have established with Dmitri that the commandments of God must be understood rightly. Say, God commanded us to keep the sabbath day. But you, most probably, do not keep it. And why?

Baptist: (From the hall): Which sabbath?

Orthodox priest: The sabbath day. “Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy.”

Baptist: (From the hall): And what does keep mean?

Baptist: (Speaker): The day of rest was shifted…

Baptist: (From the hall): From your understanding, what is it to keep?

Orthodox priest: No — there is very much information about keeping.

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, concretely, what is it to keep?

Orthodox priest: No work whatsoever may be done on the sabbath day according to the Old Testament law — to kindle fire, to cook food, to carry wood, to carry other burdens.

Baptist: (From the hall): Where was that? In the Old Covenant?

Orthodox priest: In the Law of Moses, of course…

Baptist: (From the hall): In the Old, yes. And the whole law was fulfilled in Christ.

Orthodox priest: Where do you see the commandment that abolishes it?

Baptist: (From the hall): He does not abolish; He fulfills.

Orthodox priest: Dmitri’s report began precisely with the second commandment. Therefore I took the fourth from the same list. And I say: why not? Where do you see a direct abolishing? There is none.

You accept the teaching of the Church, which transfers the day of worship from the sabbath day to Sunday for the sake of the resurrection of Christ. And you do rightly. But is there a direct commandment such as that? There is not! Therefore… And where do you see the commandment about prayer to Christ? Show me on the line the commandment that one must pray to Christ as God.

Baptist: (From the hall): And who is Christ?

Orthodox priest: Where is the commandment about prayer to Christ as God?

Baptist: (From the hall): But He is God.

Orthodox priest: Where is the commandment about prayer to Christ as God?

Second Baptist (from the hall): “In that day you will ask in My name”… that is, from John; I shall find it now (John 16:26).

Orthodox priest: But that He said to the apostles in person.

Second Baptist (from the hall): No — He was already departing.

Baptist: (Speaker): “Hitherto you have asked nothing”…

Orthodox priest: “Ask in My name” — not Me, but in My name. And where is the commandment of prayer personally to Christ? Show it on the line.

Baptist: (From the hall): And can you show it?

Orthodox priest: It is the teaching of the Church.

Baptist: (From the hall): No — of prayer to Christ, can you show it?

Orthodox priest: It is the teaching of the Church. It is a church commandment. We trust the Church in this question. And you trust the Orthodox Church in this question. And you do rightly.

Baptist: (From the hall): You say it so interestingly: the church, as though it is some building. It is people.

Orthodox priest: The Lord gave the teaching to the Church.

Comment: Very characteristic is the reaction of the Protestants. The priest showed them two examples in which they act not according to the Bible, but according to the teaching of the Church: the keeping of Sunday instead of the sabbath day, and prayer to Jesus Christ as God. It would seem the Baptists should have agreed here with the magisterial authority of the Church. But they simply pass to another question. It is worth clarifying further: the last words of the apostle Stephen, addressed by him before death to Christ, are not a common commandment. One may consider it a private example: if you are to be stoned and before death you see Christ, it will be desirable to address Him personally. But a common commandment about prayer to Christ as God there certainly is not; it is precisely the teaching of the Church, which the Baptists accept unconditionally too.

Baptist: (From the hall): Simply here is a moment. You put a question to me. Is it always that there is… Here, look.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Voice the question again, so that all understand. “Are you always in Christ, do you not get distracted into vanity…”

Baptist: (From the hall): No — are you always conscious of nearness to the Lord?

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — differently. Do you always remember God?

Baptist: (From the hall): Of God — yes. Here I should like… Are you married?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Yes.

Baptist: (From the hall): Are there moments when you have quarreled with your wife?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Yes.

Baptist: (From the hall): Say — is communion broken?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Yes.

Baptist: (From the hall): But you live together with your wife, or do you at once go off to some flat?

Orthodox: (Speaker): No.

Baptist: (From the hall): But communion is broken; nearness there is — meaning, communion there is.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Considerably worse…

Baptist: (From the hall): But you are all the same in one flat, in one house.

Orthodox priest: What is the question?

Baptist: (From the hall): Here. And now there is such a moment. When we grieve the Lord. Communion is broken. But this consciousness of His presence is never lost. You must understand this. Because when we sin… And if the consciousness of this presence — so to speak, the communion — remained on one and the same level, then we should not understand sin.

Orthodox priest: Pavel, you have now gone aside… we say: the icon helps us to come to repentance.

Baptist: (From the hall): No — we are speaking now of nearness to the Lord, which surpasses this photograph.

Orthodox: (Speaker): So you are not always like God, but all the same somewhere in you there is something.

Baptist: (From the hall): This consciousness is always… Why? Because with any… I simply wish to bring an example. We make choices every day. With any choice always within: Lord, prompt. How? Within. How for me here?

Orthodox priest: Let us finish — each two words.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Yes, yes. Look, Pavel — straight from your words it is clear you said precisely that you sometimes do not think of the Lord. You plunge into vanity — indeed, perhaps you do not sin there and so on. Scripture says man must think of God unceasingly. “Pray unceasingly.” In the first psalm it is said that “blessed is the man who meditates on the law day and night,” and so on.

Baptist: (From the hall): Yes.

Orthodox: (Speaker): That does not come out with you.

Baptist: (From the hall): I did not say so. Alan, you lumped together…

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — why?

Orthodox priest: I propose you discuss this after our meeting.

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — in other words, if a man cannot think of God unceasingly, and the icon helps him to do that, then…

Orthodox priest: That is good.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Yes, that is good.

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, Alan, I put the question to you. Do you always carry the icon before you?

Orthodox priest: Well, no, of course.

Baptist: (From the hall): Does it constantly give you memory of God?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Very often — for example, at work, in the car.

Baptist: (From the hall): Every second of your life…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Very often I turn my attention to it.

Baptist: (From the hall): Very often, but not always…

Orthodox: (Speaker): But if it were not there, it would be considerably less…

Orthodox priest: Yes, yes — not always, not always, but only if I have seen it!

Baptist: (Speaker): The remembrance of God is never superfluous.

Orthodox priest: There it is!

Orthodox: (Speaker): So why do you not carry icons then?

Orthodox priest: Quite right.

Baptist: (Speaker): We have our own icons…

Orthodox priest: Best to notice and remember… At least through a thing… at least through an icon — Dmitri says rightly.

Orthodox: (Speaker): So no — then I have a question. Why then are there no icons?

Baptist: (From the hall): We do not forget…

Orthodox: (Speaker): You always remember?

Baptist: (From the hall): One hundred percent! The spirit is born again.

Baptist: (Speaker): Alan, there are such kinds of activity we are called to do that require of us attention. In which we cannot think of God at that moment. But only… Even Brianchaninov wrote: pray at the beginning of the work, ask blessing, and at the end give thanks. If our activity is concentrated, requires concentration. Otherwise we shall not go far.

Orthodox priest: I propose… There was a reproach from Andrei: there were iconoclast councils, and we left it unanswered. Allow me to answer briefly about this.

We shall not go deep — briefly I shall answer.

Baptist: (Speaker): Please — there is a history…

Orthodox priest: The history of the church offers us councils not only Orthodox, but also when bishops voice a heretical opinion. For example, the fourth century offers us many heretical, Arian councils. Does it mean the church so taught? No — the church rejected these councils.

In exactly the same way the two iconoclast councils of 754 and 815. Both these… Two councils. There more than 40 years [between them]. The church rejected both these councils. Church teaching — not of these heretics, but of the Church — is such as we set out: that one must worship God in spirit and Truth, without doubt, but including by means of a material sacred thing.

Meanwhile the honor rendered to a material sacred thing ascends not to it itself, not to the board with paints, but to the Prototype, depicted for the greater glory of God.

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, but look how the apostle Paul writes about those people who speak in unknown tongues. What will simple people say? Are you not raving, since there is no interpretation?

Orthodox priest: Right.

Baptist: (Speaker): So here too people without understanding of God will say: are you not committing idolatry?

Orthodox priest: You speak rightly — of this you spoke in your report, and we discussed it: that one must teach. That is precisely what we do, by the mercy of God, according to our strength.

Baptist: (From the hall): And the most interesting — why is it only Christ that you have an icon of, but you have very many other depictions of people, I mean.

Orthodox priest: Right, right.

Baptist: (Speaker): Not simple people…

Orthodox priest: Not simple — not like you and me, yes.

Baptist: (From the hall): Not simple. Not simple — those who there, I do not know by what manner, were introduced into the rank of saints, yes, let us speak so. Or you venerate them as saints — I say without pretensions, without questions to you.

Baptist: (Speaker): The prophets, the holy fathers…

Orthodox priest: Yes.

Baptist: (From the hall): Simply, well, yes. They are all quite on a level with Christ — everything. I even know by my mother-in-law that she has in principle no depiction of Christ, an icon — Matrona hangs, yes. And the priest came and did not even remind that it would be good to have Christ here too, as it were…

Orthodox priest: And do you consider it necessary?

Baptist: (From the hall): Well no — I simply say: why with you is all this on a level…

Orthodox priest: I like that you inwardly feel the necessity of an icon of Christ. You dispute with us — but inwardly you feel it.

Baptist: (From the hall): No — I have said my opinion already, why I do not need it. But I said that from myself, yes. I do not tell you that you need to cross everything out.

Orthodox: (From the hall): A little question, precisely in the context of what we are now discussing. What you said resembles what we discuss — the perfection of your congregation in relation to ours.

That is, you are already so — now I shall finish my thought — so perfect that you do not even need to look upon the depiction of Christ, upon the image of Christ, in order always to remember God.

You are more perfect; we are less perfect; and we say we need it. But in this context I wish to ask: do all of you understand the affirmation of the Seventh Ecumenical Council that the veneration of the image passes to the prototype? Is this clear to you? The very definition by itself? Or — I have such a feeling forming — that you do not fully understand what we speak of.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Yes, if clarification is required, then look…

Baptist: (From the hall): All this is described in Scripture — that the veneration…

Orthodox: (From the hall): No, no — wait. The very formulation — do you understand the meaning of this formulation? That is, when I look, I address the image; I do not address this painted thing, you understand? I address God now. Do you understand?

Baptist: (From the hall): We understand.

Orthodox: (From the hall): The same as you say — that you address God, but you do not look. You are so perfect that with you either the inward image appears, or somehow otherwise.

Baptist: (From the hall): Here is Scripture; look, how we look — so that you too understand, how it helps me to look. I open Scripture and read where Christ was crucified — if concreteness, yes. Here it is. From the reading the spiritual image rises. Herein is the meaning. I simply explain — that about this.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Do you imagine Christ at that moment? Do you imagine at that moment? How He is crucified, for example?

Baptist: (From the hall): You know who does this? The Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit opens all this.

Orthodox: (Speaker): So what is He…

Baptist: (From the hall): So there I have no need of an image. There is the understanding that Christ Himself opened.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Is there some depiction in the head?

Baptist: (From the hall): Most probably not. It has no meaning. Do you understand? Even if I imagine something there, it has no meaning.

Orthodox: (From the hall): And do you have a teaching about this — whether one may imagine or may not imagine?

Baptist: (From the hall): One may read. Here it is written to the Hebrews: “Looking unto Jesus, the author and finisher of our faith.” Looking. “…who for the joy that was set before Him endured the cross, despising the shame, and has sat down at the right hand of the throne of God. For consider Him who endured such hostility” (Hebrews 12:2–3). One may look with the eyes or one may look with thought.

Orthodox priest: So — may we, after all…

Baptist: (From the hall): One may look with thought.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: With the eyes of the heart… by faith in Christ…

Baptist: (From the hall): But with thought you do not imagine an image. You inwardly understand what Christ did for you on Golgotha. But with the eyes… an image is needed for our eyes. So — when we consider Him who endured, this is the consciousness — not a musing, but the consciousness of His presence — well, how else to say it? God is Spirit. He is not reflected in our brain through the eyes. We understand only material things are reflected. But the consciousness of His presence — it is real.

The presence of God — I do not know how to explain it. But it is the consciousness. That He is here, that He is near. And through thought we may look upon Him — what He did, how He relates to us. It is written — I read today. “Cast your care upon Him.” Here I read the word of God, and there it is written — “cast your care upon Him.” And I have cares that are on my heart. I thank You that You directed me; I knelt down. And all that was on my heart, that the cares weighed upon — I took and opened it all. And the questions resolved themselves. With the heart they resolved. But this is precisely the question — with thought you look…

Orthodox: (From the hall): It is clear to us what you say.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: No, no — let those speak who have kept silence yet. Evgeny put the question to us: where in the New Covenant is written the commandment to pray to Jesus Christ. There is no such commandment — but there are facts.

Orthodox priest: Oh — there is no commandment!

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: First Corinthians, 1:2: “Called to be saints with all who in every place call on the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, both theirs and ours” (1 Corinthians 1:2). Who call on the name of the Lord.

Orthodox priest: The invocation of the name is a complex form; it may mean different things.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Very well. A question about the iconoclast council. There you said what year — 734 or which?

Orthodox priest: Two councils. The first and the main one is the Hierian council of 754.

Baptist pastor: Nicaean?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Hierian.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor:: There presbyters were gathered…

Orthodox priest: The town of Hieria. From this the name of the council — Hierian.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: That is which year — 754?

Orthodox priest: The year 754.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: There gathered 338 heads and bishops.

Orthodox priest: Yes.

These bishops represented the true Orthodox Church — or were all the true bishops somewhere aside, and did not gather at this assembly?

Orthodox priest: I shall voice now… Look — we have a complex system of church governance. At that time we had 5 patriarchates. One of the main ones is the Constantinopolitan. And this council was within the jurisdiction of only the Constantinopolitan patriarchate. There were neither Roman bishops, nor Antiochian, nor Jerusalem — for a number of reasons it came so, for political reasons.

Correspondingly, this council was not ecumenical. Although there were many bishops there, it was a local council of one church. The other local churches did not accept this council. That is, it had not the status that the whole church should become iconoclast. The same, all the more, concerns the council of 815.

But if we take the Seventh Ecumenical Council — it was ecumenical. Either all the hierarchs gathered, or representatives of the hierarchs.

Baptist: (From the pastor): Wait — these 338 bishops, they represented, it turns out, one locality, yes?

Orthodox: (Speaker): One, yes.

Orthodox: (From the hall): One patriarchate.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Only one patriarchate, and not one patriarch was there…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: From the city of Constantinople were they?

Orthodox priest: No — from Byzantium, but within the diocese, within only one patriarchate.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Were these true Orthodox priests, or already fallen away?

Orthodox priest: They were rightly ordained — that is, they were real bishops — but professed false teaching. From this they were anathematized by the Seventh Ecumenical Council.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: And was there among them… were there only bishops there, or was there also a patriarch? Was the patriarch of Constantinople there?

Orthodox priest: No — he died shortly before this council, and the council was headless.

Orthodox: (Speaker): That is, without a patriarch…

Orthodox priest: Not one patriarch was there.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Simply — here too great a mass of bishops condemned the icons.

Orthodox priest: Yes, without doubt.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: That is, it turns out you spoke of the fact that the Orthodox church is a monolith always — there is no division within.

Orthodox priest: Yes — in the empirical church there is always sin, but this sin is overcome by the power of God. I told you of the fourth century and the Arian councils. These too were lawfully ordained bishops who taught the lie that Jesus Christ is not God. But, nevertheless, God by His power intervened, and in the end — where are they? They are not, and the church stands.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: But what if it was not God who intervened? Evgeny — what if the devil intervened through Irene, this empress? And she there — well, she strongly wished to affirm all these icons, and she brought in 150 monks into that…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Then it turns out Jesus lied…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: They should not have voted there. But she saw the majority would not be.

Orthodox priest: We believe the church is “the pillar and ground of the Truth, by the word of Christ.” Correspondingly, since we see the historical body of the Church unbroken and the teaching of the Church unbroken, we believe it is the Truth of God. Besides, there is yet another argument which you all unanimously ignored — and I am surprised. Alan testified repeatedly of wonders from icons. Are these wonders of God, or false?

Baptist: (Speaker): Such-and-such can be.

Orthodox priest: I do not dispute — but can they be of God?

Baptist: (Speaker): They can — by the infirmity of faith.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: I do not know, because I have not seen. Here is how I shall answer for myself. I have not seen it; therefore I do not know. Whether there are these wonders there at all.

Orthodox priest: May I bring an example?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: I do not know.

Orthodox priest: My wife — she among other things restores icons. And once she was given for restoration an icon with such a history.

The icon belonged to a woman who lived in the city of Sukhumi in 1993 or 1992, during the war with the Georgians. Georgian tanks were brought in and shelled the city. In particular, the house where this woman lived. A multi-storey one.

We were in Sukhumi repeatedly; I saw the traces. And this woman went out onto the balcony with this icon. Moreover, the icon — well, not a masterpiece. Well, an icon and an icon, of such simple folk writing. The Resurrection of Christ. She went out onto the balcony with this icon and stood. And tanks fired at her. And the tanks damaged the neighboring houses. They did not hit her, nor the house.

Now tell me — in your view, this woman did not simply stand holding the icon — she prayed, of course. In your view, did the Lord protect her or not?

Baptist: (Speaker): He protected — by prayer.

Orthodox priest: Right!

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: By mercy.

Orthodox priest: Right! But she meanwhile was holding the icon as a material sacred thing.

Baptist: (Speaker): But that was not necessary…

Orthodox priest: But if it is an idol — would not the Lord have shown that it is idolatry?

Baptist: (Speaker): Idolatry would have been if she had turned all her faith to that icon, and not to God.

Orthodox priest: Right! And there you voice the right faith of the Church. We direct faith to God!

Baptist: (Speaker): But this case does not show that it is necessary.

Orthodox priest: Allow me — here I have drawn a little picture; on this example it will be clearer to you what we speak of. So — why does the Lord forbid idolatry by the second commandment?

Because the idol is the final addressee of the prayer of the idolater. He asks the idol for help. Well, in worldly affairs, in health or in something else. But “an idol is nothing in the world” (1 Corinthians 8:4), says the apostle. Is it not so? He is not the Existing One; he is created by the work of human hands; even if a demon exists there, the demon too is not the true God. So, an idol is nothing. From this idolatry is false worship. What does the worship of God through icons represent? The believer, looking upon the icon, directs prayer to God — as in this example of mine, about which Dmitri said the prayer was right, because it was addressed to God, although the icon was in her hands.

God is the truly Existing One. Prayer to Him is right, even though through a material sacred thing. What is the problem? Why can we not pray to God, the Maker of heaven and earth, before a material sacred thing, to strengthen our senses, our faith, proving for our senses the reality of the incarnation of God? What is bad here?

Baptist: (From the hall): Here just is the question. How I think or how you think — that is one question. And now the question: does God think so?

Orthodox priest: Well, if God manifests wonders?

Baptist: (From the hall): One moment, one moment… You say: through the icon we pray to God. And how sure are you that God through the icon accepts your prayer?

Orthodox: (Speaker): By the answers…

Orthodox priest: If the question is put concretely, then yes, we understand…

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, that is, by wonders.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Not only, but by the answer…

Orthodox priest: Including by wonders.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Prayed through the icon — received an answer.

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, then He should have written it somewhere. Then He should write it, if it is important.

Baptist: (Speaker): Take, for example, the defense of Moscow... The essence is not in the icon, but in the fact that people prayed to God.

Orthodox priest: Right.

Baptist: (Speaker): And it is not in the icon the matter…

Orthodox priest: But do not say so. If it were not in the icon, they would not have taken it with themselves.

Baptist: (From the hall): Here — right; here I agree…

Baptist: (Speaker): God, who entered into covenant with Israel for Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, answered prayers to Israel despite the fact that they had groves and oak woods and high places, and limped on both knees, as it were spiritual. He answered all the same. I consider here it is purer if you come straight to Christ.

Orthodox priest: No, wait. Let me remind once more. With us there is no veneration of icons as idol. With us there are no icons as the true God.

Baptist: (Speaker): With you there are not — but with the people?

Orthodox priest: They must be taught. You often say to a man: the clarity of biblical teaching — and he refuses to learn. So, as for Israel: we do not limp on both knees. We set out the right church teaching.

Baptist: (From the hall): I put the question. A direct connection. Icon and God. Yes — does God accept? If He accepted and wished, He would have written it. And now, secondly — the same man, anyone, without an icon had prayed to God — would God not have answered him?

Orthodox priest: Andrei, this is not serious.

Baptist: (From the hall): Well, good — not serious; do not answer me.

Orthodox priest: I have just said it. Show me on the line a record of prayer to Christ. You said there is no such line. But we understand Jesus accepts prayer to Himself. What do you now demand of us — that we show the contrary? That if it is not written on the line, it may not be done.

Baptist: (From the hall): You yourselves agreed — that not the icon, when Dima speaks. Not the icon, but prayer to God directly. So I say: if the icon were not — I put the question. Without the icon the man would have prayed. Would God have answered?

Orthodox priest: If there be persecutions. They will cast me into prison…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Not always — we see in the Old Covenant…

Baptist: (From the hall): But why does He always answer me?

Orthodox: (Speaker): And perhaps it seems to you?

Baptist: (From the hall): Hallelujah! Perhaps it seems to you too?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Often God, on the pages of Holy Scripture, accepted prayers precisely from the righteous. They prayed, and God says: no, your prayer I shall not accept. Let, say, Job pray for you…

Orthodox priest: By the way, mediators… yes… We did not answer that question…

Orthodox: (Speaker): As for mediators, I should like to say. You said that “one is the Mediator and Intercessor”…

Baptist: (Speaker): I did not say it — the word of God did. The word of God.

Orthodox: (Speaker): What did you mean — in two words, only in two words… what did you mean.

Baptist: (Speaker): Very well. “For there is one God” — that is, one; there is no other God.

Orthodox: (Speaker): I mean the mediator…

Baptist: (Speaker): We go in sequence… One — that is, one — and the mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus…

Orthodox: (Speaker): How does this relate to the theme of icons? I simply clarify.

Baptist: (Speaker): To the theme of icons: that neither an icon nor some man is a mediator in the relations between God and man.

Orthodox: (Speaker): I ask what I asked last time. Do you have in your telephone, in WhatsApp, a prayer group?

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, of course.

Orthodox: (Speaker): So why do you ask and burden your brethren, when there is one Mediator, and you can pray straight to Christ? Why this: “I travel to the dispute in Kostroma. Pray, please, that it be smoothed with the Orthodox.”

Baptist: (From the hall): Yes — much avails the fervent prayer, it is written…

Orthodox: (Speaker): If you can communicate directly and there is one mediator — why, for example, before entering, did you all pray together?

Baptist: (From the hall): For strengthening. Much avails the fervent prayer…

Baptist: (Speaker): “Pray for one another.”

Orthodox: (Speaker): Here — the contradiction!

Baptist: (From the hall): There is no contradiction.

Orthodox: (Speaker): I ask you to be a kind of mediator between me and God.

Baptist: (From the hall): Why? No. Here is the misunderstanding! Here is the misunderstanding, where… You did not understand…

Baptist: (Speaker): I ask not as mediator — I simply ask to pray for me.

Orthodox: (Speaker): And the saint is the same man whom we ask that he pray for us to God. Not that he help of himself with his divine power, but…

Baptist: (Speaker): I understand that all are alive to God, and it is better to address…

Orthodox: (Speaker): He is not a mediator. He is one whom we ask — our intercessor in prayer; the same as you in WhatsApp. We ask a holy man. Not one who seems to himself holy, but truly holy.

Baptist: (Speaker): The same David: “shall they glorify God in the grave?” (Psalm 6:5).

Orthodox: (Speaker): That is the Old Covenant. All went down to hell.

Baptist: (Speaker): “Shall the dead inquire of the living?” (Isaiah 8:19).

Orthodox: (Speaker): You finished the seminary, Dmitri Igorevich. This is the Old Covenant. And all people went down to hell.

Baptist: (Speaker): Clear. I know what the universal Church is, the Church Triumphant…

Orthodox priest: And in the book of Revelation the prayers of the saints are lifted from the hand of the Angel to the throne of God (Revelation 8:4). Well — do you not know that… the saints are alive; their prayers are alive before God? Well, what of you… You yourselves say…

Baptist: (Speaker): The prayers are alive… Perhaps we also sit on prayer…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: There is one more text saying Jesus Christ is the only Mediator. He Himself said, “I am the Way, and the Truth, and the Life; no one comes to the Father except through Me” (John 14:6). And not only by the narrow way into everlasting life. But no one comes to the Father in prayer each day except through Christ.

Orthodox priest: Sergey, Dmitri — may I put a question to you both? Brief, exegetical? There is such a text — 2 Corinthians 5:20. I shall read. “So we are ambassadors on behalf of Christ, as though God were pleading through us; on behalf of Christ we beg: be reconciled to God.” A well-known place.

Tell me, please: does the apostle Paul act in this place as mediator between God and the believing Corinthians?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Here it is meant that Paul is not between God and the believers, but between the name of Christ and the unbelievers.

Orthodox priest: How so? “On behalf of Christ”… “God pleads through us”… We beg: be reconciled to God; we beg… That is a mediatorial function…

Baptist: (From the hall): That is God Himself…

Baptist: (Speaker): Say the place once more…

Orthodox priest: 2 Corinthians, chapter 5, verse 20.

Baptist: (From the hall): God Himself pleads… Through whom?

Orthodox priest: And as it were God Himself… Ambassadors on behalf of Christ; they beg on behalf of Christ. That is a mediatorial function.

Baptist: (From the hall): So did he pray, or what?

Orthodox: (From the hall): They set themselves as mediators.

Orthodox priest: The apostle considers himself mediator between God and men. We… “You are God’s field, you are God’s building” (1 Corinthians 3:9). But we — who? Remember?

Baptist: (Speaker): But that is human mediation, not spiritual…

Baptist: (From the hall): Acts, chapter 14.

Orthodox priest: But do we not ask for the prayers? Of the apostles? Do we not ask?

Baptist: (From the hall): Acts, chapter 14. There it is written, when they wished to lay wreaths on them… they said, “gods in the likeness of men” — what did they do?

Orthodox priest: A splendid example.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Gods…

Baptist: (From the hall): In the likeness of a man — what did he say? No — what did he say? They tore their garments. What did he say?

Orthodox: (Speaker): The father will answer… You said it yourself — gods…

Baptist: (From the hall): No — what did he say?

Orthodox priest: (From the hall): “We also are men of like nature with you” (Acts 14:15).

Baptist: (From the hall): Men like you. Understand? They wished to bring them honors. They refused. Then they go into the temple. One having the spirit of prophecy says: these are men who announce God to us. These are men who came to preach to us of God. They cast out that spirit of prophecy.

Orthodox priest: So one may not preach?…

Baptist: (From the hall): So this is the whole sense: in no way do they announce themselves, as mediators, by these things. Nowhere is it written, and altogether there is not even a thought that the apostle Paul or other apostles said: pray to Christ through us, or pray to God through us. Nowhere will you see such a thought.

Baptist: (Speaker): And I should like to add that here they are not simply as mediators, but as ambassadors on behalf of Christ.

Baptist: (From the hall): But there in the Greek it is written “ambassadors.” Clearly — “ambassadors.”

Baptist: (Speaker): Ambassadors, envoys on behalf of Christ. That is, Christ sends them.

Orthodox priest: A good question. May I then answer? The question — I shall sum up your question, then answer. So, what is the question? When they wished to bow to the apostles as pagan gods, they rejected this worship, saying: we are men of like nature with you.

Baptist: (Speaker): To offer sacrifice they wished…

Orthodox priest: To bow… Why did they do it? Because they rejected pagan worship in principle. Because both these pagans — former ones, even those fallen away from idolatry, say, Cornelius the centurion, who bowed to Peter — I remember all these places. In all these cases, since they had a pagan past or present, they set the apostles in the place of God. That is unseemly. The apostles are intercessors for us to God. They are our teachers. They are our instructors. Therefore, of course, precisely they begat us by the word of truth.

Therefore, naturally, they are mediators between me and God. I render them due veneration, as Holy Scripture requires. Is it not so? But when these wished to bring worship as to pagan gods, the apostles hindered them in this.

Baptist: (From the hall): Good. Here Dmitri read: “One God alive, and one mediator between the living God and men, the man Jesus Christ.” Between which? The living God, yes? Not an idol? Right?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Let me explain. Look — this text means precisely that only Christ is that man who was able to reconcile mankind with God. That truly is only the Lord. But this commandment does not abolish the intercession in prayer for one another. Because in other texts of Holy Scripture it is said “pray for one another,” “thereby fulfill the law of Christ…”

That is, here we speak of completely different things. And you understand this perfectly well too. I repeat — again: you daily — Sergey Antonovich said you gathered there almost every day — asked one another for prayer, opened your heart before the congregation, and prayed together for one another. The same takes place in our case. We ask not only our living brothers and sisters, but also those asleep, who are, without doubt, alive to God.

Baptist: (Speaker): That is the theme of the next meeting, probably.

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — quietly. I beg forgiveness. Proceeding from Holy Scripture we know they know what takes place in the world and pray. As the martyrs in the book of Revelation did, for example. We know the martyrs who were slain knew perfectly well what takes place on earth and prayed to God. Naturally, if they pray for vengeance on the impious, it goes without saying they pray also for the salvation of us all.

Baptist: (From the hall): Not for vengeance… of what it was said. One must not tear the text out of Scripture.

Orthodox: (Speaker): What was said? Bear with me a little more…

Baptist: (From the hall): Calm yourselves. They prayed not for…

Orthodox: (Speaker): God said “do not pray”… He said: bear with…

Baptist: (From the hall): Until you render… Yes. You do not render… And what did he say? Calm yourselves… But in no way did they guide in prayer…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Did they pray? Who guides, then? Holy Nicholas the Wonderworker does not guide in life, but prays God about me… Prays. The same as you pray for a brother.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: May there be one more question, and then Nikolai Nikolaevich must be given the word. Look — you said Jesus Christ is the icon of God, and we made an icon of Jesus Christ. In order to look upon the icon, to pray to Jesus Christ. I agree that one may and must pray to Jesus Christ, because He is God.

Orthodox priest: Excellent.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: So. And if I carry this photograph of my wife and even kiss it, all will be right. But why with you is there not only the icon of Jesus Christ? But the icon of the Virgin Mary, the icon of Nicholas the Wonderworker, the icon of Matrona and others. And you venerate these icons too — so it turns out with you there is betrayal of Christ. You carry in your pocket ten photographs of various women. And look: this is my wife. Because I am in covenant only with Christ, yes? Not in covenant with the Virgin Mary or with anyone else. And you take it out. Ah — today I shall pray to the Virgin Mary, yes? Through this icon I shall pray. So. But that is wrong.

Orthodox priest: I… Now Alan will answer your question. But I think Dmitri put the question very rightly, such a general one. It would be good, then, to devote the speech to prayers, to the teaching on the veneration of saints in the Orthodox church. The Mother of God too may be included. Alan, please.

Orthodox: (Speaker): The answer to this question I had in the report: that the icon helps us to keep the commandment “remember your instructors, whose faith follow” (Hebrews 13:7). That is, we see our instructors — take Nicholas the Wonderworker. We see that this man realized the gospel commandments in his life. And we address him. We look at him.

Orthodox priest: And he is a friend of God.

Baptist: (From the hall): But how will he help?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: You are in covenant only with Christ?

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — look, as for photographs. I do not carry this icon and identify it with the icon of Christ. Christ is God. But Nicholas the Wonderworker is a friend of God.

Baptist: (From the hall): But how can he help you? That I do not understand.

Orthodox: (Speaker): And can your prayer help a brother?

Baptist: (From the hall): I address God… God will help — through prayer to God. But not Nicholas.

Orthodox priest: I did not quite understand the question. You reproach us…

Baptist: (From the hall): We do not reproach…

Orthodox priest: … that if we ask the saints to pray to God, we betray God. But if you ask your living fellow-believers to pray about you to God, and pray yourselves too — do you betray God by this or not?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: But we do not make images of these believing people…

Orthodox: (Speaker): But you telephone…

Baptist: (From the hall): We meet so and pray.

Orthodox priest: We do not pray to a board with paints, to paper with paints… Here is the icon of the Virgin Mary — but we pray to Her…

Baptist: (From the hall): Let me answer this question. It is written: “If two of you agree on earth concerning anything that they ask, it will be done for them” (Matthew 18:19). Right? We can agree. Can you agree with Nicholas the Saint — come to agreement?

Another Baptist (from the hall): How does he answer you?

Orthodox priest: I shall answer… You have no right to pray as seven. Two or three. But you are seven. You violate the law…

Baptist: (Speaker): That is a figurative expression.

Baptist: (From the hall): You have violated more. Evgeny, you have violated more. Nicholas after all answered you nothing.

Orthodox priest: How — answered nothing? What are you saying!

Orthodox: (From the hall): Many times!

Baptist: (From the hall): But how does he speak to you?

Orthodox priest: How many wonders are connected with him!

Baptist: (From the hall): What am I saying? I simply worked with your… How shall one say it? A parishioner, or how — she sings in the choir? She: “Nicholas, help, Nicholas, help!” I say: how can he help? God helps, after all.

Orthodox priest: Let me tell a story…

Baptist: (From the hall): But you say only veneration — and it turns out already petition.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Asks to pray for her…

Baptist: (From the hall): That is just it — they ask differently there.

Orthodox: (Speaker): I have said three times now that we ask him to pray about me.

Baptist: (From the hall): That is what you said. Another says differently. A thousand people, and they all said differently. That is the teaching. And the reality is different.

Orthodox priest: Andrei, may I say? I shall tell a story, when a man did not pray to Nicholas but simply received help from him. I know the story at second hand — from the lips of the priest who received this man who survived. May I tell? So, the story is such. A man drove on the highway somewhere in the region of the city of Rostov Veliky, many years ago. And his car skidded. He was driving fast in his car, did not manage the steering, and it threw him — and he flies.

He flies toward a tree and must crash into that tree. And he sees in the region of the tree into which he flies there stands a man, a little old man… And somehow it happened miraculously — completely incredibly — he, instead of the tree into which he flew, flies out into the snowdrift which is on the other side. Even so that the car remained whole. He climbed out of the car; they pulled him out; and he drives to that city of Rostov Veliky, and looks — there crosses, a temple; he drove in there.

He enters there — into the church in the monastery — and looks: the very first icon standing there is that very little old man who was on the path of his flight.

Baptist: (From the pastor): Well, that…

Orthodox priest: I did not finish the thought. The icon was of Nicholas the Wonderworker. About him was the question. So — he understands what is what; well, he bought a candle, set it — understandable — but understands that something greater is needed to God, and to Nicholas the Wonderworker himself. And after this he changed his life. He became a Christian; he began to go to church, confess, commune; radically changed his habits, removed sin from his life; afterwards, after a certain time, it turned out he was ill with cancer. He accepted this illness humbly and lived the remainder of his days as a Christian, and so died.

Tell me, please: Nicholas the Wonderworker who, in his opinion, appeared — he saw him firmly, and he must have perished. Did this saint appear to him just so, or was it a hallucination, or did God through Nicholas call him to salvation?

Baptist: (From the hall): That one must be asked.

Orthodox priest: He has already died…

Baptist: (From the hall): But you address him all the same; perhaps he will answer you…

Orthodox priest: But he considered, without doubt, that Nicholas the Wonderworker was there precisely; he did not know his icon; he was a completely unchurched man. He appeared to him precisely, and saved him, so that he should change — which happened.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Here I consider this mysticism — it resembles more the manifestation of demons than of the Holy Spirit.

Orthodox priest: So the man lived in gross sins for that, and that is good.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: God does not send these saints; if it is needed, He sends Angels.

Baptist: (From the hall): But the change must be by the fruits.

Orthodox: (From the hall): But Samuel to Saul…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Did He not send Philip to Gaza to the eunuch? Miraculously?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: But they were alive, were they not? Those same dead. Nicholas the Wonderworker died long ago.

Orthodox: (Speaker): But he is alive.

Orthodox priest: But are not all alive to God, do you consider?

Baptist: (From the hall): But who is all this?

Orthodox priest: All this is all of it.

Baptist: (From the hall): So it turns out, in your opinion, generally any man who dies — he is alive to God.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Well, naturally. The Bible speaks of this.

Orthodox: (From the hall): And you consider — no?

Baptist: (From the hall): But as it is written of eternity — some shall die, and others…

Orthodox: (Speaker): There will be… there will be…

Orthodox priest: Do you believe in the annihilation of sinners?

Baptist: (From the hall): And now it turns out sinners too are with God…

Orthodox priest: They exist — but not with God; they are in hell. As in the parable of the rich man and Lazarus… The rich man is in hell. He exists, but he is in hell.

Baptist: (From the hall): Clear — I understood then. We misunderstand in different questions. You understand so, and we simply differently.

Orthodox: (Speaker): Now, concerning temptation, I wished to say.

Baptist: (From the hall): But what of the dead being far off? They were alive, but they are dead. For God they are dead. Herein is the difference.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Evgeny — I do not believe that Nicholas the Saint, or the Wonderworker, or other saints have now in heaven such bodies as they lived in on earth.

Orthodox priest: They have no bodies.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: If they have no bodies, they cannot appear to people in material image. And if they appear — it is demons. Because these are spiritual beings, invisible to man.

Orthodox priest: Do angels have material bodies?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Angels have spiritual bodies.

Orthodox priest: Do angels have material bodies?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: I do not know; I have not seen them.

Orthodox priest: Without doubt not — these are spiritual beings. Angels are pure spirits. The apostle Paul writes of this in the Epistle to the Hebrews. So, they are pure spirits. Minds, fire — a mind flaming. They have no physical bodies, but appear to men, taking the likeness of a man, so that it be more convenient for us to see them and converse with them. So the saints also appear, taking an outward form — but appearing in spiritual bodies.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Of the saints nowhere is anything written. Of angels much is written in the Bible. Of the saints, that they take a form — well, if only Samuel there, if one recalls Samuel by the Old Covenant — and even that many interpreters of our Protestant direction consider it was not Samuel, but a demon that appeared.

Baptist: (Speaker): Having taken a form…

Orthodox (from the hall): Why then can a demon take a form?

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, of that the Orthodox presbyter wrote too…

Orthodox (from the hall): Does he have a body, then? Does the demon have a body?… That is a fallen angel…

Baptist: (From the hall): My good ones… You know we have gone far. We begin already of demons, and all… This altogether must be removed from the agenda of conversations.

Baptist: (Speaker): But who strengthened Christ in Gethsemane — who appeared?

Orthodox: (Speaker): Let us of the angels later. Let us, properly, on the report. One question. We ask you; then from your side. The question — rather, the answer. In the report of Dmitri Igorevich it sounded repeatedly that icons are a temptation for people, that people are not taught — allegedly for that reason icons are, properly, not needed. Do I understand you rightly?

Baptist: (Speaker): Not exactly rightly. It is considered…

Orthodox: (Speaker): At least three times I heard it.

Baptist: (Speaker): Not that… I read the position of the doctrine.

Orthodox: (Speaker): No — I ask you directly. Yes or no? Do you consider this cause a justified argument against icons?

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, in some degree, of course, it is a temptation. More fog among people about spiritual worship. Here the Evangelical Christians — they perceive…

Orthodox: (Speaker): Well, look — let us, by the word of God…

Baptist: (Speaker): …the veneration of images. The veneration of images, or else… Veneration, but not spiritual worship. Here I shall say to you yet a little more. The Lord wishes to be the only object of worship in the prayer ministry. God does not desire that people worship the creation instead of rendering all glory to the Creator.

Without rejecting the aesthetic, artistic, Christian value of painting, we find no justification for the censing, the kissing… Well, the kissing… all right, if you love it — the lighting of candles, the prayer before them, established in honor of feasts. An untenable assertion of the psychological necessity of an image for prayer. The possibility of praying to God without recourse to the help of images is proved both by the experience of the early Christians and by modern Evangelical believers.

With spiritual eyes the psalmist David beheld the image of God. There are no grounds for a special prayerful veneration of icons, crosses, any images — since such practice is not commanded in Holy Scripture.

Orthodox priest: Excellent. Here we read in the book of Revelation that God must be venerated — including with censing. But the Baptist tradition rejects censing. Does it not seem to you a gross contradiction of the word of God, of the Old Testament commandment and the practice of the ancient Church?

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, I do not know… Look — there was temple worship; you continue, as it were, the temple… But when the temple…

Orthodox priest: Do you have a temple?

Baptist: (Speaker): Here. With us it is synagogue-like…

Orthodox priest: Right. I am glad you understand. With you a synagogue; with us a temple. The temple grants man the full sacred ministration. The synagogue teaches. A Sunday school, in fact.

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, there prayers also sounded, and all the rest.

Orthodox priest: Yes…

Baptist: (Speaker): And what did Christ say in John, chapter four — that “true worshipers will worship in spirit and truth” (John 4:23)?

Orthodox priest: And where did the apostles go?

Baptist: (Speaker): The temple was not yet destroyed…

Baptist: (From the hall): “In every place.”

Orthodox priest: Quite right.

Baptist: (Speaker): I agree.

Orthodox priest: But they worshiped in places — look — specially built temples, altars.

Baptist: (Speaker): Well, of course, it is more pleasant to pray where it has already been sanctified…

Orthodox priest: With altars!

Baptist: (Speaker): With altars. Here another whole theme arises — and antimensionals, and all the rest.

Orthodox: (Speaker): As for temptations — they simply did not let me finish. Literally two words, and that is all. That this in reality is in no way an argument, because even from the word of God we know — not even the veneration of icons, but the very preaching of Christ is a temptation for the Jews. But that does not mean we must now cease to preach of Christ.

The teaching of the Church on the Trinity is an incredible temptation for Muslims. But that does not mean we must not try to convert them. Moreover, the teaching — the commandment that when you are struck on the right cheek, you must offer the left… For my father — for my father such a temptation, that he simply cannot overcome this abyss, to become a Christian. He is already ready to accept this, and this. But this commandment… this pride — it simply does not let him… For him it is the greatest temptation. But that does not mean I must open the Gospel of Matthew, chapter 5, and tear out this commandment and say: all right, it tempts certain people. No — the Church keeps Divine revelation in its full volume from the day of creation now and forever. And because of human infirmity — better to say, the slanders of demons — she, of course, does not intend to cut off the truth of Divine teaching. Because if we begin to cut off something, then with time we shall come to that the full will be cut off…

Orthodox priest: Every heresy is the cutting off of a part of the teaching…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: One may continue this theme every other time, when we again come to you.

Orthodox: (Speaker): As you wish — we agreed…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: We did not speak of the holy relics — how a dead man, contact with whom defiles a man in the Old Covenant — where was that abolished, or is it somehow otherwise said in the Gospel? How does contact with these relics work, and the relics sanctify a whole church? Without relics this altar and this church in general has no significance, in your understanding.

Orthodox priest: Well, not quite so…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Well — therefore, on the contrary, all these relics defile both the church and the man who touches, and the man even kisses these relics… That is a very serious theme — perhaps every other time, because today we have no time.

Orthodox priest: Yes, yes… Do you propose for next time the veneration of saints and relics?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Not next time, but every other time. When you come to us, we propose — we agreed so. And afterwards we shall return to this theme.

Orthodox priest: And next time — what?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: But next time we have not yet discussed…

Baptist: (From the hall): Nikolai Nikolaevich wished to say something…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: But if today St. Nicholas says nothing to us in conclusion…

Baptist: (From the hall): Then we brought a living Nicholas…

Another Baptist (from the hall): Dear ones, I should like to return you to the beginning, from which we began… Well, about icons, about images, about frescoes. Tell me, please — who painted them? Believing people or unbelieving?

All: — Believing.

Baptist: (From the hall): Believing. On the basis of what did they paint?

Orthodox priest: On the basis of Tradition and the word of God.

Baptist: (From the hall): So — on the basis of the word of God. Therefore the Lord also says in the first chapter of the Gospel of John: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. All things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made that was made.” Behold — people learned of Christ and decided to paint.

Now they will give you a brush and paints — you are believers; can you paint? Probably not.

Orthodox priest: I cannot; it will not come out…

Baptist: (From the hall): But even if you are capable, you will put into it everything the Lord put into your heart.

Orthodox priest: Yes.

Baptist: (From the hall): Here. Therefore all these images bear upon themselves the imprint of the spiritual experience of the one who painted. He put in his soul, so to speak. Therefore, naturally, in this image something such is contained. But what? That is a mystery. Not all is clear to us.

I shall simply tell an example. I was once, even before I believed, in the Hermitage. And looked at these pictures — there so many on spiritual themes, those divine pictures of the greatest artists. And when I read the Bible, learned, I afterwards thought — oh, how I even looked at them at all. I understood everything — all that they wished to depict there. But the Lord for a long time did not give me the possibility to be there.

When I read the Bible, studied everything, I came and began to look. And what do you think? When I came out, I thought — why am I not in rapture? Because God opened more than the artist put into this picture. When we read the word, it is far more many-sided than that image. Understand this. Well, if, of course, the icon inspires — glory to God even for that. But if you touch the Word, it is inexhaustible. How many years you read — ten times, twenty, forty times — and each day something new opens. That is God. He does not change — but we become others.

Therefore here is such a strange dialogue. On the one hand — we all grew up in Russia, after all. The culture. Our country — you enter a church, such beauty, such reverence. And who did this? People who treated Holy Scripture with reverence, pondered the Bible. In this church — I, when I was there, long ago, of course — you enter, and the whole Bible is painted on the walls.

I walk — ah, everything is clear to me; I rejoice — while to many nothing is clear. So. From this one must draw the conclusion. How shall we go deeper into Scripture or not? Necessarily one must. And Jesus Christ. Well, of course, the artist painted. We venerate. Naturally — to whom what draws, who knows what. The saints — here is the iconostasis. I do not know half what is depicted there. How can I learn? It is unclear to me. And what I know is dear to me. Therefore, “search the Scriptures, through them you hope (what did the Lord say?) to have everlasting life; they testify of me.” Here, dear ones.

Glory to the Lord that this conversation took place — that although not in our knowledge of the Scriptures to such a point, something spiritual the Lord put into us. That is important. Thank you.

Comment: So it happened that the last word was spoken by the aged Baptist pastor, and all listened to him without interrupting, rendering due respect to his age. He spoke from his worldly wisdom and his understanding of Scripture, did not revile the Orthodox Church and that veneration which in her is rendered to God through icons. He even showed clearly that through icons believers are moved to recall God more often and to pray to Him. Perhaps such an attitude toward icons may become for the Baptists the foundation for deeper reflections on it, and then for the understanding that God accepts such worship and even desires it, showing this in the history of the Church.

88
منتشر شده توسط کاربر: Rodion Vlasov
تاریخ ایجاد صفحه: 2024-06-10, به‌روزرسانی: 2026-11-17