Priest Evgeny Veselov

The Sacrament of Baptism — Dispute between Orthodox Christians and Baptists

Kostroma, 08.09.2023

(Kostroma, 08.09.2023)

Participants in the dispute:

On the Orthodox side — Priest Evgeny Veselov, Priest Dimitry Trifonov, Alan Bedoev (speaker), and others.

On the Baptist side — Pastor Sergei Antonovich Didovets (speaker) and others.

*For ease of reading, the text has undergone minimal literary editing. The comments are by Priest Evgeny Veselov.

Audio version of the dispute: https://rutube.ru/video/4c7107fe721e9ec0d84a7b3a3a868744/

Report of the Baptist side (Pastor Sergei Antonovich Didovets)

So — our theme today is Baptism. I shall read the Gospel of Matthew. I think a text known to you. I have known it by heart since I was about sixteen, probably. Chapter 28, verses 18–20. “And Jesus came and spoke to them, saying: All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth. Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age.” (Matthew 28:18–20)

First, I should like to remind what the very word “baptism” means. In the Greek language — you know the Gospel was written in Greek — where we have the word “baptism” or “to baptize,” in the Greek the word “baptizo” is used. The English word is similar — “baptize” — and in translation it means “immersion.” This word is not foreign even to secular people; they say, for example, this man received a baptism of battle. It means he plunged into the thick of battle. There is a baptism of fire, a baptism of sufferings, a baptism of the Holy Spirit — and among them a baptism of water.

When Christ spoke to the disciples these words, He, of course, had in view water baptism. That baptism with which He was baptized, when He was thirty years old, by John the Baptist, and that baptism which the apostles afterwards practiced in the life of Christ, and all the more after the receiving of the Holy Spirit, when they had already gone out into the whole Roman Empire — they baptized with water.

And this baptism, of course, has a very deep meaning. Is it important to be baptized? People ask today — even our people who go to church; some say: well, I already read the Bible, I pray, I believe — and you call: come on, do the next step, be baptized. I shall go to church, but with baptism I shall wait a while. Put it off a year, or perhaps two more. And we say to these people: it is, of course, not bad that you are thus slow with baptism, but do not forget — baptism is not a human invention, it is not an initiative on the part of man; it is the commandment of Jesus Christ. And not only in this Gospel — it is written also in the Gospel of Mark, this text we shall read somewhat later: Christ commanded the apostles that the apostles baptize people.

And since baptism is the commandment of Jesus Christ, therefore a man who does not wish to be baptized is consciously ready to violate what the Teacher bequeathed. And the man calls himself a Christian — that is, a disciple or follower of Jesus Christ — and at the same time says: I shall not do what my Teacher tells me. That must not be. Therefore, probably, you and we call people that they must be baptized; they must not baptize themselves — someone else must baptize them; of this too we shall speak a little later.

What must precede baptism? There are in the Gospel certain concrete texts which say that not every person may be baptized. One must first prepare a man. Of course, we believe the best instructor who prepares a man for baptism is the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit will guide into all truth; the Holy Spirit will convince a man; the Holy Spirit will bring to repentance — but He does it through other believers, through His church, which is His body. Therefore, not only the Holy Spirit, but we believers also must instruct one another.

And so, what must precede baptism? Whom do we baptize in our church, and whom do we not baptize? If a man has come twice to the service, listened a little, prayed somehow, and says: “such a good society here, I wish to join you.” And we say: “you will become a member of our society only after baptism.” Because in the Acts of the Apostles it is written: “then those who gladly received his word were baptized; and that day about three thousand souls were added” (Acts 2:41) — that is, it says directly there that joining to the church takes place by means of holy water baptism. And we likewise explain: you will become one of us, a member of our church, only after baptism. “I am ready to be baptized,” they say, “like the eunuch of old — “See, here is water; what hinders me from being baptized?” (Acts 8:36). And we explain to these people: you must be ready to do it.

There are three moments to which I should like to draw attention.

First: a man must be taught. This text we have already read with you. “Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations” (Matthew 28:19). And then baptize. How can one baptize a man if he does not even know what baptism is, what will happen to him at that moment? Therefore one must first teach him. And teach what? Not certain dogmas or decrees of our church — and all the more not some false religion — but teach what God says. What Jesus Christ brought to us. If we are Christians, we must teach this man the Gospel — that is, the teaching of Jesus Christ — convey the truth to him.

And these people must receive the word of God. Well, as I have already quoted that text from chapter 2 of the Acts of the Apostles. “Then those who gladly received His word were baptized” (Acts 2:41). A man must hear the word of God — and for this one must go and preach. For this God sends preachers. “How shall they believe if they have not heard? How shall they hear without a preacher?” (Romans 10:14) The Epistle to the Romans, chapter 10 — you know this. Therefore one must teach the man. And it is not necessary to teach him the whole Bible, but to teach the most important thing. Precisely the question of the salvation of his own soul. The question of living relations with God. That is, we teach the man not beginning from Genesis, from the creation of the world, but we teach from the New Covenant; we tell of Christ.

As Paul says: I went through the whole Roman Empire, came to you in Corinth, and “determined not to know anything among you except Jesus Christ and Him crucified” (1 Corinthians 2:2). First of all, one must convey to every man Christ crucified. That is the core of the Gospel and of the whole Bible; that is one hundred percent truth.

If a man understands that Christ, dying on the cross, is his personal Savior, and lays his hope on Him with all his heart, that is already enough for the Holy Spirit to begin to act in this heart, for faith to be conceived, for the man to become from an unbeliever a believer.

Therefore, if we have taught him that Christ is his Savior, that he believe in the sacrifice of Christ — and that he needs not only to believe, but also to repent, and then tell a little more about baptism — that is the first thing the man must be taught.

Second: There must be a response on the part of this man. That is, will the heart be closed or open? If the heart of a man is closed, then there is no faith. In my understanding, what is faith? Faith is the doors of the heart. Well, the spiritual heart, of course — you understand; the heart is all spiritual life. And there, of course, there are doors. These doors may be closed, may be open. Christ says: I stand and knock at these doors (Revelation 3:20). Yes? Those people who open the doors of their heart — that means they begin to believe in Jesus Christ, to agree with Him.

Therefore faith is the opening of the doors of our heart for the Lord. But I think you know from your life, have seen such people who at first, listening, accept nothing, do not agree. Then they begin to absorb something into themselves, to agree with something. And further, after a certain time, they already wish to listen to all that is said to them, and themselves begin to read the Bible, and accept every word written in the Bible as the word of God. When a man agrees with every word written in the Bible, and says: “this is God speaking to me” — then this man already has serious faith. It is written that “faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God” (Romans 10:17).

Therefore the man must make a response to that truth which he heard. He must believe. And this is the second moment. The first — the man must be taught. The second — he must believe in Jesus Christ, or accept by faith that truth which he heard. And of this Christ says: “Go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature. He who believes and is baptized will be saved” (Mark 16:15–16).

Whoever will believe! When the eunuch asked Philip — and Philip told him, probably, not only of the sacrifice of Christ, but of baptism — the eunuch said: “See, here is water; what hinders me from being baptized?” (Acts 8:36) — there was one condition: Philip answered: “If you believe with all your heart, you may” (Acts 8:37). And if you do not believe with all your heart? We say here: “then you may not.” I do not know how it is with you, but one follows from the other. If you believe with all your heart that Jesus is that Messiah of whom Isaiah spoke in chapter 53… And they probably examined this chapter in detail, and Philip clearly showed to this eunuch that you must rely on the sacrifice of Christ. So — if you believe with all your heart, you may. Therefore we do not baptize people who say they know the Gospel, the Bible, but doubt, for example, the Divinity of Christ. Rejecting one of the most important doctrines concerning the Holy Trinity, or especially Jesus Christ — we do not baptize such people. We do not baptize people who believe in the Holy Trinity, acknowledge the inspiration of Scripture, but do not believe Christ died personally for them. They say: oh, Christ died for all. It is good that He died for all — but that Christ died for you personally — do you believe that or not?

Comment: The Baptists cannot in any way understand that Christ died for the Church, because He is the Bridegroom of the Church: “Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself for her” (Ephesians 5:25). “Christ is head of the Church; and He is the Savior of the body” (Ephesians 5:23). Nowhere in the Bible is there a call to believe that Christ died personally for me. Therefore people are saved not individually, but only as part of the Church: “And the Lord added to the Church daily those being saved” (Acts 2:47). Therefore their reproach to the Orthodox — that allegedly we are people not born again — is a reproach addressed to another, unchurchly reading of the Bible. It is a reproach to the fact that we have not that unchurchly spirit of individualism which they have. In the final count it is a reproach to the fact that we are under the Head Christ, while they are free; they are outside this Head — but each by himself. Herein is the tragedy of Baptism and of Protestantism altogether.

If a man says: “I doubt it; I do not know — what did He think of me 2000 years ago, when I was not yet in the embryo,” and so on… He thought of you — thus we explain. Because David also spoke of it, that all is predestined with God. Therefore we baptize the man who says: I believe personally that God is my Father, and Jesus Christ my Savior. And I have no doubts whatsoever. That is the second moment.

And the third moment which must precede baptism is repentance. He heard, believed — that is, opened the doors of his heart, let the truth in here, that it should act here. And then the response must be. Well, truth already acts there; the light of God, the Holy Spirit acts — but there still remain the sins which you have accumulated in life, yes? They lie on your conscience as a heavy weight. They defile you, burden your life. What must be done with sins? And the man understands that Christ already took my sins upon Himself; He crucified them on the cross. And not only the sins — He crucified me, my old man. That is an accomplished fact; but that this objective truth become subjective in your life, what must you do? You must confess your sin. Repentance is a confession; it is, of course, a change of mind, a turn of 180 degrees — all this we understand — but one must also pray, yes?

Take that sin — what does the word “confess” mean? It means to tell from within. You took that sin which you long kept, loved, cherished — and now it has become loathsome to you, and you must vomit it out of yourself. As a man receives a poisoning of the organism from bad food, and the man understands that now this sin is like that poisoning within me — I must take it all and confess it, that is, give it to the Lord. “If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness” (1 John 1:9). This repentance, this change of mind, the decision to come out of darkness, to come to God — it is completed by the prayer of repentance. That is, precisely by the confession of all sins. When the man has done these three things — the man has heard the truth, the man has believed this truth, the man has repented — then one may say the same that Philip said to the eunuch — “if you believe with all your heart, you may be baptized” (Acts 8:37).

But what meaning does baptism have — what is the significance of baptism? We have spoken a little of the very word already; now let us speak of the significance. When I was preparing for this meeting today, I thought at first to tell you what baptism is not, in our understanding, in the Baptist… But I think that would be long — that baptism is not a protection from demons, not a protection from accidents, and so on… That it is not a washing of sins — well, because it is written: “not the putting off of the filth of the flesh” (1 Peter 3:21) — but I decided so: I shall tell what baptism means, as I understand it by the Gospel, and afterwards we shall draw the conclusion. I draw the conclusion that all the rest is not baptism.

Baptism has two meanings. The first is “the answer of a good conscience toward God” (1 Peter 3:21) — more simply, we call it covenant with God, or covenant with Christ. In the Old Covenant the Israelites concluded covenant by means of Moses and those commandments which Moses brought from the mountain; and in the New Covenant Christ Himself — that is, the Son of God, who is greater than Moses — came to earth. For that God sent His Son, that through Him He might conclude the New Covenant with men. You know the second part of the Bible is so named. The first — the Old Covenant — is with the Israelites; and the second part is the New Covenant — that is, with all who believe in Jesus Christ. Through Christ we can conclude this covenant with God.

So — baptism is the concluding of covenant with God or with Christ. To say it more simply — it is a wedding. When I prepare people for baptism, I explain to them necessarily and say: behold, two people have made acquaintance and for a certain time meet. They are not husband and wife; they wish to be together. And they may even commit adultery and sleep in one bed; but if they have not gone to the registry office and registered, they are to one another no one. They are simply adulterers. Even our state does not recognize civil marriages, all the more the Church. Therefore one must legalize one’s relations necessarily. And when you go to the registry office — and if these are Christians, then after the registry office they also go to church for the crowning, or as we call it, the joining in marriage — it turns out a double promise. Once in the registry office they promise faithfulness to one another, and afterwards these promises they confirm with signature. And then they go to the church, and here we, the pastors, when we give instruction, afterwards put the question: do you promise — addressing the husband — to fulfill your duties, to be faithful to your wife to the end. And afterwards we address her: do you promise? And when they say it solemnly, they as it were put signatures. There on paper — and here spiritual signatures in the church. And then, from that moment, we acknowledge and declare that these two have become one flesh; they are husband and wife.

So Christ came in order not only to be betrothed with us, but in the end also to sign the register. And I even understand it thus: this betrothal and this signing take place on earth. The joining in marriage has already taken place, while in heaven, in Revelation — there in chapter 21 it is written — there will only be the wedding feast.

How does a wedding pass, for example, with us? First the spiritual part: the instruction of the pastor; then prayers — all pray; first the bridegroom and bride, then the minister lays hands on them, prays, blesses. Then a break — they will go, be photographed — and then they gather, and we conduct it right here: we set the tables; everything here is set with tables; and here we hold the wedding feast. Congratulations, instructions, wishes there, money — who gives, and so on. So I understand that already now people enter into relations with Christ, into this covenant; not only is the betrothal announced, but they sign here too. And this signing on the part of man takes place at the moment of baptism, while in heaven the wedding feast will simply take place.

Therefore, for the contract to have force, it must be signed from both sides. On His side Jesus Christ, wishing to have such close relations with us, signed this contract with His own blood. And of this it is written in three Gospels. When Christ took the cup after supper, blessed it and said: take — this cup is the new covenant in My blood. In my understanding He both confirmed it and said that this new covenant is signed with My blood. I am now going to Golgotha to die for you; I shall shed My blood, and with this blood I sign that I wish to be in relations with you. And man, on his side, not even at the moment of repentance, but at the moment of baptism, promises faithfulness to the Lord, promises a good conscience. But a good conscience does not mean he promises to be perfect and never to sin — but not to accumulate sins.

Of the promise to God of a good conscience the apostle Peter writes (1 Peter 3:21): “There is also an antitype which now saves us — baptism (not the removal of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God), through the resurrection of Jesus Christ.” Thus briefly explained, as I understand what baptism is — it is the concluding of covenant with Christ, the signing on the part of man.

And the second meaning — in the Epistle to the Romans, in the sixth chapter, from the first to the sixth verse, there is said of death with Christ, of resurrection with Christ, and there is verse four. It is written thus: “Therefore we were buried with Him through baptism into death” (Romans 6:4). That is, baptism is the burial of the old life. It is not at this moment that a man dies for the old life, for sin, for himself, for Satan. And not at this moment does he rise. That takes place at repentance, when a man is born again. But at the moment of baptism he buries the old life.

Well, there is a great difference between death and burial, yes? A man died in a car; but they bury him already at the cemetery. Usually from death to burial there pass two-three days. Why do they not delay longer? Because the body begins to decompose. Why do they not bury sooner (although some bury sooner — for example, the Muslims: if a man died in the morning, they must bury him by evening).

But for us, that there be the possibility to prepare, to notify people, to conduct the burial worthily, some time is needed — two-three days. Death comes earlier, and the burial somewhat later. So — baptism is not the death of the old life and the resurrection for the new; baptism is burial. And we understand it literally so. Baptism is immersion in water. If it is water baptism. Therefore we go to the river or set up a basin, and the man must be buried. We bury him once. Unfortunately, even in our brotherhood there are such free-thinking — probably believers — who introduce not so much sins as certain novelties. And they baptize a man three times.

We usually conduct baptism on the Kostromka [river]. And this year, unfortunately, we had no baptisms. But next year we have several souls who this year did not decide to be baptized, and I think we shall, probably, invite you, so that you may see how it all takes place. Roughly as John baptized Jesus Christ. That is, we enter the river and baptize with full immersion. Because otherwise this word loses its meaning. If we do not immerse him in water, we have not baptized him.

If you sprinkled, then, in my understanding, you have not baptized him, but sprinkled. And immersion means the man must be buried. Do we, when we bury, merely sprinkle earth on top? But we lower him into the grave, to a meter eighty. Somewhere in sands, perhaps, a meter twenty is enough. We have such a practice. And some, it happens, baptize, dip once — in the name of the Father — and lift. Because Christ said one must baptize into the Holy Trinity — in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Then they say — in the name of the Son — and again dip, lift. And in the name of the Holy Spirit. We do not baptize so. Why? Because a man must not be buried three times. I have never seen that a coffin was lowered into the grave, lifted, then lowered again — and three times so done. Well, perhaps somewhere among other peoples it exists. Therefore once a man must be buried — completely hidden under the water, lifted — and by this we have already demonstrated that we have buried this man. The old one died; here he was buried; now he is a new man, living for Christ. That is all.

And the last thought. Baptism is not a means of the new birth. That time when we spoke of the new birth, we did not have enough time. John, chapter 3 — the conversation of Christ with Nicodemus: “Unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God” (John 3:5). There are rules of hermeneutics, rules of the interpretation of any text — not only the Bible, but any secular text — which are not invented by men. They are established by God, and by men simply discovered, as many laws are discovered. And therefore hermeneutics may be applied to any text. So, one of the rules of hermeneutics says: one must not build a doctrine or dogma, all the more theology, on a single text in the Bible. If there is only one text, that is not enough.

So — already in the Old Covenant it is said that by the testimony of two or three witnesses every matter shall be established (Deuteronomy 19:15); we try to hold to this. Christ said so only here: “Unless one is born of water and the Spirit” (John 3:5). And if we read this text and say — well, probably by water baptism is meant, because Christ bequeathed us to be baptized, and so on.

But, first, such a remark: how can one apply earthly material things to spiritual things? When we speak of the new birth — it is the birth of our spirit, the inner man. At the rebirth of the spirit one may say the soul blossoms. If the spirit is dead, the soul too is constrained; it is in slavery. But if the spirit is born again by the Holy Spirit, it means the Holy Spirit united with our spirit into one. That is the new birth. Then the soul also blossoms. So — how can the water of a river or a basin, or the water in a church — how can it be applied to the rebirth of our spirit?

In my understanding it does not fit in any way. That is, the spiritual must be combined with the spiritual. And when Christ says that “you must be born of water and the Spirit,” He meant the Spirit — we do not dispute here; everyone understands it is the Holy Spirit. But by water He meant some spiritual component.

And if we open the Gospel and read — I shall name you only three texts which speak of the new birth. Two say directly that it is the new birth. And there stands: what participates in the new birth? Well, first, who participates? It is the Holy Spirit. And water also participates in the new birth.

But other texts answer directly what this water is. So, the epistle of James (James 1:18): “Of His own will He brought us forth by the word of truth.”

There Christ did not say one must be born of the word of truth. But of water and the Spirit. And here it is clarified: the Holy Spirit remains — that is, He is present in the new birth, because so it is written in the epistle to Titus — “the washing of regeneration and renewing by the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5). There no questions arise. Here it is said God begets us by His Word. “Of His own will He brought us forth by the word of truth.”

And the First Epistle of Peter (1 Peter 1:23) — Peter says: “having been born again, not of corruptible seed, but incorruptible, through the word of God which lives and abides forever.” Again rebirth takes place thanks to the action of the word of God. Well, and the epistle to the Ephesians — there it is said of the church, how Christ works in the church, “having cleansed it (the church) with the washing of water by the word” (Ephesians 5:26).

Here “the washing of regeneration and renewing by the Holy Spirit” (Titus 3:5) — and here a washing. “Having cleansed it with the washing of water by the word” (Ephesians 5:26). It turns out three texts which say the word of God directly participates in the rebirth of a man. Therefore I understand that, when Christ spoke with Nicodemus, by water the word of God is meant.

I thank you for your attention!

Report of the Orthodox side (Alan Bedoev)

In principle, there will be the same texts — but in church interpretation. Speaking on the theme of baptism, it is important to note that the prophecy of New Testament baptism was given to mankind already in the Old Covenant.

We remember that Ezekiel, being moved by the Holy Spirit, left us the following text: “I will sprinkle clean water on you, and you shall be clean from all your filthiness… and I will give you a new heart and a new Spirit” (Ezekiel 36:25–28).

According to the teaching of the One Holy Catholic Apostolic Church, baptism is a Sacrament in which the one baptized, at threefold immersion in water in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, dies for the sinful and fleshly life, is cleansed of all his sins, and is born again of the Holy Spirit for a righteous and holy life.

The divine institution of this sacrament is evident. Yes — here with you we have no disagreements whatsoever. The Lord, as you rightly noticed, after His resurrection said to the apostles: “Go and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit” (Matthew 28:19).

The Church calls baptism a sacrament, and not simply some rite, since through the outward sacred action there is given to the one baptized the invisible but effective grace of the Holy Spirit, which drowns every sin and every defilement in man.

Now, by theses. First: The Church teaches that precisely in baptism, not before baptism, all his sins are forgiven to man. Therefore the apostle Peter said to the believing Jews: “Repent, and let each of you be baptized… (for what?) for the forgiveness of sins; and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit” (Acts 2:38). And the Church considered this text so important that it included it even in the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed, which the majority of neo-Protestant organizations formally acknowledge. I do not know how it is with you, but practically everywhere the Creed is read precisely before Communion at the Lord’s Supper.

This text gives us also a certain sequence which is afterwards traced in other texts of Holy Scripture.

Peter says: first comes repentance — “repent.” Then comes baptism — “let each of you be baptized for the forgiveness of sins.” And third already — the receiving of the Holy Spirit. The brightest illustration that sins are forgiven precisely in baptism, and not in repentance, is, of course, the history of the conversion of Paul. We know that Paul, once Saul, at a definite historical moment of his life was a sinful man, even a fighter against God. The book of Acts tells us this man went to Damascus with a definite aim: to seize Christians and lead them to trial.

On the way this man experiences the strongest spiritual and emotional shock. He meets with Christ. Meets with Christ personally. He even hears His voice. He understands before him is the Lord Jesus Christ, and even says to Him: “Lord, what do You want me to do?” (Acts 9:6)

Further this same book tells us Paul was in the strongest contrition of heart, in repentance, three days. It is written he did not even eat or drink anything. That is, few of us repented so.

God, who is above time and space, knowing the state of Paul, in what repentance he is, sends to him a certain Ananias, who comes and says to him the following words: “Saul, Saul, why are you waiting? Be baptized!” And here is the question — for what? Ananias answers — “and wash away your sins” (Acts 22:16). That is, in this text, as in the text Acts 2:38, we see that the forgiveness of sins takes place precisely in baptism, and not in repentance. Otherwise the meaning of this text, the meaning of the actions of Ananias, who was sent by the Lord Himself, is quite simply lost.

The Baptists — at least those with whom I spoke — contrary to the word of God, distorted this principle and teach roughly thus: first repent for the forgiveness of sins, then receive the gift of the Holy Spirit, and afterwards, the third stage — be baptized not for the forgiveness of sins. That is, we see this is an evident distortion of the word of God. And it is the common principle of all neo-Protestant organizations.

Here Sergey Anatolyevich said that “we believe baptism does not cleanse sins.” In another place we read of the cleansing function of baptism — this is Ephesians, chapter 5, (Ephesians 5:26), “that He might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water by the word” — this text was already mentioned. As is known, the main component of baths in antiquity was the font. Whoever has touched, however briefly, at least once in life, the history of the church, knows that baptism in apostolic times, in the first century, the second, the third, and so on, was always called the font of rebirth, the bath of rebirth.

Evidently here we speak precisely of baptism. But you drew attention precisely to the second part of the verse: it is written the church is cleansed by means of “the word.” We acknowledge — yes, it is indeed so.

Quite right — “the word” in baptism is necessary. That is, we use the formulation which the Lord Himself left us: “In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.” There was one such brother in Christ, blessed Augustine — he said: “What is baptism? It is water with the invocation of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Take away the words — there is no baptism. Take away the water — there is no baptism.”

Second, this text must be understood in the sense of gospel preaching. You again noticed well what Paul once said: “How shall they believe in Him of whom they have not heard? How shall they hear without a preacher? How shall they preach unless they are sent?” (Romans 10:14–15).

In exactly the same way one may say: how to be baptized, of whom they have not heard, have not believed, and so on. The word of God is necessary that faith be born in a man. It truly begets faith, which afterwards impels the man to keep the commandments — including, naturally, the commandment about baptism. Therefore we acknowledge: yes, the word is necessary; but this does not say baptism is not needed for salvation. The word of God begets faith. Faith impels the man to keep the commandments.

The second aspect — baptism saves, that is, it is an integral part in the work of salvation, and therefore it is necessary for all people, regardless of race, sex, and age. Precisely age — I make the accent — because you noted that you do not baptize children. But that we shall discuss further.

The Lord, in the conversation with Nicodemus, said words which you have already called to mind today. Words very categorical, and because of their radicalness they are often rejected by Protestants. “Unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of heaven” (John 3:5).

In what, properly, is the essence — what is the matter? We all know the book of Genesis narrates how the primeval man fell away from God, transgressing His commandment. As a result man lost that grace which literally impregnated his nature, sustained life in it. And as we know — “a holy place is never empty” — sin entered into human nature. In this connection a full perturbation took place in human nature. The mind lost control almost completely over the will and feelings. The lower powers of the soul, such as the feelings, came to predominate over the spiritual. And man simply began to be guided by the flesh; he became passionate; he became mortal; he became ill. And this state, which in the final count leads man to death and plunges his soul into hell, is called now “original sin.”

It spread to all people. In the fifth chapter of the book of Genesis we already read that Adam begat a son in his own image and likeness — well, that is, in the image and likeness of sinful man. The same book of Genesis tells us “the imagination of man’s heart is evil from his youth” (Genesis 8:21). We remember the bitter words of righteous Job, who said “who can bring a clean thing out of an unclean?” — and himself answers: “not one” (Job 14:4). We remember the words of the apostle Paul (Romans 5:12): “as through one man sin entered the world, and death through sin, so death spread to all men.” And into children, and into grandmothers, and into Papuans. Into all men. “Because in him all sinned.”

Man was doomed to perdition. He became guilty before God. And “a child of wrath,” as the epistle to the Ephesians narrates (Ephesians 2:3). Already by the fact of his birth.

The loving God, seeing all this, did not abandon His creation. He inclined the heavens and came down. Being the Judge, He gave Himself over to judgment. Being the Source of all life, He endured death. Being the Word, the Logos, He was compelled to be silent on the cross. In order “to save and seek that which was lost” (Matthew 18:11), as He Himself says of it.

And here before every believing man the question arises. But how can we become partakers of His redemptive fruits, of the fruits of His redemptive sacrifice? He died for us, redeemed — but how are we to become partakers of this? Scripture teaches us that for this purpose the Lord created the Church. “Christ is head of the Church,” the epistle to the Ephesians tells us, “and He is the Savior of the Body” (Ephesians 5:23). Here it is important: in the report it sounded — God is my personal Savior. Scripture says: He is the Savior of the Body, not of each separate person taken apart. The Body — that means the Church. Which is the image of the New Ark, outside which there is no salvation. And which has its clear boundaries. Through Baptism we enter into the bosom of the Church, for “by one Spirit we were all baptized into one body” (1 Corinthians 12:13), the apostle Paul tells us. That is, through Baptism we became partakers of His Body, of His Church: “as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ” (Galatians 3:27). And how can one be saved without having put on Christ? In no way. A man is saved, becoming partaker of His Body. If this putting on of Christ takes place precisely in Baptism, then, consequently, Baptism is an integral part in the work of salvation.

Therefore we administer it to all. I shall repeat this often, so that it be better absorbed. “He who believes and is baptized will be saved; but he who does not believe will be condemned” (Mark 16:16). Again we see for salvation not only faith is needed, but also Baptism. The text of Titus, which has already been quoted (Titus 3:5): “He saved us, not because of works of righteousness which we have done, but according to His mercy.” The question: how? “through the washing (that is, the font) of regeneration and renewing of the Holy Spirit.” Therefore the Church affirms Baptism is necessary for all. Baptism cleanses from all sins. Baptism is the way, the door into the Church. Therefore we administer it to all people.

The third aspect. The celebrants of the sacraments of Baptism, and of other sacraments, are the apostles and their successors. Again we must return precisely to the question of participation in the historical Church. The Lord commanded His apostles to go, preach, and baptize all nations; they — their successors. And baptizing must precisely the shepherds of the Church who have direct apostolic succession, ascending to the apostles. By which their hierarchical right to celebrate these sacraments is proved.

Generally, any doctrinal position — whether the Eucharist (Communion), baptism, chrismation, confession, and the rest — cannot be considered outside the ecclesiological context. That is, the Lord founded the Church which has sacraments, which has clear boundaries, and precisely in this Church all this takes place. “The Church” — one, not churches, as we already said last time. And it is very grievous for us that, unfortunately, you are while outside this Church. And into her we call you.

Discussion of the reports

Orthodox priest: (Priest Evgeny Veselov): So that it be clearer to us, here one must understand how God acts. God is not a man, to act as you or I. Here I shall wish, say, to touch someone — I must do it with hand or foot, but not touch the whole body. God, He is above me, and therefore He acts, naturally, more mightily than I. And the grace of God — that is, the uncreated power of God — penetrates not one concrete point, but penetrates as God Himself considers necessary.

“The wind blows where it wishes” (John 3:8). Therefore this grace of God — it, as you rightly said, depends on our free will, on our desire. And this desire, our faith, is one of the conditions for calling the grace of God. Seeing our faith and our deeds joined with faith — in particular, that we come to baptism — the priest baptizes the man; God sends His Spirit. And this Spirit of God invisibly comes down upon the water, comes down upon the one baptized; and it is administered not through the hand, not through the eye, not through the foot, but to the whole body and the whole soul of the man at once. But invisibly. Meanwhile it is known there are not a few cases when a newly baptized person receives certain special gifts. For example, the holy righteous John of Kronstadt, when he was born, was a very weak child, and his parents despaired of his life. They invited a priest, that he baptize at once — the same day. That is not accepted with us. Usually there the eighth, fortieth day, or even later still. But since the child was at the point of death, they called the priest, and he baptized the infant at once. The child survived and afterwards lived quite a long life. That is, we see that through the action of the sacrament of baptism the Holy Spirit strengthened John of Kronstadt both spiritually — certainly this is visible in his life — but bodily too. Of such cases there are very many.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes, I understood your thought, but cannot yet agree. Thank you. I understood the answer.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — And how do you interpret the text you quoted repeatedly — “Repent, and let each of you be baptized for the forgiveness of sins” (Acts 2:38)?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: Well, I always say: let us look how it is written in the Greek.

Orthodox: — Let us.

Baptist: (Speaker): — We read. “Peter said to them: repent, and let each of you be baptized on the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.” (Interlinear translation from the Greek of Acts 2:38)

Orthodox: (Speaker): — And what is the difference? The main thing is that baptism gives forgiveness of sins. “For” the forgiveness of sins — as you understand?

Baptist: (Speaker): — Already your sins were forgiven, and you are baptized. We have no contradiction. There are no contradictions here, since the repenting were baptized at once. Therefore there were both repentance and baptism at once. The one was not separated from the other.

(Speaker): We have here, for example, no basin. Suppose for a year people turn to God, repent. And at repentance — there are many texts — “repent for the forgiveness of sins,” that is, repentance is a necessary condition; the man asks forgiveness; he receives forgiveness of sins. But since the possibility to be baptized is with us only in summer, the man waits for his possibility to be buried by baptism into death.

(Speaker): Why there are no contradictions here — because in the first apostolic church, at once as people believed, at once they turned to God; they were at once led to baptism.

(Speaker): Therefore I simply see no contradictions. But we wish to say: it is not the rite of baptism itself that produces forgiveness of sins, but the fact that a man repents of his sins. Here children, yes, they may ask forgiveness — but not sincerely; you understand this. Even before they ask forgiveness, you are already inwardly disposed to them; you are ready to forgive them everything; but it is considered reconciliation took place between father and son when the child sincerely repents. Therein is the sense. If with you repentance takes place and at once baptism in the church — yes, you have the right.

Orthodox priest: — It seems to me your everyday examples, or from your modern practice, are secondary in relation to Holy Scripture. In Scripture are described cases where we see no evident repentance. Well, for example, the prison guard. Where is repentance? He sees the wonder, sees the faith of the prisoners, hears their word about Christ, and at once is baptized. Scripture says not a word of repentance. Philip and the eunuch. The eunuch rides, hears the word from Philip — “here is water”… Where is repentance? Even when the apostle Peter gives his first preaching, he says “they were pricked in their heart” (Acts 2:37). No public confession, no repentance in the book of Acts. But nevertheless they unanimously come to baptism.

(Speaker): Consequently this idea of yours — that they go for a whole year, repent, experience — in these three biblical examples (and one may continue them) does not act. Lydia, again — her house. Well, there is no such repentance. The accepting of Christ with all the heart there is. The desire to become a Christian there is again. Repentance as an experiencing of one’s life, a public or personal penitence — there is not. There is no temporal interval.

(Speaker): What happens further? And further the forgiveness of sins takes place. That forgiveness which, in your opinion, takes place earlier, before baptism — according to the book of Acts this forgiveness of sins takes place somewhere, but not in the repentance preceding. So — in the font of baptism. And if we read the Epistle to the Romans, chapter 6 — of which we were already told in the first report — we shall see that there baptism is tied to forgiveness of sins.

Baptist: (Speaker): — It is written: “He will convict the world of sin.” Of what sin does the Holy Spirit convict?

Orthodox priest: — You go far away.

Baptist: (Speaker): — We speak of repentance. A man repented of sins. Right? The most deadly sin. What is the first sin which the Holy Spirit convicts?

Orthodox priest: — Well, you have your opinion; voice it.

Baptist: (Speaker): — No, not opinion. There it is written in the sixteenth chapter: “The Holy Spirit, having come, will convict the world of sin, that they believe not in Me” (John 16:8–9).

Orthodox priest: — It is not said there that this is the first conviction.

Baptist: (Speaker): — “He will convict the world of sin, that they believe not in Me.” That Jesus Christ said clearly. Now: what penitence does God accept first of all? The confession of sins may be also after repentance; the man goes to the minister, confesses his sins — that is, before God.

(Speaker): But the first thing that takes place is not visible — that is why with the prison guard it is not visible — because it is done before God. This is the first — that now he acknowledges Jesus Christ as his Savior and repents that he believed not in Him.

Orthodox priest: — And the other sins?

Baptist: (Speaker): — The other sins — that is already as a consequence. He repented of unbelief. And he goes with the confession of sins, as the Lord convicts him — that he smoked, drank, something else there (it is opened before the priest, before the minister). But the first penitence which the man must perform is to repent that he believed not in Jesus Christ. If this penitence is not, then in half a year the man will again come to confess these same sins. In a year he will again come to confess these same sins. In two years he will again come to confess these same sins.

(Speaker): And when you look at his life, with Christ nothing is connected. Why? Because the first sin, the most important one, is not confessed. “Believes not in Me.” I answer the question why it is not visible that the prison guard repented — but we see it in his actions: “Men, brethren, what must I do?” (Acts 16:30). Why? Because his light penetrated.

(Speaker): Christ said to Paul: “Saul, Saul, why do you persecute Me” (Acts 9:4). We see he there did not repent, did not confess sins. He prayed three days; but he clearly says afterwards that he accepted that conviction — that he went against Christ.

Orthodox priest: — We have with you a common weak place. I feel it in myself, and I see it in you. Since you are a preacher, and I must preach by status, then instead of answering briefly one wishes to convince with words. That is unseemly.

Baptist: (Speaker): — I answer the question why we do not see repentance.

Orthodox priest: — You contradict the apostle Peter, who says baptism grants the remission not of the sin of unbelief, but of sins altogether. And the Lord promises forgiveness not of the sin of unbelief, but of sins altogether. Of course, one must repent of unbelief too; of course, one must overcome unbelief with faith. I do not dispute with you; you are completely right. But baptism forgives all sins. And it regenerates for the new life by the Holy Spirit.

(Speaker): Understand — take the epistle to the Romans, the sixth chapter. This text with us is read during baptism. Because precisely it, in the opinion of the Church, is one of the brightest, which teaches what baptism is, in the spiritual respect. So — if we open this text, we shall see baptism is regeneration. That is a very important thing. When the Lord says one must be born of water and the Spirit — that is birth. Because Nicodemus compares with bodily birth, while the Lord speaks of spiritual birth.

(Speaker): And in this same text — you say there are no other texts; not true — here is a text…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Read…

Orthodox priest: — Therefore we were buried with Him through baptism into death, that just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life. For if we have been united together in the likeness of His death, certainly we also shall be united in the likeness of His resurrection, knowing this, that our old man was crucified with Him, that the body of sin might be done away with, that we should no longer be slaves of sin; for he who has died has been freed from sin. (Romans 6:4–7).

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Where here is the word “regeneration” or “new birth”?

Orthodox priest: — I am surprised. Let us read further. Here it is shown we died with Christ for sin; but if we are dead, must we not live in Christ? Does life appear in us or not? Newness of life. That is precisely that birth into Christ which takes place in baptism, and not something else.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Here about regeneration there is not one word.

Orthodox priest: — Once more. Do you agree (with the Apostle) that we die with Christ in baptism?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No. I believe we die for the old life in repentance.

Orthodox priest: — Not in baptism?

Baptist: (Speaker): — The moment of repentance is the death for the old life, for sin, for self, for Satan, and the resurrection from the dead — at the moment of repentance it takes place.

Orthodox priest: — But the apostle says: “Therefore we were buried with Him through baptism into death.” Not by repentance — by baptism.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — “We were buried” — that is burial; I already spoke of it. That “we were buried into death” is as confirmation of the fact that we are already in such a state.

Orthodox priest: — Here I do not even know what to say to you, because this text altogether concerns baptism… But let us take a little earlier. Verse three. “Or do you not know that as many of us as were baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into His death” (Romans 6:3)? Again not that?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — This here may be applied not to water baptism. And “having been baptized into Christ Jesus”… That takes place at repentance.

Orthodox priest: — No — “were baptized.” The word baptism is unambiguous according to the text.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No. The very word “baptism”…

Orthodox priest: — How not? You yourselves used it precisely as relating to water baptism. Is it not so?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — We baptize people in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit; in the name of Jesus Christ we baptize; but in this text, if one studies it more deeply, here two baptisms are spoken of.

(Speaker): “Baptized into Christ Jesus” — that is one who has entered into Christ; and this takes place… In my conception it takes place at the moment of repentance, at the moment of the new birth. And the man who has been baptized into Christ Jesus — he must go, perform water baptism, bury the old life. I explained that this is not death and resurrection, but burial of the old life. A dead man — he must be buried. In water baptism — spiritual baptism — this is immersion into Christ Jesus, with the cooperation of the Holy Spirit; it takes place at repentance.

Comment: A very characteristic dialogue. To understand the absurdity of the position of the Baptists, one may consider this text of Romans 6:1–13 in full — whose meaning the Baptists distort: “Or do you not know that as many of us as were baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into His death? Therefore we were buried with Him through baptism into death, that just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life. For if we have been united together in the likeness of His death, certainly we also shall be united in the likeness of His resurrection, knowing this, that our old man was crucified with Him, that the body of sin might be done away with, that we should no longer be slaves of sin; for he who has died has been freed from sin. Now if we died with Christ, we believe that we shall also live with Him, knowing that Christ, having been raised from the dead, dies no more; death no longer has dominion over Him. For the death that He died, He died to sin once for all; but the life that He lives, He lives to God. Likewise you also, reckon yourselves to be dead indeed to sin, but alive to God in Christ Jesus our Lord. Therefore do not let sin reign in your mortal body, that you should obey it in its lusts; and do not present your members as instruments of unrighteousness to sin, but present yourselves to God as being alive from the dead, and your members as instruments of righteousness to God” (Romans 6:3–13). As is evident, baptism takes place into the death of Christ — and by no means into His burial. “We were buried” — because we went down into the water and, as it were, became partakers of death, because all abiding in the earth are dead; but in the sacrament of baptism the earth is replaced by another similar element — water. This going down into the water, that is, baptism, grants us renewed life and makes us in some measure partakers also of the resurrection of Christ. Baptism grants victory over sin, frees from slavery to sin, crucifies the old man. Through this life begins to act in us (in contrast with the death that was before) — life which gives power to act in Christ, power to keep His commandments and not obey sin. The baptism of the Baptists, being an empty rite, gives no life in Christ and gives no experience of this life. Therefore the Baptists do not know, and do not even believe in the possibility of the victory of a Christian over sin — while with us the experience of such victory was had by every saint. But the experience of the grace-bearing power proper to us to conquer sin is with every believer, although at times we ourselves are conquered by sin. Of course, the absence of the living grace of God leads the Baptists to a false ascetics and theology.

Orthodox priest: — And find the text where it is said that repentance before baptism — that is precisely baptism. Not your suppositions — show directly in the text, on the line.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Once more — that repentance before baptism…

Orthodox priest: — …is precisely baptism. As you just told me — such a text: show it, please, and I shall agree with you. I know no such texts and consider your interpretation contradicts Scripture.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I did not so say that…

Orthodox priest: — You said literally that “as many of us as were baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into His death” (Romans 6:3) refers not to the act of water baptism, but to the preceding repentance, which has no relation to water. Prove it; give another example. You set out to us the rules of hermeneutics.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I believe so: in the First Epistle to the Corinthians, in the twelfth chapter it is written: “For by one Spirit we were all baptized into one body” (1 Corinthians 12:13). That is, baptism with water is baptism with the Holy Spirit. So He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire. And there is baptism with water. There baptism with sufferings besides. That is, this baptism with the Holy Spirit, of which Paul writes in Corinthians, and at this moment we are immersed into the body of Christ — that is not water baptism. It is baptism with the Holy Spirit. It takes place at the repentance of a man. That is the immersion into Christ.

Orthodox priest: — In vain do you consider so… If according to the text: “for by one Spirit we were all baptized into one body — Jews or Greeks, slaves or free — and have all been made to drink into one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:13) — did I quote rightly?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — The Lord says (John 3:5) that “unless one is born of water and the Spirit — here is the Spirit — he cannot enter the kingdom of God.” That is, we see a complete coincidence. Birth of water and the Spirit is baptism, which — as we believe, and you cannot refute — is that baptism which gives the Spirit. And the apostle speaks of the same — and, what is more, not only gives the Spirit, but introduces into the body of the Church. And you agree that baptism introduces into the body of the Church — it all coincides, it seems. You spoke of this to us specially.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: I understand your thought. I think you understand mine.

Orthodox priest: — I do not see you arguing worthily. Because the text you bring speaks against you.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Very well; I think we shall not show this too deeply.

Comment: Having no answer from the Bible, the Baptists do not wish to acknowledge their error. Their false teaching contradicts the Bible, but they do not wish to ascertain the truth — if only to remain in their seductive feeling that they are already saved.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Why?! This is very important.

Baptist: (Speaker): — We have many questions yet which, I think, the brothers wish to ask.

Orthodox priest: — Do I understand rightly that you agreed here with our point of view?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No, I did not agree with that — that water baptism is the rebirth of a man. I brought you three arguments: that in water baptism — or, more precisely, in the spiritual rebirth of a man — the word of God and the Holy Spirit participate. And that is all. That is, Christ by water meant the word of God. There is no third option.

Orthodox priest: — So, I understand rightly (you set out hermeneutics to us): where in the Gospel of John we see the word “water” — that is precisely “teaching.” For example, when the Lord turns water into wine — clear, evidently, that He takes much “Word” and makes it wine…

(Speaker): The point is that there are several texts where, indeed, “water” means “teaching.” For example, in the conversation with the Samaritan woman. For example, in chapter 8 of the Gospel of John. But there every time alongside it is explained that “water” means teaching. But if there is no such explanation, then, of course — if from the rib of Christ issue blood and water, but “teaching” surely does not issue — water issues. If John baptizes Christ in water, in the Jordan — but not in “teaching” surely does he baptize in the Jordan — in water he baptizes.

(Speaker): That is the elementary rule of hermeneutics. That very one of which you spoke to us quite rightly. Therefore, of course, if it is written “water,” then it is water; if it is written “teaching,” or water means teaching (it is written alongside) — so we believe and so we read. Why then distort the word of God and see what is not there?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes, good. Let us put a couple more questions. Our main aim was that we shall tell how we believe, and shall not dispute and accuse others that “you distort Scripture.”

Comment: Again the Baptists evade the answer. Although it was clearly shown to them: usually the word “water” does mean water, and only in certain cases, when the parabolic meaning is evident, does it mean “teaching.” In the conversation with Nicodemus regarding water there is no parable at all; the Lord sets forth positive teaching. It is not clear to Nicodemus not because of the water, but because of the image of the second birth — of which he himself says in answer to the Savior: “The wind blows where it wishes, and you hear the sound of it, but cannot tell where it comes from and where it goes: so is everyone who is born of the Spirit. Nicodemus answered and said to Him: how can these things be?” (John 3:8–9). So, the cause of the errors of the Baptists is not in their ignorance or non-understanding of the Bible, but in their unwillingness to learn the right teaching. In that they set their human opinion above the word of God and the teaching of the Church.

Orthodox priest: — You do not distort Scripture, but you interpret.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — “You distort; you do not agree with Scripture.” We have not yet once said that to you, while from you we have already several times heard it.

Orthodox priest: — So we say, in essence…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — We agreed so: that we shall share our faith. Here — I believe so; I stand on such convictions. I am interested how you believe; you tell how you believe. Good — thank you; I shall take that into account. And we go further; questions appear; I put questions; you put questions. Everyone present here. Why are we in expanded composition? So that all may participate. We put questions. If my answer did not satisfy you, you do not say: “oh, you answer not according to Scripture!”

(Speaker): I answer as I believe, as I understand. It seems to you I answer not according to Scripture. And it seems to me you answer not according to Scripture. But let us not accuse one another in this. Therefore let us go further — there are still many questions clarifying this moment: how you believe, how you understand.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Well, let us. You put a question; now our side. You touched the theme of hermeneutics. In general, your central verse is “not the putting off of the filth of the flesh, but the answer of a good conscience toward God” (1 Peter 3:21).

(Speaker): The question is simply this: does it not trouble you that this word “eperotema,” which is translated as “answer [pledge],” occurs only once? And may be understood both as “answer [pledge]” and as “inquiry.” But in its verbal form — “eperotao” — it occurs 59 times in the New Covenant — 59! And it always means “inquiry.”

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Well, I personally have not studied that.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Well, you speak of hermeneutics — that on one verse one must not build one’s teaching and so on. It occurs once in this form, and in the other 59 cases — precisely “inquiry.”

Orthodox priest: — Let us clarify: in the dictionary both meanings are given — both “inquiry” and “answer [pledge].” But the context there does not directly show how to choose correctly. The Slavonic translation, for example, has “inquiry,” while the Russian, as you know, the Synodal translation, gives “answer [pledge].” But the other usages of the word, as we are told, show such a context.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — In your translation “inquiry” — what do you mean?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — The man inquires of the Lord, asks of the Lord help to keep a good conscience. Lord, help! That is what we do.

Baptist: (Speaker): — And does that not contradict this “answer [pledge]”?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — “Answer [pledge]” — that is what you say — covenant…

Baptist: (Speaker): — No, one may [understand] to the end. “Answer [pledge]” does not mean that I rely on myself, on my fleshly powers, to keep my conscience. That is not so. “Inquiry” is also a very, even very good translation, because we always ask that the Lord help us, that we really be faithful, remain faithful. Of this there are many other texts in Holy Scripture where we truly ask, have need, depend on God, to remain faithful to Him.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — No — in the report it sounded as a contract. That I have a covenant with God; that, as it were, from that moment I keep myself, do not sin, have already died for my past life, and so on. That is a contract — that is an “answer of a good conscience.” On that, properly, the dogma of baptism is built.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Yes, I always understood it so, believed so, and taught so.

Orthodox priest: — May I agree with you in this question? I should like to say: I agree that baptism is entry into covenant with God. That is very important. Precisely — not the preceding deeds of man, including penitence — but precisely baptism is entry into covenant. It is both an “answer [pledge],” for whoever may pledge, and an “inquiry,” for whoever may inquire. But in any case — the entry, the beginning of relations with God. Why does the Lord speak of birth of the Spirit? Before this the Spirit was not yet. The Spirit called to the font of Baptism. Now the Spirit is given, and entry into covenant with God takes place. I agree with you completely.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Thank you. So in the Greek there is this meaning — “petition,” “inquiry.” It is my omission that I did not study how it is written in the Greek.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Simply by inward sense both “answer [pledge]” and “inquiry” — all has one meaning. What meaning? To be obedient to Jesus Christ. That “the answer of a good conscience” is obedience; that “inquiry” — again we come to obedience, that we be obedient. That is, this covenant — from our side we agree to obedience. As it turns out, it may at first not come out very well, but we are already inwardly disposed to the obedience of God. We lived in unbelief — did not obey God, in our own way — and now in obedience.

(Speaker): May I put a question?

Orthodox: — Yes.

Baptist: (Speaker): — About the church — here was the last phrase. “We are not in the church; we must return to the church”… What is the church in your understanding?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — In general, according to biblical teaching, if we consider the Bible not apart from context, then church may be called only such a community of people believing in Jesus Christ which, first, has its beginning from Christ and to our days. That is, it did not appear there 300 years ago, 500 years ago — at the best, like the Lutherans, and so on. Which has apostolic succession. Well, we shall examine this point by point. Let us — already this fact says precisely the Orthodox church is the true church.

(Speaker): In the age of modern technologies anyone wishing — any believer, why say believer — any atheist — may trace the successive connection, for example, from Patriarch Kirill and, in this case, to the apostle Andrew. That is, I repeat — it is simply a fact. Here we understood precisely the Orthodox church is that church which the Lord created. It is that church which will be “the pillar and ground of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:15) through all ages, which “the gates of hell shall never prevail against” (Matthew 16:18), and which will keep the truth.

(Speaker): The second aspect of the church. The church is such a community of people believing in Jesus Christ as keeps the purity of Divine revelation in all its fullness. That is, in the form of divine Tradition and Holy Scripture — not cutting off one of them. You remember the apostle Paul said: “stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word” — that is, through divine Sacred Tradition — “or our epistle” (2 Thessalonians 2:15) — that is, Holy Scripture.

(Speaker): The third aspect — it has the Sacraments; and the fourth aspect — the hierarchy of the church.

Baptist: (Speaker): — So your church goes from the apostle Andrew, yes?

Orthodox priest: — Yes. And he was sent by Christ.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But if Catholics were sitting among us, they would say differently — that the Church is from Peter… And I say it why? They say, say, from Peter; you go from Andrew; someone else from someone else. But we look at it according to Scripture: the church is the body of Christ. So — and I should like to know.

(Speaker): I do not know whether you have membership or not… Is the Orthodox church the body of Christ — or are the children of God who by faith, by baptism, by renewing of the Holy Spirit, these born children of God — are they the Body of Christ? Or is the Orthodox church the Body of Christ?

Orthodox priest: — Very simply. Everyone baptized in the Orthodox church is her member, if he has not fallen away. If he has fallen away — of course, he ceases to be one.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Fallen away from where?

Orthodox priest: — Has lost the faith, or gone into some other religious organization, or something else.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But if he remains in the Orthodox church, sins, sits in prison, does what he wills — but he is Orthodox and considers himself Orthodox?

Orthodox priest: — Well, he may consider himself anyone, but “faith without works is dead” (James 2:20). That is, if a man by his works refutes his faith…

Baptist: (Speaker): — But he received baptism, performs the sacraments, perhaps even sits in prison…

Orthodox priest: — The apostle Judas too was called by Christ, participated in many wonders which Christ performed. More than that — he worked wonders himself, when the Lord sent His twelve apostles to preach. Scripture does not note to us that all the eleven healed, cast out demons, and Judas, because he betrayed Christ, was outside that grace. That is, Judas was a participant of the preaching, was a participant of the grace of God, but in the final count his falling away, his sin led to that he fell away from the Lord.

(Speaker): Therefore the man too who received baptism in the Orthodox church may fall away by his works, by his faith, because faith and works are interconnected.

(Speaker): That is, it is clear — you too mentioned it today — that we all, unfortunately, sin; we all repent. But one thing is when a man relates to sin precisely as to a crime and apostasy from Christ, and as Peter repents of it, and afterwards through repentance unites with Christ again… Even if he was a murderer… Or the man, like Judas, rejects the grace of God and, correspondingly, finishes his life somehow differently. Therefore a man may consider himself Orthodox.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Priests give him Communion — but, in principle, it is all in his faith, so?

Orthodox priest: — If he repents…

Orthodox: (Speaker): — I have an addition to this: the Head of the church with us is Christ. Christ is the knower of hearts, and only He knows the heart of man, and He knows who enters into the composition of the church and who does not. A man may consider as he wills.

Orthodox priest: — But, again, this entering or not entering — it is meant not generally of all people, but of the baptized. That is important.

Baptist: (Speaker): — And here, and the last thing, to clarify: you are from the apostle Andrew.

Orthodox priest: — No — the hierarchy is from Andrew, but we are from Christ. And Andrew — from the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost; do not forget that.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But the Catholic church — it has succession from the apostle Peter. And the other ten apostles yet.

Orthodox priest: — Each has its own.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But do you know who from whom?

Orthodox priest: — Of course.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Well, say — which from the apostle Thomas? Because you, declaring we are not in the church, while you unconditionally go from the apostles…

Orthodox priest: — Let us do so: you asked about Thomas. I shall say about him alone, and on this, if it is interesting, learn further yourselves. Concretely the apostle Thomas preached in India, where he was slain; there the Indian church was founded, which afterwards deviated into the Monothelite heresy — the Malabar church. Therefore they conduct their hierarchical succession precisely from the apostle Thomas. That is, in principle, all these lists exist.

(Speaker): I have a question on the report.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes, we listen.

Orthodox priest: — I liked your report, both for its thoroughness and for a number of moments I did not expect to hear, very near to us. And of two such moments I should like to ask you. Among other things you said the man must be baptized by a baptized one — that is, a continuous system of baptism. One cannot baptize oneself.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — Good.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — A dead man cannot bury himself. Another must bury him.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes, excellent. That is a very right remark; I think so too.

(Speaker): And second, you speak of the fact that a man (here is yet another condition of baptism) — he must be taught the Bible, or more precisely, the right understanding of the Bible. And this preacher who speaks to him must be sent. Do I understand you rightly?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes, of course.

Orthodox priest: — Excellent. And even with you there is a system of sending — that is, you did not set yourselves presbyters of this congregation. Someone set you pastor. These two points seem very right to me. I fully agree with them. But what troubles me is this. You — in reality someone did set you. And him who set you, someone also set.

(Speaker): But this whole aim of setting and sending ascends to John Smyth, who in 1609 baptized himself. And why did he baptize himself? I shall explain. The matter was serious. At that moment in the whole of Europe, in his whole nearest surroundings (he lived in England, then moved to Amsterdam), in his opinion there was not one baptized man. All were baptized in childhood.

(Speaker): And so John Smyth, being in the society of unbaptized — in his opinion — people, and himself being unbaptized, having no one from whom to receive baptism, since, by his convictions, it had been broken from the times of the apostles, he baptized himself and his followers.

(Speaker): Well, and afterwards already Helwys and others began to baptize further. So it turns out: you informed us — and rightly; you have now confirmed it — that from the apostles to this day baptism must be continuous. The living buries the dead, not the dead the dead. But this one baptized himself — and this is the father of Baptism.

(Speaker): And the second moment, as regards preaching — I agree with you there must be sending by another man who has the Spirit of God, has the right to send. But again we ascend continuously to the seventeenth century — to that same John Smyth. Who sent John Smyth? Who invented the idea of baptism in adult age? You will tell me about the Anabaptists; I shall agree with you, shall not dispute — it is not so; but I shall agree. We shall return another hundred years back. And those — who sent them? That is, we have a discontinuity of sending from the apostles both in preaching and in baptisms — if we agree with you.

(Speaker): And if we agree with the Orthodox — that is, the continuity of baptism from the apostles to this day and the continuity of preaching. How does it seem to you?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I shall answer a question with a question. Who sent the apostle Paul? Who made him apostle and sent him? The apostles in Jerusalem, or did Christ send him directly?

Orthodox priest: — Well, let us say so: Christ sent him and gave him the Holy Spirit.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes. And only after fourteen years, he says, he went to Jerusalem, to verify whether we preach rightly, whether we act in one spirit. That is, already in the first century Paul did not accept succession. He was sent directly by Jesus Christ, and that is all. So it turns out: there are twelve apostles, and Paul stands altogether apart.

(Speaker): Perhaps the Baptists went from Paul? We, probably, received succession from him. But that I say in jest, because I do not believe in this succession.

Orthodox priest: — So — why then did you speak of it?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I do not believe in succession.

Orthodox priest: — You spoke of it…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I believe the Lord may find any man in a pagan country, touch his heart, enlighten his mind, show him His grace, yes? And this man, believing in Christ and receiving the Holy Spirit, will go, will be the first missionary; he will accept no sending from anyone. And through him God will create many churches in that country. I believe that.

Baptist: (Speaker): — And we understand thus: altogether the administering of Baptism — this is not a denomination. What has Baptism or Orthodoxy to do with it? Here I did not understand this. I say it why? With us the center is Christ. And I shall say thus: even if a man of another denomination — not necessarily that he came to Baptism. That is, this is a question not of religion, but of personal relationship with Christ.

Orthodox priest: — I understand. And the second half — about baptism. He was dead and baptized himself. Here what will you say?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Once more…

Orthodox priest: — John Smyth baptized himself. And afterwards the Baptists accepted baptism from him. Here what will you say?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I once knew that John Smyth, as it were, is the founder of Baptism.

Orthodox priest: — Well, it is generally known. Well, or Helwys, if you wish.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I long ago forgot about it. It is not essential. And I never associated myself with him.

Orthodox priest: — That is understandable.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Nor with Calvin, nor with Luther. They too are fathers of the reformation. But I did not go from them. My faith, my salvation does not depend on them.

Orthodox priest: — But we say baptism is precisely that which is connected with life. And here it turns out John Smyth was dead and remained dead, and you received this deadness in succession from him.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No — well, why? I personally received this living faith through the word of God.

Orthodox priest: — Faith you received — but precisely rebirth…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And rebirth through the word and through the Holy Spirit. They say — behold, the Baptists… According to our doctrine a man receives rebirth not through baptism, but through faith in the word of God.

Orthodox priest: — So all the fruits of baptism that were voiced to us, and which John Smyth did not have — by your conviction, and could not transmit to others, because he himself did not have it, and you also do not have it — they all turn out an empty sound. Do I understand rightly?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I am not strong in history.

Comment: That is true: the Baptists usually know their original history poorly. By this they show they are strangers to the historical body of the Church. But in this case the pastor is proposed not to voice his knowledge of the history of Baptism, but to answer a logical question. If John Smyth was spiritually dead, then as inheritance to his spiritual descendants he could transmit only this same deadness. Therefore the Baptists cannot but be spiritually dead people, having no access to the church sacraments. But the pastor again does not wish to answer in essence, so as to evade the unpleasant question.

Orthodox priest: — Well, say, entry into the church…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Succession never interested me at all.

Orthodox priest: — We speak precisely of baptism. You told us — it sounded in the report — that only another man can baptize, one who is himself born again.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — And here John Smyth baptized himself, and afterwards administered to others what he himself did not have.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But why do you consider we “descend” from John Smyth?

Orthodox priest: — Because you are Baptists — there is no choice here.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But see wherein is the catch: I just explained. I tomorrow go out, for example, from the membership of the church of Baptism — do I remain a believing man?

Orthodox priest: — One may go out and remain; one may go out and not remain…

Baptist: (Speaker): — No, no — as from membership: here from the paper they crossed me out, and I am no longer a member of the Baptist church. Do I remain faithful, or has my faith gone somewhere?

Orthodox priest: — You understand some go out, having lost faith, and some without losing faith.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But faith, it turns out, is somewhere in a denomination or in the heart?

Orthodox priest: — Faith is in the heart, of course — or it is not in the heart, without doubt.

Baptist: (Speaker): — And why is Baptism fastened to me here, or Orthodoxy?

Orthodox priest: — Because according to the report it comes out that baptism gives certain fruits. So it was said in the report. And I ask: if John Smyth received no fruits and did not transmit them to his followers…

Baptist: (Speaker): — Here I shall say to you thus… Well, we went from Christ, from John the Baptist — let us take that. Or from any other apostle. We may likewise tell. History has come down to Smyth. But before Smyth — tell then, if you know the history.

Orthodox priest: — To tell what precisely?

Baptist: (Speaker): — You took it from Smyth; but before Smyth there were people too.

Orthodox priest: — There were no Baptists.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — You say the year 1054 — the great separation. Before this, did you call yourselves Orthodox?

Orthodox priest: — Of course. You, evidently, simply have not studied history.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes. But tell me: from the first century did Christians call themselves Orthodox?

Orthodox priest: — The Church of Christ was so called. Then, for distinction from all sorts of others, she came to be called Orthodox.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — When did she come to be so called?

Orthodox priest: — When heresies appeared. This began at once in the first century, when people deviated from the true faith, continued to call themselves Christians, but by their faith deviated from Holy Scripture, from the teaching of the apostles. And in order somehow to designate these people…

Comment: If quite historically precisely, then the first use of the word “Orthodox” is fixed among church writers of the second century, beginning with Clement of Alexandria. It may well be that the Church was called Orthodox even earlier — simply no other written monuments have been preserved. See more about this: https://bibleox.com/ru/ru/w/%D0%BF%D0%BE%D1%87%D0%B5%D0%BC%D1%83-%D1%86%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%8C-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BB%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%8F.

(Speaker): Suppose we came to you; at the entrance you have a tablet. There it is written concretely what you declare — we are Baptists, yes? The church of Evangelical Christians-Baptists. If you come to an Orthodox church, there it will be written — the Moscow patriarchate, the Russian Orthodox Church. That is, a designation. To distinguish from you, and from others. Therefore, when these great schisms arose — the Catholics and the Orthodox — so that any man, well versed in this theme or not versed in it at all, should understand who is before him, accordingly these discrete organizations began to designate themselves thus, so that the man should understand: these people, this assembly believes thus, and these people, this assembly believes so.

(Speaker): And originally, of course, we remember with you, when people first began to be called Christians — in Antioch. But not at once, not on the first day — again, so that these people should be distinguished from the Jews. That is, from people who believed not in the Messiah and did not accept Him as Savior — precisely believers in Christ began to be called Christians. And the Jews began to perceive them as a sect. And, correspondingly, for the convenience of distinction they began to be so named. But we have now gone a little into a spiral.

(Speaker): We listened to you attentively; therefore we saw a certain contradiction. Herein is the problem. Because when you spoke, first, you said at first that baptism in Greek is “baptizo” (immersion), and afterwards in the course of the dialogue you renounced it…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — It seems so to you that we renounced…

Orthodox priest: — You simply said yourselves that baptism is not immersion.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No. I added one more concept — that besides water baptism there is also baptism with the Holy Spirit, which takes place at the moment of repentance.

Orthodox priest: — Simply your phrase sounded that baptism is not immersion. And at the beginning you said baptism is immersion. Afterwards one may verify by the recording; perhaps I understood something wrongly. In one text was said “not immersion.” And now we have clarified. You really said wonderful things — that a dead man cannot baptize a dead man. And that a man cannot hear if no one has been sent to him. And you yourselves illustrated this with the history of the apostle Philip and the eunuch. Then the example with Paul was added. Because you mentioned that we are baptized into Christ. But, first, Christ baptized no one — the Gospel says clearly. And second, we see Paul, having believed in Christ, having realized he went to Damascus to destroy Christians, having repented of it, nevertheless receives baptism from the apostles.

(Speaker): Yes — he did not at once go to Jerusalem and did not receive, so to say, the blessing of the apostles for his preaching — but there was an understandable cause, if one speaks historically. Because Paul was long not accepted, and he himself writes of it, that he was a persecutor of the church; and therefore they looked upon him as on a spy, roughly speaking — because to believe in such a marvelous conversion of a man was hard even for the apostles.

(Speaker): And even when they afterwards send him with Barnabas to preach, the apostles look upon this situation with astonishment — because humanly, understandably, this infirmity manifests itself. But nevertheless we see — and Scripture says clearly — that Paul, although converted personally to Christ, nevertheless accepts baptism from the apostles. That is, properly, what we speak of.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Ananias baptized Paul.

Orthodox priest: — Yes — Ananias, an apostle.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And who is Ananias?

Orthodox priest: — One of the seventy, an apostle.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Well, that is already inventions.

Orthodox priest: — Why inventions?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — In Scripture it is not written that he is an apostle; not a word is said of his apostleship; and all that… is not written in the Bible is all already guesses, inventions.

Comment: A splendid idea. But how then are the Baptists to learn that the Gospel of Matthew was written precisely by the apostle Matthew? In the Gospel itself there is not a word of it. So one has to turn to church Tradition. But when from the same Tradition they are told of the status of the apostle Ananias, they reject it. Is that not hypocrisy?

(Speaker): Yet one more little moment: Russian Baptists — you need to read a little how they formed, precisely the Russian Baptists. Because you speak there of John Smyth; but all — the Russian Baptists, the Evangelical Christians-Baptists — formed from three independent points of awakening in Russia. These were the Stundists, these were the Evangelical Christians, these were the Baptists.

Orthodox priest: — The Molokans — let us add yet.

Baptist: (Speaker): The Molokans — they entered afterwards; the Mennonites — those were the Stundists… there was awakening… So to set John Smyth at the head of Russian Baptism is simply unseemly, because there were these three independent points… And where did Lord Redstock go from, then?

Orthodox priest: — From England.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — From England — from where, from what church?

Orthodox priest: — He was himself an evangelical.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — That is a Baptist.

Comment: Striking historical ignorance! If only they would confess they do not know, but wish to study the theory of the question… Yet the disciples of Redstock not only were called “Evangelical Christians,” but were not in communion with the Baptists, until the Soviet power (and by no means their Christian conscience!) compelled the Pashkovites (“Evangelical Christians”) to be reconciled with the Baptists in 1944.

Orthodox priest: — The very idea of baptism in adult age is characteristic neither of the Mennonites nor of the rest. It is precisely a Baptist invention.

Baptist: (Speaker): No — we say Russian Baptism did not go precisely from John Smyth. You say he baptized himself and wish to say of such a succession — that Russian Baptism is from John Smyth. But one must take and look at the history of Russian Baptism. Two hundred and a little years ago. It goes from three independent (they did not agree among themselves) points of awakening in Russia.

Orthodox priest: — But German preachers acted everywhere, and you do not speak of it.

(Speaker): We now go into history, in which we all swim a little, because we simply did not prepare to discuss a historical sketch. Simply — why did we stop now on this — because in the report first it is said it is important that a living man baptize a dead one, that a preacher sent preach to him whom the Lord sends — and afterwards you yourselves renounce it, say: it is all one to me who baptized Smyth; the main thing is that I am with God. It turns out a contradiction…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I did not say that.

Orthodox priest: — You said yourselves it is all one to you how Smyth was baptized.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I did not say that all this is not important. But all these people, sent by Christ, who awakened others, preached the Gospel, baptized — these are God’s instruments. And God may take this instrument in any place, make of a pagan a Christian; he will be the first missionary, of which I have already spoken, in that country, and will know no succession; and there hundreds and thousands of churches will be formed. They may be called anything whatsoever. Neither Orthodox, nor Baptists — simply Christians; and these will be the purest Christians, in reality, if without any additions. Therefore in this I believe. He afterwards will go; his God will send him; and he will preach, baptize, and so on. Otherwise we shall cling to the name.

Orthodox priest: — Allow me to address the other brothers.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes, yes, of course.

Orthodox priest: — We were quoted the epistle to the Galatians, that when the apostle Paul began to preach, he nevertheless went to Jerusalem, and there consulted with the pillars of the church, with the senior apostles, and they acknowledged the preaching was right. Do I understand your quotation rightly?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — Here. And for the apostle Paul himself it was important, and for the others it was important, that they all preached in one spirit. Right?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — Excellent.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — That is very important.

Orthodox priest: — When Baptism appeared, with which of the pillars of the church did they consult, so as to receive human approval, and already men set by God, having the right to preach?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I do not know that. I did not live then.

Orthodox priest: — I know. It was a community persecuted by all, which struggled for its existence and survived. And even to this day has brought great fruits — in the sense of a great number of believers. Therefore, of course, there was no such consultation. He sent himself.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No. If Christ sent him, we cannot dispute that.

Orthodox priest: — But we agreed with you that the consent of the preceding pillars is needed. And it was not. There must be one preaching.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Remember how Gamaliel rose and said — if this enterprise is of men… it will come to nought (Acts 5:38–39).

Orthodox priest: — The Jehovah’s Witnesses love to quote this place. They love it very much.

Comment: That is understandable. Not everything is good that long abides: “What if God, wanting to show His wrath and to make His power known, endured with much longsuffering the vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, and that He might make known the riches of His glory on the vessels of mercy, which He had prepared beforehand for glory” (Romans 9:22–23).

Baptist: (Speaker): — I do not know; I do not wish to speak of false witnesses. The point is it will come to nought. But if from God? And we look… We climb into the roots of history — there may be distortions… We look at results and fruits. And this church of Russian Baptism went through persecutions, and prisons, and all. And we look: before the Soviet Union Orthodox priests acknowledged the Russian Baptists as truly believing people. Vasiliy Guryevich Pavlov and others, who went and told the simple people, revealing Christ. Therefore we look at results.

(Speaker): And now one more moment. Do you believe the Holy Spirit acts to this day? Or did He only act in the apostles, and afterwards gave succession?

Orthodox priest: — Of course the Holy Spirit acts — but not in every man, without doubt.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Not in every one, but He acts. He may reveal Christ to a man even if there is not one believer.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — He may.

Baptist: (Speaker): — He may send him to preach to some tribe or, say, to some people, that they believe. May He?

Orthodox priest: — No, He may not.

Baptist: (Speaker): — God may.

Orthodox priest: — No — that is your conviction. But in Scripture, as you quoted to us, it is written: “How shall they preach unless they are sent?” (Romans 10:15). Human sending of men is needed, having sanction for this from God. When the apostle Paul goes to preach — well, you remember — the believers pray, lay hands on him, and after that he preaches!

Baptist: (Speaker): — But by whom is he sent? Christ sent him.

Orthodox priest: — He begins his preaching with sending from men, while he had the Spirit of God long before that! But you remember the book of Acts!

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Well, time passes quickly… A very important question, a practical question. Here you baptize; you believe every baptized one must be born again. So — how many have you baptized, and how many, by their fruits, born again are there in your church? Why are all the Orthodox in prisons? Why do they drink in taverns? They are all baptized; they all have crosses.

Orthodox priest: — Do not accuse all; we do not drink; we are not in prison… Let us be more polite.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Well, not all — but the majority of the Orthodox live a worldly life and serve Satan. Why? And baptized in childhood, and in mature age…

Orthodox priest: — Let us be more polite — some Orthodox live a worldly life and serve Satan. Let us say — some…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No, no… All the prisons are filled with the Orthodox. Here I went around all. Alexey Vladimirovich Vinogradov — do you know him? Yes, here he sits; here he tells; but there are now no Baptists left — no one to tend there. But there are plenty of Orthodox, plenty of Muslims there — why does grace not act?

Orthodox priest: — I shall easily explain. Tell me, please: Ananias and Sapphira, or, say, Simon the sorcerer — did they receive the grace of God when they believed?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — They received.

Orthodox priest: — Are you sure of it?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — Why then did all three sin against the Holy Spirit, and one was excommunicated by the apostle, and two even perished?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Well — because they sinned.

Orthodox priest: — Rightly.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — They lied.

Orthodox priest: — Because they, by their free will, having received the gift of the Holy Spirit — here about Simon: he received the gift of the Holy Spirit, he saw it — and, however, contrary to the Holy Spirit he began to act sinfully. So these Orthodox too. Having received the regenerating grace of the Holy Spirit, they, alas, by their free will did not wish to make use of it.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — So it turns out the majority of the Orthodox who were baptized — they simply died spiritually again, yes?

Orthodox priest: — They did not so much die… well, one may say so too; I shall even agree in part.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Very well; then the next question, following from this. Here we — the church, a hundred people — love God, hate sin, preach the gospel, love people, live a holy life — well, not a sinless life, but a holy one. Among us there are no divorces. No one among us smokes, drinks, commits adultery. Do you think we revived ourselves by our own strength thus? Or is it the action of the Spirit?

Orthodox priest: — Let me continue your thought thus. And also apostolically: you perform wonders, you prophesy, you heal the sick, raise the dead, and show the other gifts of the Holy Spirit which were with the apostles. Do I understand rightly?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I did not quite understand.

Orthodox priest: — How so? We see the first Christians…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Here look: you say salvation is only in the bosom of the Orthodox Church — that is, grace acts only here. With the Baptists, heretics, grace does not act. That is all. Then what — it turns out we corrected ourselves thus? Suggested it to ourselves? What grace have we then?

Orthodox priest: — And the Jehovah’s Witnesses? Well, the Jehovah’s Witnesses will say the same. That grace acts in them too? You will not agree, surely? They reject Christ as God!

Comment: There is a splendid video on the internet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3bGbbjhBd0. In it a Muslim, a Krishnaite, and a Jehovah’s Witness testify that after they became faithful adherents of their religion, Allah, Krishna, and Jehovah helped them correspondingly to become worthy people and cease to sin. But the Baptist will not agree with their opinion. So, the change of the outward life does not witness to the truth and to nearness to the living God. Even many atheists change their life, ceasing to commit gross moral transgressions and passing to the life of a “normal man.” What — is that also the action of the “god of atheism”? Of course not. Simply the action of conscience awakens in the man, and the devil departs from him, so that the proud consciousness of his righteousness may hinder such a “righteous man” from entering the true Church of Christ and receiving in her real deliverance from sin and forgiveness.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — But I was at a meeting of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, and know their life. They live in sins just as all the rest. They are not free from the power of sin.

Orthodox priest: — They say they are free.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — But we are free. But it is not our merit; it is the action of Christ. “By their fruits you shall know them”…

Orthodox priest: — I have conversed many times with Baptists who testify that in their assembly (I am not acquainted with your assembly) there happen people who commit adultery.

(Speaker): I shall tell you even a terrible story, unpleasant, but nevertheless. A man who knows the situation told it. One woman who went to a Baptist assembly sinned, went on a spree, and became pregnant. And she, somehow with shame, but nevertheless confessed it before all. She was excommunicated from communion for a certain time. Then she repented; they pointed a finger at her for a long time yet. She humbled herself, but nevertheless so lived. And she afterwards told her friend that the other fellow-believers — the other women — quietly sympathized with her, and in the process of all this public condemnation they said: you fool (forgive me) — a fool. She would have had an abortion and nothing would have been to you.

(Speaker): So — what do I wish to say? Here we see, first, the deadly sin — that she committed adultery. Second, others, for some sort of human respect, pushed her to another deadly sin. Is that holiness? I am ready to agree that in your congregation there is none of this. I do not know you. But in other congregations such a thing happens very often.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — I shall tell you: we have fleshly life. Among our believers sins are met. And when certain sins come out in our churches, we put under doubt: perhaps this man was not born again? Even if he repented, even repented in the church, and was baptized. But the Holy Spirit, probably, never touched him. And such a man we excommunicate from the church, yes. And we acknowledge. But those people who are free from the power of sin — did they free themselves? We believe — only Christ.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — We know many moral atheists. Did they revive themselves from the power of fleshly sin? Or who? Themselves.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Then a question. Whence did personal faith come in you?

Orthodox priest: — Each has his own life history… The Lord touched the heart of each.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But how did He touch you? What happened? Here you lived personally as all. Did a meeting with Christ take place? How did it take place?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — With everyone differently. Someone through illness; someone was believing from childhood. With someone sorrows happened; someone himself wished to come to Christ. It is written the Lord knocks at all. Someone felt this was important for him…

Baptist: (Speaker): — But this moment all the same exists? From an unbelieving life, your free life — and afterwards a life pleasing to God went, yes? This moment, the watershed?

Orthodox priest: — Well, you know, with us it is different. Many people are in the Church with us from childhood, and they did not so acutely experience this power of sin over themselves. And with them simply calm spiritual growth. But some… here how I shall say of myself. I lived in childhood outside the Orthodox Church. And afterwards somehow I understood I very much needed and this was important. And I see such a watershed for myself. Each sees it in his own way.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Well, look: the attitude changed toward faith in God, or the attitude toward Christ?

Orthodox priest: — The attitude changed toward everything. I was blind — I received sight. What is unclear here?! Do you not understand this, or what?

Baptist: (Speaker): — I understand.

Orthodox priest: — Then what are you asking?

Baptist: (Speaker): — I understand. That is why I say: did this take place in baptism?

Orthodox priest: — No, of course. I was baptized in childhood.

Baptist: (Speaker): — So it took place much later?

Orthodox priest: — Much later, yes.

Baptist: Baptist pastor: — Much later. So in baptism it turns out a man, you personally, did not receive sight…

Orthodox priest: — In me was placed the spiritual seed… I understood your thought… You understand wrongly the word “rebirth.” Rebirth is not that you became perfect…

Baptist: (Speaker): — Not perfect…

Orthodox: (Speaker): — In baptism a man receives spiritual eyes. That is the seed that fell into the earth. And further precisely of the earth it depends how this seed will grow. That is, of the personal will of man. At first I hindered the growth of the seed…

Baptist: (Speaker): — But this seed… the word of God — does it act?

Orthodox priest: — That is not the word of God; that is the grace of God.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Very well — grace. Does it act on the heart of a man?

Orthodox priest: — Without doubt, but the heart hinders this seed. And afterwards, with time, I understood I was wrong; I sinned. And I tried to do so as not to hinder God, that He act in me. But the seed was laid on the day of baptism.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Well, what influenced your decision? Precisely not to hinder God, but to live in the divine way?

Orthodox priest: — The feeling that earlier I lived wrongly; the desire to be with God. And I am sure that was the call of God.

Baptist: (Speaker): — This is precisely the regenerating action of the Holy Spirit. Simply — why do we speak so: if our repentance (at once with baptism or not at once with baptism) did not come from a meeting with Christ, that Christ opened the eyes, did not change the attitude to the person of Jesus Christ — well, and in general to God, but first of all to the person of Jesus Christ — then it is dead faith. Let it be called Baptist, Orthodox, Catholic — this man may be in any church. Now the second moment… The forgiveness of sins. What is it needed by man for?

Orthodox priest: — On the first moment — you contradict yourselves. Before this you showed the significance of the fruits of faith — that is, deeds. And now you say, as the main criterion — and now you say rightly — that a man changes in his attitude to God.

Baptist: (Speaker): — He changes. We said it at once: “He will convict the world of sin, that they believe not in Me.”

Orthodox priest: — The Holy Spirit does that. I speak of the man, not of the Holy Spirit. That is, it turns out the fruits, the deeds, which the Adventists have, and the Jehovah’s Witnesses, and the Mormons, and everyone who will say: I was a sinner, became a righteous man… — with the Pentecostals crowds come out and say it from the stage. It is a commonplace with them. That is, these deeds, the changes of outward life, are less important than the inward changes. But we have already established — as you rightly said — that if a man seemingly repented outwardly, seemingly had the Holy Spirit, and afterwards it turned out he sins — then he did not repent, then he was not born again.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But outward deeds proceed from within, do they not?

Orthodox priest: — Yes, the Lord says so: from the heart.

Baptist: (Speaker): — From the heart proceed these deeds: as he inwardly thinks, so it is expressed in deeds. So — the forgiveness of sins — for what does it take place?

Orthodox priest: — In order that I, having received power over sin, may conquer it further. Is it not so?

Baptist: (Speaker): — And further — for eternity, what does it give?

Orthodox priest: — Well, if I was born, I shall live in eternity as one born; if I was not born, I am blind and dead, and shall go to hell.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But in relations with Jesus? I simply direct the thought. In relation to Jesus — the forgiveness of sins, your personal forgiveness of sins — what did it give for relations with Jesus?

Orthodox priest: — You mix somewhat… Simon the sorcerer believed, was baptized, received the Holy Spirit, and…

Baptist: (Speaker): — He did not receive the Holy Spirit yet… There it is written he brought money to receive it…

Orthodox priest: — Shall I show you the text? If you have forgotten, I shall show…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes, please… While you look, I wish to ask another participant: do you have the Holy Spirit?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And when did you receive Him?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — In baptism.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Were you baptized in childhood?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And since then He acted? Performed His work in you?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — As long as you remember yourself, were you always a churched person?

Orthodox: (Speaker): No.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Then, when you grew up, you nevertheless went into the world…

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And where did the Holy Spirit go when you went into the world? Was He in your heart?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And manifested Himself in no way?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — He manifested Himself in certain events, in my conscience…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And did He not leave you?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — He did not leave.

Baptist: (Speaker): — A good answer. Thank you.

Orthodox priest: — So: “Now when the apostles who were at Jerusalem heard that Samaria had received the word of God, they sent Peter and John to them, who, when they had come down, prayed for them that they might receive the Holy Spirit. For as yet He had fallen upon none of them (I shall explain why — Philip was a deacon; he had no right to lay hands, to give the Holy Spirit). They had only been baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. Then they laid hands on them, and they received the Holy Spirit.” So — Simon is one of them. Further: “And when Simon saw that through the laying on of the apostles’ hands the Holy Spirit was given, he offered them money, saying: give me this power also, that anyone on whom I lay hands may receive the Holy Spirit” (Acts 8:14–19). As we see, they were baptized…

Baptist: (Speaker): — So he did not receive the Holy Spirit?

Orthodox priest: — He wished to receive the power to transmit it to others for money. But he himself received the Holy Spirit, of course, as the Samaritans did.

Baptist: (Speaker): — If we take it thus — the Holy Spirit is the everlasting God?

Orthodox priest: — Yes, of course; we believe it.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Can you say that a man filled with the Holy Spirit goes and wishes to buy power for money, to rule over others… That says he did not receive the Holy Spirit…

Orthodox priest: — But herein is the point — here is opened… Can a man filled with the Holy Spirit fall away?

Baptist: (Speaker): — Filled at the given moment cannot fall away. I shall explain. Tell me — is darkness here?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Well, somewhere there is; here there is a shadow…

Baptist: (Speaker): — And by what is it swallowed up? By light! When a man is filled with the Holy Spirit, he cannot fall away! A man falls away not being filled with the Holy Spirit.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — May I ask? Are you now filled with the Holy Spirit?

Baptist: (Speaker): — Now? Well, the Lord fills…

Orthodox: (Speaker): — So you cannot fall away?

Baptist: (Speaker): — If the Lord fills, a man cannot fall away.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — You assert that you in principle cannot fall away — that it is impossible?

Baptist: (Speaker): — Let us do this: now I shall come up, press the switch, and the light goes out. Say — did darkness envelop?

Orthodox priest: — Yes, of course.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But in five minutes I do not know what will be…

Orthodox priest: — So — can you, after all?

Baptist: (Speaker): — A man falls away not being filled with God…

Orthodox priest: — By his own will he may fall away from God. So Simon received, and afterwards fell away…

Baptist: (Speaker): — So he was not, it means, filled…

Orthodox priest: — But here it is written — all received the Holy Spirit… And he too. All received.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Very well; let it be so.

Orthodox priest: — Agreed.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — If Christ today came, would He take you to Himself?

Orthodox priest: — You make me decide for Christ some very difficult questions. I should not dare to take upon myself such a function.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — So you have no such assurance?

Orthodox priest: — That Christ will come today? I see signs in Holy Scripture which say He cannot come today.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No — that He will take you… today, if your life should end — would you enter paradise or not?

Orthodox priest: — I hope for it…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — So you have no assurance?

Orthodox priest: — There is none and cannot be, of course.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — And none of you has assurance?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — We have hope.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Only hope?

Orthodox priest: — The apostle says: “we were saved in this hope” (Romans 8:24). You repeat the question you put to us at the first meeting.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Because different people, a different faith…

Orthodox priest: — No — look: you yourselves answered the same way.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No.

Orthodox priest: — When I asked whether it may happen that you find yourselves outside salvation, you said: yes, it may be. You admit it. Wherein is our difference with you in this question — it is (perhaps it is not good to speak so) — but the Orthodox think about this more humbly. We have no right to decide for God. Yes, we hope Christ will accept me; we hope and believe He will give us the life of the age to come; but we cannot be assured of it, because one thing is human judgment, and another the Judgment of God. As the Lord says that “not everyone who says to Me, Lord, Lord, shall enter the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 7:21). That is, I say: I may perform wonders, I may preach — but, as Scripture says, the Lord may say to you: “depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness; I never knew you” (Matthew 7:23). Although the man may be persuaded that he serves God and follows Him. But that is only our judgment, human; and quite another thing is the Judgment of God. Therefore we do not dare judge ourselves. Because in the Gospel of John the Lord Jesus Christ says clearly that “the Father has committed all judgment to the Son” (John 5:22). And the Son judges us all. Therefore, when we begin to judge ourselves and say I am saved, and he is not saved — or even of another — that is already daring…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — If you asked me, I should answer: “I am assured that if Christ came today, I should be in paradise.”

Orthodox priest: — We sympathize with you, sympathize very much… One wishes to wish: God grant it be so… that your own judgment coincide with God’s.

Orthodox: (Speaker): — May I add: the apostle Paul said “I do not even judge myself” (1 Corinthians 4:3) — while you pronounce judgment on yourself. To be assured one is saved is a judgment about oneself. As a man you pronounced judgment on yourself.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Do you believe in every word written in the Gospel? That it is God-inspired Holy Scripture?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — Yes.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — You do not doubt any text?

Orthodox: (Speaker): — No.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — (1 John 5:11–13): “This testimony is that God has given us everlasting life, and this life is in His Son. He who has the Son of God has life; he who does not have the Son of God has no life. These things I have written to you, who believe in the name of God, that you may know that you, believing in the Son of God, have everlasting life.” Already “have.” Do you have now everlasting life? Everlasting life is paradise.

Orthodox priest: — Yes, of course, we have now everlasting life. I shall explain, so that it be clear to you. Say, how does a man enter everlasting life. For example, the Eucharist — the Body and Blood of Christ — they give a man participation in everlasting life. But you have not the Body and Blood of Christ — do I understand rightly — you believe they are symbols. So, through your symbols you symbolically receive everlasting life, while we through real communion receive it really.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — No — we not through symbols and not through real transubstantiation, but through the sacrifice of Jesus Christ we receive everlasting life.

Orthodox priest: — I have heard you; but according to the text of the Gospel of John, chapter six, it is written that precisely the Body and Blood of Christ give everlasting life. We so understand everlasting life — Baptism regenerates us; Chrismation gives the gifts of the Holy Spirit…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — So you must be ten times more assured that you will be there than we…

Orthodox priest: — Right, right…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — If you say you have grace, you have succession…

Orthodox priest: — You said that very precisely…

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — We have nothing, but we believe in the sacrifice of Christ and are assured of our salvation.

Orthodox priest: — You said rightly — but there is a nuance you do not take into account. Allow me to say?

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Yes.

Orthodox priest: — The point is the Holy Spirit acts in us, and He is very humble, and teaches us the same humility.

Baptist pastor: Baptist pastor: — Clear. Then a question to the Orthodox sister. Are you married?

Orthodox: — I am married.

Baptist: (Speaker): — And are you sure of your husband — that at any moment, when you come up to him, he receives you with joy? At any moment?

Orthodox: — No.

Baptist: (Speaker): — Does he not love you? And are you not sure of him? What — if he does not receive you; that he is disposed to you, that you are his wife and he your husband, his heart is open?

Orthodox priest: — But if he is tired, if he is angry?

Orthodox: — I shall answer: I believe him, but am not sure of him. For how can one be assured of some man at all, if in Scripture it is said: “Do not put your trust in princes, nor in a son of man, in whom there is no salvation” (Psalm 146:3).

Baptist: (Speaker): — All the same you go to your husband…

Orthodox: — I have hope…

Baptist: (Speaker): — He receives you, right… You believe he loves you…

Orthodox: — I believe him, his word — but I am not sure…

Baptist: (Speaker): — That there in two days… that you said rightly… Why assurance in a Christian? At the given moment. We do not speak of through a year — perhaps someone will fall away. Because the man believes Christ loves him; between him and Christ nothing stands; therefore, if now He come, I shall be with Him. Do you understand wherein is assurance? Just as you believe your husband — here now nothing stands between you — you go with joy.

Orthodox: — I do not doubt God — His mercy, His love, His judgment. I do not doubt God. Therefore I have assurance in God; assurance in man — I have not.

Baptist: (Speaker): — I understand.

Orthodox: — What judgment He will pronounce concerning me, I do not know — because only He knows.

Baptist: (Speaker): — But He loves you?

Orthodox: — Yes, He loves all.

Baptist: (Speaker): — No — you personally? Why do I say… Because when I went to Christ, Christ drew; I said: “Lord, it does not matter to me that you love all — do You love me?” When the Lord revealed Himself. And it was revealed that He loves me personally — and from early childhood the whole life opened thus — then I already received clarity and assurance that He loves me personally. For you are assured your husband loves you personally? And that makes you simply go to him openly. Well, simply converse, and that is all… So here — the assurance that He loves allows me to think that if now my life be cut short, I shall find myself in His embrace. Because between me and Him nothing stands; but if something stands — I sin, do not wish to live by Him — then yes, He loves, but I do not. Therefore, if two persons, God and man, love one another…

Orthodox: (Speaker): — And do you love God now?

Baptist: (Speaker): — Glory to God, yes!

Orthodox: (Speaker): — You do not sin?

Baptist: (Speaker): — Why do I not sin? I do sin if — the Lord draws — I say: Lord, only let nothing be broken, because I love. Do you understand — between a man born again and one not born again precisely this love stands as the measure. If a man loves not the Lord — it is written — anathema. All shall appear with Him, “those who have loved His appearing” (2 Timothy 4:8).

Orthodox priest: — I propose we end the discussion on this. Better to converse on this specially, since it is a complex theme.

90
منتشر شده توسط کاربر: Rodion Vlasov
تاریخ ایجاد صفحه: 2024-06-24, به‌روزرسانی: 2026-11-17