4th century
St John Chrysostom, archbishop of Constantinople (c. 347–407)
If he has departed even as a sinner, we must for this very reason rejoice, because his sins have been cut off and his wickedness has ceased to grow; and moreover, we must help him as far as possible, not with tears, but with prayers, supplications, alms and oblations. For not without cause was this devised, not in vain do we make memorial of the departed in the divine Mysteries and draw near with prayer on their behalf to the Lamb that lies before us, who takes away the sin of the world, but in order that some comfort may come to them from this; and not in general does he that stands by the altar, when the awesome Mysteries are being celebrated, exclaim: “For all those who have fallen asleep in Christ, and for those who make their memorials”. For if their memorials were not for them, this would not be said. For our ministry is not a spectacle, – God forbid, – but this takes place by the command of the Spirit. Let us help them and make memorial of them. If the sons of Job were purified by the sacrifice of their father, do you doubt that some comfort comes to the departed when we make oblations on their behalf? God is accustomed to have thanksgiving offered by some for others; Paul also pointed this out, saying: “that by the intercession of many, thanks may be given by many for us for the gift bestowed upon us” (2 Cor. 1:11). Let us not grow weary of helping the departed and of offering perfect prayers on their behalf. For there lies before us the universal purification of the universe. Therefore let us boldly pray then for the universe and call them together with the martyrs, the confessors, the priests, for we are all one body, though some members are more excellent than others, and it is possible in every way to bring down upon them forbearance – through the prayers, through the gifts offered for them, through those who are called together with them. Why then do you grieve, why do you weep, when it is possible to bring down such forbearance upon the departed?
<…>
Shall we not strive to rescue him from dangers? It is possible, it is possible, if only we wish, to lighten his punishment.
Let us make constant prayers for him, let us give alms – and even if he were unworthy, God will be merciful through us. If Paul spared and showed mercy to one for the sake of others, then all the more must we do this. Whether from his money, or from your own, from whatever you will, but help, pour out oil – or rather, water.
<…>
set up widows, proclaim the name, command all to offer prayers and supplications on his behalf; this will propitiate God. Though it was not done by themselves, another has become the author of almsgiving for his sake, and that too is a work of divine philanthropy.
<…>
Knowing this, let us consider what consolations we might bring to the departed: instead of tears, instead of lamentations, instead of memorial meals – alms, prayers, oblations, that both they and we may attain the promised blessings, by the grace and philanthropy of the Only-begotten Son
(Homily 45. That we should not labour excessively over the mourning of the dead)
11th century
Blessed Theophylact of Bulgaria, archbishop of Ohrid (2nd half of the 11th c. – early 12th c.)
But one must fear Him who punishes not only the body, but subjects the soul, an immortal being, to endless torments, and that in fire. Thus Christ teaches His friends spiritual courage, makes them witnesses, and drives human fear away from them. Men, He says, extend their malice only to the corruptible body, and the end of their wiles against us is the death of the flesh. But when God punishes, He does not stop at the flesh alone, but the very unhappy soul is subjected to torments. Mark from this that death brings sinners to punishment: they are punished here, being slain, and there are cast into gehenna. – Examining this saying, you will understand something else as well. See, the Lord did not say: fear him “who” after killing “casts” into gehenna, but: “who is able” to cast. For sinners who die are not necessarily cast into gehenna, but it lies in the power of God both to forgive, for example, for the sake of those oblations and almsgivings which are made for the departed and which bring no small benefit even to those who die in grievous sins. Thus God does not unconditionally cast into gehenna after killing, but has the power to cast.
(Commentary on the Gospel according to Luke, 12)
20th century
Dmitry Vladykov, protopresbyter (1863–1955)
“For for this cause was the gospel preached also to them that are dead, that they might be judged according to men in the flesh, but live according to God in the spirit” (1 Pet. 4:6; cf. 1 Pet. 3:19–20). “When the Lord visited those in hades”, remarks Blessed Theophylact, – “some, who had lived in this world according to the flesh, were condemned, while others, who had lived spiritually, either rose together with the Lord, for many bodies of the saints that slept arose (Matt. 27:52), or came to life with good hope”. If the lot of the departed were unchangeable until the universal judgment, the Lord would not have preached the gospel to them. “Whosoever shall speak a word against the Son of Man (seeing His humiliation), it shall be forgiven him (for this is a sin of error, of weakness, washed away by repentance); but whosoever speaketh against the Holy Spirit, it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, neither in the world to come” (Matt. 12:32). “This He said, because they said: He hath an unclean spirit” (Mark 3:30). “What then do these words mean? This”, explains St John Chrysostom, – “that the sin against the Holy Spirit is above all unforgivable. Why? Because they did not know who Christ was; but they had already received sufficient knowledge about the Spirit. Thus the prophets spoke, speaking by the inspiration of the Spirit, and in the Old Testament all had a very clear concept of Him. Therefore the words of Christ have such a meaning: let you be offended at Me because of the flesh in which I am clothed; but can you say also of the Spirit that you do not know Him? That is why your blasphemy will be unforgivable, and here and there you will bear punishment for it... The Holy Spirit is known to you, yet you are not ashamed to reject the evident truth. If you say that you do not know Me, then you doubtless know that casting out devils and performing healings is the work of the Holy Spirit. Therefore you blaspheme not Me only, but the Holy Spirit also; therefore your punishment, both here and there, is inevitable”. The expression “neither in the world to come” points to the possibility of the forgiveness of sins in the world beyond the grave, and consequently to the change of the lot of the departed. It would have no meaning to say “neither in the world to come” if after death there were no forgiveness.
(The Orthodox Church and the Sectarians, part 2)