Priest Evgeny Veselov

Apostolic Succession — Dispute between Orthodox Christians and Baptists

Maandishi haya yanapatikana kwa lugha zingine:

(Kostroma, March 12, 2024)

Participants in the dispute:

On the Orthodox side — Priest Evgeny Veselov, Alan Bedoev (speaker), and others.

On the Baptist side — Pastor Sergei Antonovich Didovets (speaker), and others.

Comments by Priest Evgeny Veselov.

*For ease of reading, the text has undergone minimal literary editing.

Audio version of the dispute: https://rutube.ru/video/8de534f9c454bb33b4174d70a1ed59f6/

Report of the Orthodox side (Alan Bedoev)

Orthodox (speaker): Let us begin. Reflecting on the topic of the historical succession of the Church, I think it is appropriate first to recall and bring to mind the original fundamental qualities of the Church, which we draw from Holy Scripture.

As the Word of God — the Bible — tells us, the Lord Jesus Christ laid the beginning and foundation of the Church, choosing the apostles from among His hearers. The apostles and a few believers, united by one faith and one teaching, made up the original Church of Christ.

The Bible also tells us that the Lord and Master of the universe, at a certain historical moment, out of His great mercy and superabundant love, did not wish to leave His creation in its plight; He inclined the heavens and came down.

As Gregory of Nyssa says — we have such a saint — a man, seeing a drowning child in a raging river, does not even think that he will get dirty there, be covered in filth, be battered against the stones; he leaps in and saves the person.

In like manner our Lord Jesus Christ, although He knew that He would certainly die, took the form of a defenseless servant and redeemed mankind from sin, from the curse of death, from the power of sin and the devil. But so that man might appropriate the fruits of the redemptive sacrifice, the Lord sends the Holy Spirit into the world, upon His disciples. It is precisely at this moment that they become the Body of Christ — they become the Church.

Before the sending of the Holy Spirit they were not yet the Church, since they did not yet have His divine power, everything needful for life and godliness, as the apostle Peter tells us (2 Peter 1:3).

So, the Lord created the Church — this is so far only a little background, but it is necessary… The Lord created the Church and appointed it to stand unshaken from age to age; He gave it a definite structure, a clearly built hierarchy, and the sacraments for the sanctification of the faithful.

Having created the church, the Lord made it the place of salvation, a kind of new-covenant Noah’s ark: entering into which, a person could already attain his salvation.

He entrusted it to guard the purity of divine teaching and to become a kind of keeper of the teaching of Christ. It is said: the church of the living God is the pillar and ground of the truth (1 Timothy 3:15). That is, the Church will be the keeper of absolute truth, and the gates of hell will never be able to overcome it. What does this mean? It means that in whatever persecutions it finds itself, whatever difficulties it endures, however it is beset by all manner of heresies, it will still stand firm, and the truth will abide within it unshaken.

Why? Because the Lord Jesus Christ will always be at the helm and will never abandon it. With this, everything seems clear.

Going further, it is important to note that the Church of Christ has, and always has had, an outward side, and was visible to the people around it in the historical perspective. This too is an inseparable attribute of the true Church of Christ.

And, while being inwardly invisible — since the Holy Spirit and the Lord Jesus Christ invisibly dwell and act within it — on the outward side it was always visible to the people around it. Visibly, for example, people entered the Church through baptism; visibly they gathered for prayer; visibly the divine services were performed; the church hierarchy was visible, and so on. If the church had at some period been invisible, then people who wished to save their souls simply could not have joined themselves to it — which would be absurd, foolish.

Also, in that case it could not have been distinguished from other religious communities that would have presented themselves as the Church at that time. A city that is set on a hill cannot be hidden, the Lord tells us (Matthew 5:14).

Also, speaking of the properties of the Church, one cannot fail to note a key aspect which is directly traceable in Scripture: the factor of continuity. The church is continuous from the moment of its creation to our days, and to the end of the ages. We read in the Gospels: I am with you always, even to the end of the age (Matthew 28:20) — this is Matthew telling us. The evangelist John also notes this in his Gospel; it is said (John 14:16): I will pray the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may abide with you forever. The apostle Paul confirms the same in (Ephesians 3:21): To Him be glory in the church by Christ Jesus throughout all ages, world without end.

The church stands firm for the reason, as I said earlier, that its Head is, and always will be, the Lord Jesus Christ.

Let us go further. Jesus Christ, although He said that His followers, the people who believe in Him, would receive the Holy Spirit in abundance, at first promised to send — and, as we know from the Bible, did send — the Holy Spirit only upon the apostles.

Why is this said? The church was hierarchical from the beginning. God poured out the Holy Spirit on the apostles alone with the purpose that they, filled with the Spirit, might be a kind of instruments or mediators in the transmission of the Holy Spirit to other believers.

Therefore, at first only to them alone was given the right to perform the church sacraments. For example, baptism. It is said in (Matthew 28:19), the well-known verse: Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.

We know that the Lord gave this commission precisely to the apostles alone, not to all believers. It was precisely the Lord who established the Sacrament of Communion, the breaking of bread — likewise gathering precisely the twelve disciples, not all His followers. And He entrusted them to celebrate this sacrament also to the end of the age. It was precisely to the apostles that the Lord commanded to forgive sins, and He gave them authority for this.

So we read (John 20:21–23): Jesus said to them again: Peace to you! As the Father has sent Me, I also send you. And when He had said this, He breathed on them, and said to them: Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained. Note here that the transmission by Christ of the Holy Spirit to the twelve, of which this biblical passage speaks, is connected, on the one hand, with apostleship, with being sent. The Lord Himself, being sent from the Father, sends the apostles and gives them for this certain powers, authority, and grace.

And the apostles will later send their successors not simply: “There — here is what is written for you, go,” but they will also transmit to them definite powers and strength for this. But we will see this further from the biblical texts. And the second side of this verse, as before, confirms that the Lord gave this gift not to all believers, but precisely to the apostles alone.

In general, it is important to note that the Bible directly distinguishes the clergy and the laity, the shepherds from the flock, those who rule from those who are subject.

There is truly an ocean of such texts, and one could parse them for a long time, but for lack of time let us touch at least on some. I will cite the best-known verses. (1 Timothy 5:17): Let the elders who rule well be counted worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in the word and doctrine.

It is obvious that in the Church some are those who rule, who speak the word of God, who are the elders, while others are those who hear this word of God, and who are obliged to render honor to those who spoke. This is evident from this text.

Or here is another verse: Therefore take heed to yourselves and to all the flock, among which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers (that is, bishops) to shepherd the church of the Lord and God, which He purchased with His own blood (Acts 20:28). This place, as we see, also speaks clearly: there are shepherds, and there is the flock which must be shepherded and guarded. With this, too, everything seems clear.

The apostles, invested with the power of the Holy Spirit — as we read in the Bible — also received from the Lord authority not only to communicate Christ’s grace to believers through the church Sacraments: baptism, Communion, and confession, as I touched on this theme earlier, but also, through ordination, to pass on to their successors the powers and strength, to bring down the grace-bearing gifts — which they did, establishing in hierarchical order deacons, presbyters, and bishops. Again it is important: this sacred rite — we speak of ordination — is not some empty, formal ceremony. But it, as the Bible tells us, is the form of the transmission of authority, transmitted from the apostles precisely to their successors, as we will now see from the further texts.

The apostle Paul, instructing Timothy, said the following words… A most famous text: Do not neglect the gift that is in you, which was given to you by prophecy with the laying on of the hands of the eldership (1 Timothy 4:14). That is, Timothy received from the apostle not simply a formal appointment to the office of pastor, as usually happens in Protestantism and Baptism. People sit, choose a certain person, appoint him pastor, and that is all — from that time he is a priest, a pastor, may govern, and so on. No: Timothy, besides the juridical appointment to this office, received with the laying on of hands a certain gift as well, of which Paul speaks in other places of Holy Scripture too. For example: I remind you to stir up the gift of God which is in you through the laying on of my hands (2 Timothy 1:6).

When I was a Protestant, we always held that there is a set of qualities of a presbyter, a deacon, a bishop: that he must be the husband of one wife, not a drunkard, not a killer, hospitable, gentle, peaceable, and so on.

And that if the community has such a person, this means the Holy Spirit has chosen such a person for the role of presbyter, and we must simply legitimize him — simply place him before the assembly, say that we have acknowledged him, and appoint him to the office. This is what we always thought and held. But it turns out nothing of the kind.

A great many Christians may in fact possess these qualities, but not all are called to the priesthood, and not all have the powers, the right, and the strength for it at all. It turns out that this gift — the gift of the priesthood, of which the apostle Paul speaks — is communicated through ordination. And these qualities described in the pastoral epistles simply say that there are people who possess these qualities and are worthy of this gift of the priesthood. And there are people who simply do not possess these qualities, and who need to strive toward these biblical norms.

In the end, for what did Simon the sorcerer want to give money to the apostles? Really for some formalism? He could easily have forged the document; he could even have spread the rumor that the apostles had authorized him to perform something — he knew how to deceive. But he wanted to receive the real power that the apostles transmitted to their successors, and which (this power) he, of course, had observed.

Therefore hierarchy is a divine institution that makes it possible to preserve the lawful succession of apostolic authority, teaching, grace-bearing gifts, and sacred rite. The presence of a lawful hierarchical ministry is a necessary, though not the only, condition of the Church’s being.

When a given religious community lacks this grace-bearing hereditary connection with the apostles, which, as we see, is transmitted through ordination, then consequently with this absence there is also absent the right, and the authority, and, in fact, the saving grace. And this is a biblical principle. If there is no inheritance, if there is no organic connection, no kindred participation in the Church of Christ, then naturally there is no salvation either.

It is the same as if, after Bill Gates’ death, I came to a notary and, in the presence of his blood relatives sitting there, began to declare and say that I too am an heir, because I read his book.

And no matter how much I told them how good I am, how my moral standards are higher than those of his blood children, and so on, it would be like laughingstock for the hens, and I would, of course, receive nothing. To be an heir, one must have organic belonging — in this case, to the Church.

So, the New Testament church, with one faith, one teaching, one structure, with a verified hierarchy and a single succession of ordination from the apostles, began to become a mother for other local churches.

So it lived and spread immeasurably for a thousand years. Being the keeper, as I said earlier, of the true teaching, it gathered the seven Ecumenical Councils, at which it affirmed truth and rejected falsehood — that is, heresy.

But the enemy of the human race, the devil, of course, did not want to be reconciled to this, did not want to see the Church crushing his power over the people, and decided to destroy the first of the churches of the world — just as he himself fell, being the first of the angels.

He raised up in the West a heresy against the Holy Spirit and cast down into the abyss the pride of the Roman bishop — that is, a heresy appeared. Thus began the lamentable division, which continues to this day. The pope demanded for himself the fullness not only of ecclesiastical but also of state power. If we are already running ahead — going further and further — the more, the worse: as we know, sin has a certain tendency to gather speed. Having begun to distort Tradition, they went further: they began to say that the pope is the vicar of Christ on earth; the dogma of purgatory appeared, where, supposedly, people pay for their unredeemed sins; the dogma of the Immaculate Conception of the Mother of God; indulgences, and so on.

But, returning to the topic: a heresy against the Holy Spirit appeared, and in the end, as we all know, in the eleventh century the final schism took place.

The Roman church, which is now called Catholic, fell away from the Church, from the source of grace, thereby depriving itself of spiritual life. Here: if a branch breaks off from a tree and falls, it is deprived of that life-giving sap which nourishes, and simply dries up. And the same thing happened precisely with the Roman Catholics.

Of course, formally they still have certain rudiments of apostolic succession to this day.

But it is necessary to understand that apostolic succession is not reduced simply to ordination from bishop to bishop; it also implies the transmission of the saving, uncorrupted teaching, “which was once for all delivered to the saints,” as the apostle Jude says (Jude 1:3).

Five centuries after this monstrous tragedy, in 1517, the Catholic church gives birth to the Reformation, and the first Protestants come into the world.

What was I leading to with all this? Here it is important again to pay attention to the analogy I gave, of the tree and the broken-off branch. The Protestants are born not from the Church, but precisely from the broken-off, life-deprived branch — that is, from a schismatic organization which in itself, at that time, already had no grace at all, being torn away from the Church of Christ.

In other words, Protestantism, by the very fact of its birth, was already spiritually dead and deprived of Christ’s grace because of the absence of connection with the Apostolic Church, which is the source of grace.

By and large, here, in fact, it no longer matters… we will not go deep — whether they are Lutherans, Calvinists, Baptists, Mormons, Methodists, charismatics, Pentecostals, and so on, and so on. The fact is one: If the firstfruit is holy, the lump is also holy; and if the root is holy, so are the branches (Romans 11:16), the Word of God tells us. In exactly the same way one can conclude: if the firstfruit is dead, then also the whole, then also the branches.

Therefore the Church of Christ has a clear structure, boundaries established by God. Again — this is not some invention of the Orthodox, of tradition and so forth; we read all of it in the Bible. Historical participation in the Apostolic Church is, according to the Bible, a necessary condition for the salvation of a person.

In the context of our dialogue: Baptism, despite its many positive qualities… They truly exist. They exist — and, by the way, even visiting various organizations of the city, I repeatedly heard that many of you are known for your virtues: you helped to do something on Lagernaya Street, I found out recently. In general, there are very many positive sides. From some of them one could even learn. But all the same, by the points set out above, your organization cannot be the heir of the promises of Christ.

First, because of the absence of lawful succession. Second — because of corrupted faith. Third, — the very origin from spiritually dead schismatics.

For us it is unbearable sorrow that between us there are such divisions. But while we are alive, each person can change this in a private way. As for Orthodoxy — here no questions arise at all; I did not even write about this.

Anyone who wishes, this very day, can trace the apostolic succession from Patriarch Kirill to the apostle Andrew. Anyone who wishes can trace the apostolic succession of faith, of the purity of the faith of Orthodoxy — for example, take the present-day Orthodox teaching and open the sources of, say, the second century. Or the first century. The teaching is identical — that is, it all lies on the surface.

And therefore I thank you for your attention, and I would like someday to receive Communion with you.

Orthodox priest: In an Orthodox church.

Baptist: Come to us.

Orthodox priest: In an Orthodox church.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Thank you for the interesting report. Probably I will manage in the same spirit as Alan did today.

Orthodox priest: Excellent.

Report of the Baptist side (Pastor Sergei Antonovich Didovets)

Let us read from the Gospel — the book of Revelation, chapter 3, verses 7 through 11: And to the angel of the church in Philadelphia write: These things says He who is holy, He who is true, He who has the key of David, He who opens and no one shuts, and shuts and no one opens: I know your works. See, I have set before you an open door, and no one can shut it; for you have a little strength, have kept My word, and have not denied My name. Indeed I will make those of the synagogue of Satan, who say they are Jews and are not, but lie — indeed I will make them come and worship before your feet, and to know that I have loved you. Because you have kept My command to persevere, I also will keep you from the hour of trial which shall come upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth. Behold, I am coming quickly! Hold fast what you have, that no one may take your crown (Revelation 3:7–11).

Probably all the churches to which Christ addresses Himself through the apostle John were founded as a result of the ministry of the apostle Paul.

But Christ, addressing the presbyters and the churches, never once mentions Paul as His successor or as the man who was to pass the succession on to others. Christ praises the Philadelphians for having kept His word and calls them to hold fast what they have — to keep holding this word. The word “succession” or “successiveness” does not occur in the New Testament.

Jesus and the apostles did not teach successiveness. The only succession that we can see on the pages of Holy Scripture is the handing on of the Word of God to people.

In the Gospel of Matthew, 28:19, Christ says to His disciples: Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations (Matthew 28:19). They were to take the word they had received from Christ and teach it to other peoples. Mark 16:15: Go… and preach the gospel to every creature (Mark 16:15). And Paul, when instructing his disciple Timothy, said: the things that you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit these to faithful men who will be able to teach others also (2 Timothy 2:2). So, it is this succession that the Baptists acknowledge.

The word that Christ spoke to the apostles, they received, assimilated, digested, and passed on undamaged to other people, to their disciples, who subsequently passed it on from generation to generation. The heart of God’s word is the Gospel.

The Orthodox church does not preach the Gospel, since it does not itself believe in it. I drew this conclusion from our previous meetings. No matter how many times we met, and no matter how we — I and my brothers, my helpers — tried to learn how sure you are of your salvation, the Orthodox always answered — that is, all of you present at the meetings — that you are not sure you have eternal life.

You have a hope of salvation, but there is no assurance of salvation. And the Gospel gives birth to assurance of salvation. What is the Gospel? The Gospel is the good news about Christ, and especially about the last days of Christ’s earthly life. This assurance in us is based on what Christ did, dying on the cross of Golgotha. His sacrifice, the substitutionary sacrifice, is the heart of the Gospel. If we believe that we cannot save ourselves and that because of our sins we have deserved hell, then we must turn to the One who can save us. And this Savior is Christ.

He came to earth precisely, as Alan said, to take the sins of all mankind upon Himself, including our personal sins, and to die for us, and that the sins be nailed to the cross. There, on the cross, our old man was crucified too — our old Adamic nature.

And if we believe this with all our heart, then straight from the Cross we receive the forgiveness of sins — of those we have committed, both the terrible sins we have committed and the less important sins that lay on our conscience. We receive liberation from the feeling of guilt, we receive salvation from the power of sin. And this is precisely the Gospel.

That is, if I believe in the Gospel, if I believe with all my heart in my Savior Jesus Christ, then I believe that Christ took all my sins away from me and nailed them to the Cross. I believe that He forgave me, and, having forgiven, He entered my heart by the Holy Spirit. Therefore He is my Savior, and I am His child. I have the new birth.

Comment: Here is set out the Baptist version of the teaching of salvation by faith alone, which rests in part on a high personal self-regard as a saved and holy person, born again and having the Holy Spirit. Of course, apart from their own words and a pointer to their normal universal-human morality (without grievous sins), the Baptists cannot bring forward other arguments, so the speaker stresses that he simply believes this. Such a faith is very far from the faith of the apostles and the holy fathers, who were friends of God and had high charismatic endowments from Him — prophecy, wonderworking, healing, and so on — but who personally were marked by great humility, meekness, non-acquisitiveness, patience. They by no means strove to testify to the world of their savedness, but called themselves the last of sinners, as did the apostle Paul. In a word, they were the complete opposite of the Baptists.

Therefore a person who says he is not sure of his salvation may in fact not have that salvation. That is, there are cases when a person was born again, but doubts beset him, and he still wavers whether he is saved or not. But when he reads God’s word a little more and sees that in the word of God there is confirmation of what he believes, then all the doubts will scatter.

But if a person says: I believe in the Gospel, and this Gospel I preach to others, and at the same time says: “I do not know whether I am saved or not; I have only a hope of salvation” — then I draw from this the conclusion that the person does not believe in the Gospel with all his heart. That is, he places his trust not in the Gospel but in something else, very similar to the truth, which may not be that truth.

We return to the first century, to the origins. The Acts of the Apostles, 11:26: the disciples were first called Christians in Antioch (Acts 11:26).

And this name “Christian” is the most important title, or name, of a disciple of Jesus Christ. All the others are secondary. I know that you believe the word “Orthodox” goes back to the first century, although, according to the sources I read, they began to use it only in the second century.

We can say our Baptist faith is even more ancient than yours, because the first Baptist was John the Baptist, the second Baptist was Jesus Christ, then the apostles were Baptists. And we can argue like this; but these names — “Orthodox,” “Baptist,” “Catholic,” “Adventist,” and so on — are secondary. This is not a name; it is a patronymic. If you want to be called thus, please do — it is of no principle importance to me at all.

And when I performed missionary service in Yakutia — that was in the nineties — we came there and opened a Bible school. The people who believed, repented, were baptized… we then went to the justice office to register the church.

And we made the decision that we would not be called Evangelical Christians-Baptists, so as not to confuse people, who at that time still regarded the Baptists in the old way, since under the Soviet regime people were frightened with Baptists, saying they sacrifice children and, switching off the light, engage in lewdness. Therefore we registered the church as a church of Evangelical Christians.

And, not calling myself a Baptist, I did not feel diminished in any way, because I knew that the most important name of a disciple of Jesus Christ is the name of Christian.

There in Antioch those disciples first began to be called Christians. Not long ago I watched the debate of Dulevich and Denis Samarin. In that debate Dulevich repeatedly asked one and the same question, which, it seems to me, Samarin did not answer clearly. And the question sounded like this: “Where were the Baptists, for example, in the fifth century, or the tenth, or the twelfth, in the Middle Ages?”

Already after the Reformation, after Martin Luther — somewhere there these Baptists appeared from John Smyth, as you told us, because I did not know that the Baptists, supposedly, descend from such a father.

Orthodox priest: Grandfather…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I told you he is not my father. When this question sounds, I answer thus: Baptists, as a name of Christians — that is, disciples who would be called Baptists — there were none of them in the fifth century, nor in the eighth, nor in the tenth; but throughout all the centuries there were Christians.

These Christians may have been called Orthodox, or the Catholic church — which became the Roman Catholic a little later — perhaps they called themselves thus, but that is not important. That is, the secondary succession has absolutely no significance — well, personally for me.

Comment: It is not a matter of how this pastor or anyone else regards succession, but of how God Himself regards it. And for Him historical succession is very important, as is evident from this dispute. So, the pastor places his subjective opinion above the teaching of the Church and of the Bible.

Therefore the main thing is that these Christians existed throughout all the centuries, and they kept the most important thing, the thing Christ told us to keep. Hold fast what you have (Revelation 3:11). You… have kept My word… My command to persevere you have kept (Revelation 3:8–10). If you hold this word, then you will be a true Christian, and the Holy Spirit will always act in you.

Therefore yes, the Baptists did not exist; but those true Christians who held to God’s Word and who strove to add nothing to it and take nothing from it — they are my true brothers and sisters. Let them have lived in the second, the fifth, or the tenth century.

Beginning from the second century, in connection with the spread of the heresies of the Gnostics — there were other heresies as well, but the Gnostics laid claim to secret knowledge and went about the churches, preaching, saying there are truths you do not yet know. Supposedly, Christ taught this at some time, the apostles knew it, but these truths had, as it were, been lost after one century, after these hundred years, and we want to bring you this additional knowledge… well, they did not say it was additional knowledge, but simply deeper knowledge about God, about Christ. And when this heresy began to invade the life of the churches, the bishops, the presbyters, the priests whom God had appointed as overseers in those churches grew anxious, and then they began to reflect, and even gathering together, to reason about how to determine which church is true and which is not, which minister is true and which is not. And as I understand it, it was then that they began to seek this succession from the apostles and from Jesus Christ Himself.

And already at the end of the first century, the beginning of the second, one of the ministers, Ignatius of Antioch — there, the year 97, and 117, I think; I did not write it down here, but so I remember — he taught… He is a minister of God; I believe he was a reborn person in whom the Holy Spirit acted. But, reflecting on the church and on succession, he came to such a conclusion as we, as Baptists, can in no way accept. He taught that the bishop at the eucharistic assembly is the image of the invisible Bishop. And the eucharistic assembly is the assembly around Communion, around the Lord’s Supper.

And in the first period, I think, they celebrated Communion much more often than, for example, we Baptists; we once a month, on the first Sunday, celebrate this commandment; perhaps in the Orthodox church it is done more often. So, gathering at the eucharistic assembly to make memorial of the sufferings of Jesus Christ, to speak about Him, to pray to Him — at the center, or at the head of the table, sat the bishop, and this bishop himself felt that he was, as it were, a representative of Christ. And already at that time Ignatius taught that you, the parishioners, or you, ordinary believers, must receive the bishop as Christ Himself. And he placed himself on a level with Christ.

So — we in the body of Christ do not see Him, because He ascended into heaven, but the bishops are Christ’s vicars here; therefore you must regard the presence of this bishop as the presence of Christ Himself. If the bishop is present, then it is a genuine assembly. If he is present, then it is the Church of Jesus Christ, and then we may partake of these Holy Gifts — that is, of the Body and Blood of the Lord.

And this is how I understood it — that is, he says: “Where the bishop is, there the people must be, since where Jesus Christ is, there is the catholic church.” That is, he placed the bishop on a level with Christ — this I have already said — in other words, where there is no bishop, there is no church.

This is already a serious delusion. In the first century. People who probably were still filled with the Holy Spirit had already launched into vain talk, into speculation, and imperceptibly pride began to enter their hearts.

And they placed themselves on a level with Jesus Christ and said that if there is no bishop, it is not the church. But I so believe the words of Christ from the Gospel of Matthew, chapter 18, where Christ says: For where two or three are gathered together in My name, I am there in the midst of them (Matthew 18:20). And if three ordinary Orthodox people, or three parishioners of a Baptist church, gather together, and they open Holy Scripture, read and pray…

Comment: …the Lord will hear them, because He is omniscient and omnipotent, but He will not necessarily fulfill their wish, because He is free, and our wishes are not always useful for our salvation. But what relation does common prayer about one’s needs have to the question of the structure of the Church, which had bishops from the very beginning? When the hieromartyr Ignatius the God-bearer, at the very beginning of the second century, before his death, wrote epistles to various churches, he did not demand that they establish bishops for themselves, but simply addressed the ordinary believers and their church leaders, listing them in the order accepted to this day: bishops, presbyters, deacons. At the same time, it is true, the hieromartyr Ignatius insisted that one must obey the bishop, but he held this not as his personal opinion but as the commonly accepted teaching of the Church.

We also believe in the same way that ordinary believers of our church cannot celebrate the breaking of bread. There must be presbyters, there must be bishops who are ordained.

That is what we believe too. But even if they do not celebrate the breaking of bread, but read Holy Scripture and pray to Jesus Christ, Christ is in the midst of them. He dwells in their hearts, and they perform a genuine divine service. It is not eucharistic, because there is no breaking of bread here. But it is the church of Jesus Christ, where two or three are gathered.

Further, if we return a little to those centuries of which Alan spoke, the Reformation began. From the Orthodox point of view, the Catholics are apostate Christians, and then the Catholics, as we heard today, gave birth to the Protestants. That is a double grief for the Orthodox. I do not know. I am not a follower of Martin Luther. I strongly condemn him for his attitude toward the Jews, for how he treated the serfs. And, in the end, he supported that war which was waged against the serfs. That is, the serfs wanted to free themselves, but the feudal lords drowned it all, crushed it, and he nevertheless did not take the side of the oppressed. Yes, he should have stood on neither side, but somewhere in the middle and called everyone to peace. But he took the side of the oppressors, and in this he, of course, sinned much.

But here is such a saying of his — and in general this motto of the Reformation, “Sola Scriptura,” which means “Scripture alone” — is one of the most important beliefs of the true church. He said: “Where there is the word, there is faith. And where there is faith, there is the true church.”

Here I personally fully agree with this. Faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God (Romans 10:17). Christ bequeathed to us precisely such a succession: that we pass His Word from generation to generation. And if we are gathered around the Word, then this Word is Christ Himself. He said… not He said, but the evangelist John wrote: In the beginning was the Word… and the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, full of grace and truth (John 1:1; John 1:14). And there is also such a saying of one of the Reformers: “The legitimacy of the church and its clergy is determined not by historical, but by theological succession with the apostolic church. It is more important to preach the same Gospel as the apostles than to be a member of an institution that historically ascends to them.”

Comment: But what is more important for a person: the head or the heart? Or must one still live with both the head and the heart? So it is with apostolic succession: one must have continuous succession in faith, and together with it succession in the gifts of grace from the day of Pentecost. If the faith is corrupted, as among the Catholics, then indeed the succession of ordinations cannot repair that damage and bring the Catholics to salvation.

And one can give the example of a glass — this mug here. Form and content. I understood it thus: the bishops from generation to generation are like this glass. If it is empty, then such a bishop of the church will bring no benefit.

When Christ called the apostles, they were simply an instrument; they were vessels which had to be cleansed. And all the sinful things that were in them the Lord cleaned out, washed with His blood, then filled with the Holy Spirit, filled with His word, and said: Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations (Matthew 28:19). You must carry the contents to all people without distortion.

And they went and began to preach. And they taught the disciples: see, this is how one must believe, this is what one must believe. As I passed this word to you, you must pass it to others. But, as I said, at the end of the first century they began to add something of their own into this little mug, into this content. And with time more and more was added — we must not do this.

If… we must preserve the Gospel undistorted, we are grateful to the Orthodox church, to those holy fathers who preserved God’s Word undistorted. Yes, it was kept somewhere… first in Rome, then in Byzantium, and then it was brought to our lands.

When the Baptism of Rus took place — the friendship with Byzantium, with the priests — these priests, not all of them, but, as I understand it, mainly in the monasteries the undistorted Word of God was preserved; it was written in the Greek language, perhaps in some other languages as well.

And then came the day when the Orthodox priests and in general the whole Holy Synod reasoned for a long time — there was a time when the tsar first permitted the Bible to be translated into Russian, then other tsars came and forbade it, then again permitted, and, in the end, in 1876 the whole Bible was translated into Russian.

And this is the undistorted Word of God. We use the translation of the Holy Synod. This is the Synodal translation. I hold this Word in my hands, and I believe that from the first page to the last it is pure God’s Word. This is the only letter the Lord wrote to people. And I know that in this Word of God there is not a single distortion, not a single contradiction.

Therefore I am grateful to those holy fathers who kept the Word of God and who translated it into Russian. But if one looks into the modern glass of Orthodoxy — you say you have this succession — then, it seems to me, of the Gospel there remains in it only one percent. All the rest is tradition and various other stories which perhaps do not stand on a level with tradition, but in which simple people believe devoutly.

So, when I look at the phenomenon called the Orthodox church, contradictory feelings arise in me. Boasting of its succession, having pushed the Gospel aside, having placed the traditions of the elders at the head, the church proclaimed a monopoly on truth. It confined the sovereign and omnipresent God within the frames of Orthodoxy. It enclosed the grace of the Holy Spirit in seven Sacraments; it called all who disagreed heterodox and heretics. Having separated itself from world Christianity, the Orthodox church came to resemble a sect.

Note how I say it — yes, this is how I understand it; I am not saying it is a sect, but certain such manifestations already exist. And the Orthodox god is very far from the biblical God. Therefore I want to wish, above all, all of us — the Baptists, of whom there are many at this meeting — the Baptists must hear once more what I read. These are the words of Jesus Christ Himself. You… have kept My word… My command to persevere. Therefore hold fast what you have, that no one may take your crown (Revelation 3:8–11). And addressing the Orthodox, I want to wish: return to the origins, to the first century, to the teaching of the apostles. And the teaching of the apostles — all of it, one hundred percent — is written in the Gospels. No other teaching of Christ and the apostles exists. And be true disciples of Jesus Christ. Thank you for your attention.

Orthodox (speaker): Thank you.

Discussion of the reports

Orthodox priest: A fascinating report. But the last phrase surprised me very much (before the thanks). You said that our God is far from the biblical God. Before this you said more than once that our teaching about God is identical. Whom to believe — you, or you?

Laughter.

Many times you… on various details — and the teaching on the Trinity, and the teaching on the attributes of God, on the natures in Christ — everything was identical, and now it turns out to be thus…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I will answer this question. A very easy answer. All that teaching about God which you take from the Bible is the same as ours. We also take it from here. But in addition to this you have added much of your own. I even explained there in what.

Orthodox priest: About God?

Baptist pastor (speaker): About God. You explained to us that God acts only within the bosom of the Orthodox Church.

Orthodox priest: No.

Baptist pastor (speaker): That outside the Orthodox Church God does not act. That is a restriction of the sovereignty of God.

Orthodox priest: You understood Alan a little incorrectly. He means that the saving action of God — the saving one — is only in the Church. But outside the Church, it is saving in such a way as to lead into the Church. That is the grace that calls.

Orthodox (speaker): God acts even in hell, according to the 139th Psalm.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here you are already speaking about God what is not written in the Bible.

Orthodox (speaker): For example — let me say… why not?

Orthodox priest: And the Lord added to the church daily those who were being saved (Acts 2:47), and you say this is not in the Bible.

Baptist: Those who were being saved…

Orthodox priest: Those who were being saved — quite right. That is, the one who was being saved was added to the Church. And the one who was not being saved was not added.

Baptist: To which church?

Orthodox priest: Well, it was one.

Orthodox (speaker): To that of Christ, yes.

Orthodox priest: To the church of Christ.

Orthodox (speaker): And there is one church. Yes, there was and is.

Orthodox priest: And it still is one Church to this day.

Baptist pastor (speaker): You say “those who were being saved.” That is, where did he receive this salvation? So, outside the church, and afterward the Lord added him to the church.

Orthodox priest: But it is not “the saved” — “those who were being saved”…

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, the Lord saved him outside the Orthodox church, and then…

Orthodox priest: Those who were being saved… Not the saved — those being saved… You have mixed it up…

Baptist pastor (speaker): So in your view a person is still being saved in the church all his life.

Orthodox priest: Well, it was so with the apostles all their life… What about the teaching on God — how much does ours differ? I did not understand…

Baptist pastor (speaker): It is identical with ours if we take it from the Bible…

Orthodox priest: Excellent.

Baptist pastor (speaker): And it differs if you continue to study this teaching about God relying on the traditions of the elders. There we already disagree with you.

Orthodox: Well, in the first four hundred years, on what did the Christians rely? On which Bible? The canon appeared at the end of the fourth century.

Baptist pastor (speaker): On oral tradition. We have already spoken about tradition here.

Baptist: On tradition or on the Word of God?

Baptist pastor (speaker): They preserved it undistorted…

Baptist: May I, to Alan, the first speaker… I have questions; may I ask them while they are fresh…

Orthodox priest: One at a time. One question each. One for one. You to us, we to you — one question each.

Baptist pastor (speaker): One question each.

Orthodox priest: It was Sergei who proposed this long ago…

Baptist: Fine — the first question then to Alan, and that is all. Alan quoted… Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the age (Matthew 28:19–20). Alan said this was said only to the apostles. Then explain to me this argument: I am with you always, even to the end of the age. Are the apostles alive today?

Orthodox (speaker): Their successors, yes.

Orthodox priest: Please just state your question.

Baptist: No — simply, when Alan spoke, he said it was only to the apostles.

Orthodox priest: Yes, of course. We heard his words. But what is your question?

Baptist: What is the question? Only to the apostles, or to all who believed? Who believed and taught others?

Orthodox priest: May I answer? I will briefly explain, because his thought was correct, but perhaps you did not understand it, or he said it unclearly. Here is the idea:

He said it as the promise about the Church given to the apostles. The continuity and invincibility of the Church is confirmed, among other things, by this verse. But of the Apostolic Church. The apostles were given authority, among other things, to bring into the Church. Authority was given to make disciples for themselves. And to the disciples again — authority to bring into the Church. And so on, even to this day and to the Second Coming. Therefore, when He says “with you,” what is meant is “with you, and with those who are yours.” Right, Alan?

Baptist: I am just looking… the thing is… The thing is, wait, Alan — if, according to its context…

Orthodox (speaker): Let me answer…

Baptist: Yes, yes, of course.

Orthodox (speaker): Look, the context is this. I said that the right to celebrate the Sacraments was given at first to the apostles alone, not to all believers.

That is, not to everyone — the Lord did not say to every believer: go all of you and baptize in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit; all of you forgive sins, and so on. No — we see that the Sacraments, including baptism, were given at first to the apostles alone. I showed this simply in the context of hierarchy. That the church was hierarchical from the beginning.

Baptist: Yes, yes, yes.

Orthodox (speaker): That is, here we see that this command was given precisely to the apostles alone, not to all believers.

Baptist: And when this command was given, the Lord said: I am with you always, even to the end of the age.

Orthodox (speaker): Well, it is understood — with their successors…

Baptist: I am not against the fact that it was given to the apostles.

Orthodox (speaker): Then what troubles you?

Baptist: Look — where are the apostles today?

Orthodox (speaker): Their successors are everywhere: the bishops, Patriarch Kirill.

Baptist: I understand that…

Orthodox (speaker): Vladyka Ferapont…

Baptist: No — the apostles themselves… They wrote the Gospel, did they not? The Gospel of the apostle John exists, yes…

Orthodox priest: And why did you decide that the apostle John wrote the Gospel?

Orthodox (speaker): Yes, by the way…

Orthodox: I also wanted to ask that.

Baptist: Let us finish this to the end… afterward…

Orthodox priest: Let us…

Baptist: The First Catholic Epistle of the holy apostle Peter. James, Jude, John, the Revelation of John…

Orthodox priest: Well, we read the Bible.

Baptist: Yes — Thessalonians and all the rest, of the apostle Paul. There they are, the apostles who teach us today and transmit the teaching to us. Therefore Alan simply did not say — I wanted to hear what he meant. He said simply “hierarchically.” The person who today reads the Word of God, from the primary source, from those to whom the apostles transmitted this Word, receives this Word from the apostles themselves.

Not through a hierarchy, but from the apostles themselves. Because — thank God, as Sergei Antonovich said, we are grateful to the Orthodox priests who, in their conscience, in their heart, resolved to translate the Word of God into Russian without distortion, so that today every person has that word, reads it, and receives from the apostles themselves the teaching they transmitted. That is the meaning. And why I say to Alan — in the sense that this is simply, how to put it, through a hierarchy. I am with you always, even to the end of the age. So this is not simply — how to say — I just wanted to clarify.

Comment: Well then — until the Synodal translation, all our forefathers were perishing, and God did not care in the least??? Or was salvation nevertheless accomplished by God’s Providence in the true Church, through its instructing of the faithful?

Orthodox: If you take today’s Orthodox person and compare his understanding of Scripture with the understanding of a person living in the third or fourth century, it will not differ in any way. If you take Pentecostals, Adventists, Baptists, or someone else, give them one and the same text — each will have his own understanding.

Orthodox priest: Paul — but allow me to answer you with the words of Christ. These were the words of Christ, were they not?

Baptist: Yes.

Orthodox priest: So — in the High-Priestly Prayer, as you remember, the Lord Jesus Christ prays for the apostles. Personally for the apostles. And among other things He says: I pray for them. I do not pray for the world but for those whom You have given Me, for they are Yours (John 17:9).

Baptist: And further?

Orthodox priest: Wait — may I continue? I know… So we see here, as in the text you quoted, the prayer strictly for the apostles. What does He say further? And further He says that He prays not only for them, but also for those who will believe in Me through their word (John 17:20).

Baptist: Through whose word?

Orthodox priest: Through their word. So, when the Lord says that He is with them, with the apostles, to the end of the age — certainly we are speaking here not only of the apostles personally; they have all died, except, probably, John the Theologian. But in any case, we are speaking here of the fact that He prays for the Church. Hence, in the church… glory to Christ throughout all ages, world without end (Ephesians 3:21). Not every believer will glorify through all ages, says the apostle Paul, but glory is offered to Christ in the Church.

Baptist: I very much agree with you, Evgeny — yes, I do not know your patronymic…

Orthodox priest: No need for the patronymic…

Baptist: Well, yes… look: “those who will believe in Me through their word” — and this is what I was speaking about, that this word… The church today consists of those who are not enclosed in some Baptists, Orthodox, Catholics, but those who believed through the word of the apostles. And we read today: take the New Testament — it is all written, except, perhaps, the Gospel of Mark; he, it seems, wrote from the words of Peter. Here… Luke, that is, was also with the apostle Paul, and all his epistles… most were written by the apostles, and if we believe through their word, then we are members of the true church. It does not matter, say, which one it is…

Baptist 2: The succession through the word.

Baptist: Yes — that is what it is about: “those who will believe in Me through their word.”

Orthodox 2: A small remark: you know that in India the church went from the apostle Thomas, and there is a Gospel of the apostle Thomas.

Baptist: Fine. The apostle Thomas wrote nothing, so to speak; and not all the apostles wrote something, because God… when you read the Word of God, everything there is structured harmoniously… The four Gospels show four sides of Jesus Christ. The Acts of the apostles… And there were those apostles who, I think, proclaimed the Gospel. Of them — there are very many; it is described in Acts. Of the apostle Andrew nothing at all is written in Acts, right?

Of the apostle Peter, where it is written that he stood up and said: “To me the Lord gave to open the gospel to the Gentiles and to the Jews” — that is, the apostle Peter was given… And other apostles — some wrote the Word of God… And the apostle Paul, who was not among the twelve apostles, wrote very many epistles, and he himself said that “I was appointed an apostle of the Gentiles (2 Timothy 1:11), just as Peter was appointed an apostle of the Jews,” yes?

That is, we see that the very word “apostle” means “one sent.” That is, Jesus Christ sent the apostles so that some of them would write down the Word. And this Word has reached our days, so that through the reading of this word — of the apostles, of the epistles of the apostles — we would believe in the Son of God, Jesus Christ. That is all. Thomas did not write; Andrew did not write; and many others did not write…

Orthodox 2: But they possessed the fullness of the Gospel which the Lord Jesus Christ gave. Did they possess it? If they possessed it, then it was also transmitted orally, and not only in writing, as you say. This is what is called church Tradition, which is what we follow.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Alan had six questions…

Orthodox (speaker): Now it is our turn…

Baptist 3: You say it instructed… and in the context many times… the teaching is identical. That is, the teaching which existed in the first century and in subsequent centuries did not change.

Orthodox (speaker): Yes, unquestionably.

Baptist 3: But we see that the moments that characterize, or that are accepted in the Orthodox church — icon veneration, monasticism, and many other moments which… the veneration of relics, the teaching about the saints, and all the rest… That is, what belongs to the Orthodox church, yes, we spoke of this. And many of these things, of course, took shape in the second, the third, the fifth century. In principle, probably all these things were formed by the fifth century. Icon veneration too, as I understand it, was finally established, probably, at the seventh council, in the eighth or seventh century…

In principle it probably existed earlier, in the fourth or fifth century. Well, not the point. So there it is — the progressing teaching of the Orthodox church, which, at least over several centuries… and probably took final shape by the division of the church into the Western and the Eastern.

That is, it developed — it was not yet formed. That is, why is it progressing? If you say the teaching is identical and did not change, we see that it did change. And, in principle, the church changed also after the division into the Western and the Eastern church. That is, perhaps to a lesser degree, but so it was.

Orthodox (speaker): I understood the question, yes. Look — let me answer briefly. In fact there was no dogmatic development at all. And even if we take icons separately — I showed this directly at our last dispute: frescoes, for example, from the first century, from the catacombs, from the time of Nero. But look, what is the point of the question?

The thing is that they always existed — both the veneration of relics and icons and the rest — they simply became known because certain heresies arose. Heresies arose — take, for example, the teaching on the Trinity. That is, the teaching on the Trinity appeared in the fourth century. In the fourth century. But this does not mean that in the first century they did not believe in the Trinity.

Orthodox priest: The teaching on the Trinity was formulated in the fourth century…

Orthodox (speaker): Oh, I beg pardon… it was formulated in the fourth century, at the Council of Nicaea, yes. But it is obvious that the apostles in the first century already believed in the Trinity. There simply appeared in the fourth century a certain character, Arius, who began to teach that no, Jesus is not God, He is a creation of God. And the Church was compelled to answer, to react to this action, to convene an Ecumenical Council and to affirm the truth. And this, of course, became known throughout the empire. But this does not mean that before this it did not exist.

Orthodox priest: May I add… Let us, on the extreme example… we said — we had a whole dispute on icon veneration. But I will answer very briefly: the teaching does not change in substance. So, look. There are certain sacred images which, indeed, we do not see in the first century in such a form, with such developed iconography. But subsequently we do see them. And you consider this a change of faith.

Baptist 3: Of doctrine…

Orthodox priest: Well, of doctrine, of faith… But we consider there is no change of doctrine. Accordingly, there is a certain conflict of opinions. Why we consider there is not — here one must understand our point of view. For us the decisive thing here is the conception that Jesus Christ is true God and at the same time true man. As God, He is of course Imparticipable and above the world; as man, He is of course depictable. Therefore, depicting Him in human form, we insist on His depictability, on the fact that He has flesh the same as all of us, on the fullness of His incarnation. Is this correct teaching?

That He truly became incarnate, such as we are? Correct teaching? He became incarnate, took our sins, and suffered for us. Is this correct teaching?

Here is what we wish to depict — not only by word, as I am telling you now, not only by ink and brush as before, and on the computer as we do now — but we wish to depict it also in colors.

What is our error? This teaching is correct — you agreed with us — but we depict it in this way. And any person, even an illiterate person, even one of little knowledge, seeing an icon of Christ, will say: yes, truly He became incarnate. And the rest we supply verbally.

Baptist: We always remember that He became incarnate…

Orthodox priest: Is our thought clear to you? That is, the teaching is unchanging.

Baptist 3: Yes, it is clear… But do we find this in the teaching of the apostles…

Baptist pastor (speaker): In Christ Himself first… Do we find it in the Gospel…

Baptist 3: In Christ and the apostles… Do we find it in Scripture…

Baptist 2: Confirmation…

Orthodox (speaker): Unquestionably.

Baptist 3: That is, the church which came into being on the day of Pentecost — did it practice icon veneration, many other things…

Orthodox priest: One can take relics — that would be more convenient for us — but I deliberately took the worst case for us. Relics, and I will explain why it is better. The middle of the second century, the epistle of the Church of Smyrna to the Church of Philomelium on the death of Polycarp of Smyrna, a disciple of John the Theologian.

In this epistle it is said that the pagans and the Jews, deliberately seeking to destroy the relics of the saint, so that we might not take them and venerate them as God — though we do not do this and do not venerate him as God — yet we were very careful that, when they were burned, we gathered the remains of the relics and venerate them as a kind of holy object.

The middle of the second century, the apostolic epoch: Christians venerate the relics of their teacher who died for Christ — venerate them as a holy object. Such, concerning relics.

Baptist pastor (speaker): This again confirms that already in the second century there was apostasy from the teaching of Jesus Christ and the apostles, because not one word about relics was said by Christ or written by the apostles. Not a single word exists about icons; not a single word about the veneration of the Virgin Mary was said by Christ or the apostles. And for us the model and standard is, after all, the teaching of Christ and the apostles, written in the Gospel.

Baptist 3: From the origins…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes — already the end of the first century, the beginning of the second: the apostasy is already beginning.

Orthodox priest: That is, the Virgin Mary, who speaks by the Holy Spirit — this… the word of the Gospel… In the Gospel of Luke it is said that she speaks by the Holy Spirit. And she speaks several words. So, among other things, she says: Henceforth all generations will call me blessed (Luke 1:48). We bless her, as the Holy Spirit said to her. We believe the Holy Spirit. And how do you venerate her? How do you bless her?

Baptist pastor (speaker): We bless her too, but the word “blessed” means “happy.” We venerate her as the most happy in heaven and no more. And we have no other relations with her. Because Jesus and the apostles bequeathed us nothing by which to address her.

Comment: Very precisely said: “we have no relations with her.” Without having relations with the Mother of the Son of God, they want to say that thereby they bring joy to her Son? She is now in communion with Him, and they do not wish to be in communion with her — so how can they have communion in common with God? So, the Baptists place themselves outside the divine life and spiritual communion with the friends and kin of the Son of God.

Baptist 3: Did I hear correctly… These points about icons and all the rest… That is, we do not find this in Scripture. And we do not find it in the church which came into being on the day of Pentecost.

Orthodox priest: This — what? The conception of the Incarnation — we find it. You yourselves said it exists. That He died for us — again we find it. The conception that He took our sins upon Himself — again we find it, and Sergei spoke of this in the report. It seems you agree with us in this.

Baptist 2: The matter is not even in the image…

Orthodox priest: Once more. Images allow the sight, as one of the senses, to become established in the dogma of the Incarnation. And what is wrong with that?

Baptist 2: Here — look: you said last time, I remember, that when you spoke about the depiction of Jesus Christ, we cited the place from the Old Testament, from Deuteronomy: “you shall not make any image” (Deuteronomy 5:8) — you said this was said to those who had not seen Christ. But we, as it were, are after Christ and have seen.

Orthodox priest: Yes, of course.

Baptist 2: On that basis… one may paint, yes?

Orthodox (speaker): God, yes.

Baptist 2: Then who saw the Trinity? You have the Trinity painted… Who saw it?

Orthodox (speaker): In what image is it painted?

Orthodox priest: The three strangers who appeared to Abraham…

Orthodox (speaker): It is painted in the three strangers.

Baptist 2: But who saw them at all, and who described them?

Orthodox (speaker): In the three strangers… Were the strangers visible to Abraham?

Orthodox priest: I have heard you. Once more. An icon is not a photograph. An icon is theology in colors. Sometimes we do not know the photograph of a saint, especially an ancient one. Sometimes not even an exact description has been preserved. And then what is depicted is, well, a typical icon, so to speak. Here, seeing this image, seeing the inscription on the icon, we pray to that saint, before that icon, and through him we pray to God. Do you understand? It is not a problem. So also with the Trinity: certain three angels. But we raise our mind not to the angels, not to a board with paints, but to God, who appeared to Abraham. That is what we believe. After all, this is faith.

Baptist 2: We understand what you are doing, but we cannot agree with it.

Orthodox priest: Well, when you read “God” — the letters on your phone right now, at this minute — and see the word “God,” a certain inward reaction immediately arises in you. Do you understand? But this is an image. It is the verbal image of the same invisible God. Is this not obvious? You allow the verbal image, but not the depiction.

Orthodox (speaker): But we are moving into another topic…

Baptist: Yes, Evgeny — simply, when you explained to Misha that Christ became incarnate, we paint Him in the flesh. And they asked a question: God the Father, the Father… in Timothy it is written: who dwells (God the Father) in unapproachable light, whom no man has seen or can see. To whom be honor and everlasting power! Amen (1 Timothy 6:16).

That is, I say — we have not seen God the Father at all. And here it is written that of men no one sees Him at all.

Orthodox (speaker): But what is the question? Where is God the Father depicted?

Baptist: In general, if, say, about Jesus Christ — He was painted as a visual aid…

Orthodox (speaker): Where was God the Father depicted?

Baptist: As a visual aid they painted Him, and you can explain that He became incarnate… But the icon of the Trinity, where God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Spirit, God… how do you explain this at all — as incarnate, or not incarnate…

Orthodox priest: Is that a question?

Baptist 2: Yes. Of the three strangers… then label it so — that it is an icon of the Three Strangers…

Orthodox priest: May I? Friends, you asked; I will answer as best I can, and I propose returning to our topic…

Baptist: Yes, enough…

Orthodox priest: I repeat once more: this is not a picture, it is theology in colors. Hence we must separate two things. First: No one has seen God at any time (John 1:18). That is true. In His essence the Godhead is undepictable; He dwells in unapproachable light. No one says He is depictable in His essence. But if God appears in some visible image, we depict the visible image. And of course this was many thousands of years ago; we did not live then, did not see it. But a certain generalized image is depicted. If one reads the icon of the Trinity correctly, then dogmatically we will see in it both the redemption and the incarnation of the Son of God; we will see the Divine Council about our salvation. We will see the relations of the Persons of the Trinity among themselves… You will not see it — I will. I know this, because I have been taught it. Well, this is theology, do you understand?

Baptist: That is why I want to find out. How is it with you…

Orthodox priest: Therefore I propose not to accept a primitive understanding of icon veneration — look, stupid Orthodox bow to a board with paints, ha-ha — one must not understand it that way. This is high theology, which I personally studied for many years in order to understand at least something. If you have not studied it, then, of course, you cannot understand it. Well, accept that.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Friends, let us agree on this: a question, and two minutes for an answer.

Orthodox (speaker): Yes, yes.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We will not get through all the questions… I have two questions on Alan’s report.

Orthodox priest: Yes, of course.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Now Alan asks a question.

Orthodox priest: Let you… We answered long about icons… Ah, wait — we were answering about icons…

Baptist: Well, the icons are not to the point…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here — Misha asked a question; now the question from you… Alan has six, please…

Orthodox (speaker): Well, not six — it has already shrunk, but…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I have two, and I must certainly ask them.

Orthodox (speaker): Look, a very interesting moment. Or rather, you yourself touched on it, recalled the debate of whom?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Of Dulevich and Samarin.

Orthodox (speaker): Of Dulevich and Samarin. And, supposedly, you found a very simple answer. That is, you said there were individual believers who kept the Word of God. Did I understand you correctly?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes, the holy remnant.

Orthodox (speaker): And they were Baptists.

Baptist pastor (speaker): It existed in the Old Testament, and it exists always in the New.

Orthodox (speaker): And they were Baptists?

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, they were true Christians.

Orthodox (speaker): Well, who?

Baptist pastor (speaker): They were not called Baptists.

Orthodox (speaker): Professing the apostolic teaching.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox (speaker): The one you profess now?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes, the apostolic one, which is written in the Gospel.

Orthodox (speaker): Identical to your teaching — do I understand correctly, yes?

As I myself said in the report: the Church abides from age to age, that it… that it always has an outward side and so on. You can show who specifically this was, in what century, perhaps some individual church, and so on…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I do not know. I did not live then; how can I…

Orthodox (speaker): On what basis, then, do you say that… We, for example, do not know such people, but we know who believed as the Orthodox.

Baptist pastor (speaker): I believe they existed, those people, the reborn, who believed the holy Gospel, because Christ said, as you also read at the beginning: I will build My church, and the gates of Hades shall not prevail against it (Matthew 16:18); the devil throughout the centuries wanted to overcome the Church, but he achieved nothing. The holy remnant always existed.

Orthodox (speaker): But Christ said that a city that is set on a hill cannot be hidden (Matthew 5:14).

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox (speaker): But you say that, all the same, it hid.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Well, I do not know.

Orthodox (speaker): Simply — look, I am not trying to catch you out… The fact is that, in reality, from the second century to the fifteenth century the church never believed in the identical way as the Baptists. It never held the Body to be a symbol; it never believed in salvation by faith alone. It never…

Baptist: How? They did not believe in salvation by faith…

Orthodox (speaker): In salvation by faith alone — who believed that?

Baptist: Let us read…

Orthodox (speaker): Please…

Orthodox priest: No, no — from the second century to the fifteenth, name the names… with quotations.

Baptist: From the first century to the fifteenth…

Orthodox priest: Yes.

Orthodox (speaker): Well, we believe that the Church of Christ will abide from age to age.

Orthodox priest: The church is people, you understand?

Orthodox (speaker): Do you believe that the Church is the pillar and ground of the truth? (1 Timothy 3:15) Do you believe?

Baptist: So it is written — the word of Jesus Christ.

Orthodox (speaker): That is, the truth will be preserved in the Church unshakably from age to age.

Baptist: Yes, but in which apostle was this said?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Paul — come on, the question was put to me…

Baptist: Well, he is looking at me…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Let us put the questions more briefly and answer more briefly.

Orthodox (speaker): Exactly, Sergei Antonovich — do you believe that the Church is the pillar and ground of the truth, that is, it will keep the truth from the first century to the present day?

Baptist pastor (speaker): It carried it through. Yes.

Orthodox (speaker): Yes.

Baptist pastor (speaker): And even the Orthodox church kept the truth — the one which is the Bible — and translated it into Russian. The Orthodox church preserved the truth. We Baptists accept this truth, we believe in this truth with all our heart, and we acknowledge nothing else.

Orthodox priest: Your point of view is thus: the church is the pillar and ground of the Bible.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Of the truth.

Orthodox priest: Of the Bible.

Baptist pastor (speaker): For me it is identical.

Baptist: It is said: My word is truth (John 17:17).

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes. For me it is identical.

Orthodox priest: Excellent. And in that case you have no doctrine of your own, as we established, but only the Bible, and you do not teach one another anything.

Baptist pastor (speaker): My faith… is based on the Bible.

Orthodox priest: That is clear, but do you have a faith of your own?

Baptist pastor (speaker): And our Baptist doctrine is strictly based on the Bible — neither to the left nor to the right.

Orthodox priest: Well, that is how you consider it; we do not consider it so.

Baptist pastor (speaker): That is how we consider it.

Orthodox priest: The question is different. So — do you after all have your own doctrine, or only the Bible?

Baptist pastor (speaker): I personally have a living faith in what is written in the Bible, but I agree with the doctrine of our Baptist union.

Orthodox priest: So there is a doctrine after all.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes, of the Baptist brotherhood and, in particular, of the Union of Baptists of Russia…

Orthodox priest: So, you do have a doctrine.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We do.

Orthodox priest: Excellent. So, if you have it, and you consider yourselves a church, as I understand, then it must have existed a thousand years ago as well. Show me, a thousand years ago, a doctrine like yours, which would contain, among other things, salvation by faith — and this is an important thing for you, highly important, decisive — and other moments very important for you. Name that person.

Baptist pastor (speaker): I… well, I know history poorly. I do not know such people who…

Orthodox (speaker): Even people who know history well — they, of course, say…

Baptist: A doctrine. Here — first… the apostle Paul set out this doctrine in all his epistles. And if you look at the doctrine of the Baptists… you tell us better — if you have seen the doctrine of the Baptists, tell me what discrepancy there is with the epistles of the apostle Paul…

Orthodox (speaker): Let us, let us…

Orthodox priest: Ah, you put it very well.

Baptist: Yes.

Orthodox priest: Very good. You began to quote the passage from the apostle Peter, as you remember, where he says that certain truths of the apostle Paul the untaught and unstable twist to their own… destruction (2 Peter 3:16).

Thus, Scripture itself is not self-evident, not self-sufficient; there are needed certain people who understand it correctly, and they will teach you.

Where were those certain people who taught salvation by faith a thousand years ago? There were none of them. Even if we suppose there were certain people like you who quietly, in a corner, believed thus…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I am sure they existed; I simply do not know them.

Orthodox priest: Excellent!

Baptist pastor (speaker): History has not brought them down to us…

Orthodox (speaker): But this contradicts the Bible.

Orthodox priest: Faith is a fine thing…

Baptist pastor (speaker): But I know that two thousand years ago there were very many of them… The apostles, then the five hundred to whom Christ appeared on the mountain before the Ascension. And then a mass, a mass of people who believed throughout the whole Roman empire. They accepted the undistorted word.

Orthodox priest: Fine. Here — I believe that I have an earthly father. I know his name; I have a mother; she tells me she gave birth to me, although I do not remember this. And she says this man is my father. And I have a document, a passport, where it is written that I have such-and-such a patronymic, and in the birth certificate even the name of my father was written. That is, I have a document that I am precisely from him. If he were to resist (he will not), but if suddenly, I would say: “No — look, here, I am your son. Everything here is in order.”

What documents do you have that you are the successors of the apostles? You say: we have the Bible. The Mormons will also say — we have the Bible. A Jehovah’s Witness will say: we too have the Bible. And an Adventist… also the Bible. This is not a document. Even an unbeliever takes the Bible and beats a believer over the head with it.

Baptist pastor (speaker): This is the most important document. And for me it is enough, all…

Baptist: But whom do we need to prove it to? I do not understand.

Orthodox priest: Whom, how do you mean?

Baptist: Whom? God Himself? What are you — what is this about? Why this question? To whom must I prove it?

Orthodox (speaker): At least, to “give a defense of your hope” to us… (1 Peter 3:15)

Baptist: To you?

Orthodox (speaker): Yes. That is according to the Bible…

Baptist: But Christ said: If anyone keeps My word… (John 8:51) Then we will give an account to God, and so it is written…

Orthodox priest: So.

Baptist 2: Then why do you ask me about it in advance? Leave this until eternity, until the Judgment. And there all this will be. And you will show your documents… we are not persuading you of anything… Is that what you believe?

Orthodox priest: We are discussing…

Baptist 2: For God’s sake… No — why ask such questions, that is what I mean… A thousand years ago to find someone, someone else, you understand — you immediately put it as if the Lord Himself showed us nothing historically, so that, here — prove something, then you will be my disciples. Where do you see this?

Baptist: By the way, the Jews said exactly the same to the first disciples. Prove your succession. Here — our succession is from Abraham. And the apostle Paul (to the Galatians) breaks this, and says: know that every believer is a child of Abraham. He breaks it… Why? Because Abraham, if we read in the Gospel of Matthew, in the first chapter, in the first verse: The book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, the Son of David, the Son of Abraham (Matthew 1:1) — and whoever believed in Christ is a child of Abraham by faith.

And he broke this. And the Jews were the first likewise: “Where is your genealogy, where is your succession? It is to us that God gave the covenant; everything was given to us,” and they broke the first disciples — some of them, say, the Galatians. And he says: “O foolish Galatians! who are you — do you, that is, not obey God?” — in my words… (Galatians 3:1)

Orthodox priest: If there are such long monologues, we will not be able to answer anything…

Baptist: Yes, therefore… there is a point here that the document… here is the document… (points to the Bible)

Baptist pastor (speaker): Who is asking the question? You have already asked…

Orthodox priest: May I briefly say about the Galatians and circumcision… Here one must understand what this is about. It is about fundamental things. Not that Abraham is an ancestor, but whether we have a relation to the God of Abraham. That is the question. The Jews say: no, because you are not circumcised; but the apostle says: yes, because you entered the Church. The way of entry into the Church is baptism. This is the church of Christ; Christ is the Son of God, joining man and God in Himself. Is this not obvious? That is what it is about, not about circumcision at all.

Baptist: Evgeny, I agree, but look at what the question is. The Old Testament was with the Jews, and the disciples did not have it — only the oral tradition of the apostles. And they went with the Scripture and proved that they were right, and… broke the faith of some. Why, say, must we dig around for a thousand years, go somewhere else? We are speaking today about faith, about our faith in Christ. On what basis is this faith…

Orthodox priest: Because it is not Scripture that the gates of hell shall not overcome, but the Church (Matthew 16:18). Christ will be with the disciples — not with the Scripture, but with the disciples — all days. Always. Where is your historical succession with the disciples — that you are the disciples of the disciples of the disciples? That is what it is about.

Baptist: Here it is…

Orthodox priest: That you are not disciples of a book, but disciples of disciples…

Baptist: It is not a book… Excuse me — when I read Pushkin’s verses, tell me, am I reading a book, or the expression… what the author wrote down, what Pushkin wrote…

Orthodox (speaker): The author, as it happens, speaks precisely about historical succession — there it says, the gates of hell shall not prevail; what does that mean? I am with you… to the end of the age (Matthew 28:20) — that is, there will be a historical path.

Baptist: Here. And it is with you… Here today Christ is in the word (very actively points to the Bible) — with the word of God transmitted from the apostles, with this word to the end of the age, so that we too may believe…

Orthodox (speaker): With a doctrine, with a doctrine… the true one…

Orthodox: Here the brother said it — I will quote the text: “My word is truth” (John 17:17). If we rely literally on His words, we cut out of the text the words of Jesus Christ, put them together — this is the Truth — and everything else, well, that is secondary…

Baptist: Why?

Orthodox priest: Because He said so literally…

Baptist: There are very many places in Scripture where the Lord says His word is truth.

Orthodox priest: That is exactly what we are speaking about…

Baptist: Most assuredly, I say to you…

Orthodox: So truth is only what Christ said.

Orthodox priest: And the rest, it turns out, is not truth…

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, no… What Christ said, the disciples heard all of it, assimilated it, and carried it to teach the people. All of it — that is what we believe…

Orthodox priest: Orally, or did they carry a book?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Let me have a question on the report.

Orthodox (speaker): Yes — only on the topic…

Orthodox priest: Yes.

Baptist pastor (speaker): On the report. From Alan’s words I heard that when the Holy Spirit came down on the disciples on the day of Pentecost, He came down only on the apostles.

In that upper room there were a hundred and twenty people; among them were some women — at least, the Virgin Mary was there. Did only the twelve receive the Holy Spirit that day, or the hundred and twenty? Therefore it depends on this — to whom… So Alan said that only those who received the Holy Spirit have the authority to transmit the Holy Spirit further. On that day did a hundred and twenty receive the Holy Spirit and were baptized with the Holy Spirit, or the twelve?

Orthodox (speaker): No, look. There is a context here; my words must be considered in context. I said to the effect that even if there were a hundred and twenty, initially these powers were given precisely to the apostles; the Holy Spirit came down on them in a special way, and precisely they, because precisely…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Did a hundred and twenty receive the Holy Spirit, or the twelve?

Orthodox (speaker): It is even written in my report that the apostles and certain other disciples, and a few other believers. That is, I do not say only the apostles. The authority to celebrate the Sacraments was given at first to the apostles (to the apostles alone). To the apostles alone.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Nowhere is it written…

Orthodox (speaker): How is it not written… I am saying…

Baptist pastor (speaker): That only to the apostles…

Orthodox (speaker): Baptism, baptism… Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations (Matthew 28:19)…

Baptist pastor (speaker): There were a hundred and twenty people there…

Baptist: There were all of them… All received the Holy Spirit, it is written… on the basis of the word of God, not of a report…

Orthodox (speaker): Wait… I am telling you: the special grace to celebrate the Sacraments, the special grace of the Holy Spirit, was given at first only to the apostles. You say: show it in the Word of God. I am showing…

Orthodox priest: May I say a word?

Baptist pastor (speaker): No — specifically…

Orthodox priest: No — we were told “they were filled”… We read the end of the first chapter of Acts: And they cast their lots, and the lot fell on Matthias. And he was numbered with the eleven apostles (Acts 1:26). It seems clear.

Baptist pastor (speaker): So.

Orthodox priest: The second chapter begins: When the day of Pentecost had fully come, they were all with one accord in one place… Who are “they”? Well, those same twelve of whom it was just said. There were no heads there. Heads — that is the thirteenth century. And suddenly there came a sound from heaven… it filled the whole house… Then there appeared to them divided tongues… and one sat upon each of them. And they were all (clearly all) filled with the Holy Spirit… and began to speak with other tongues… (Acts 2:1–4) And Peter speaks for all. I am even surprised one can speak of what you speak of…

Baptist: There were a hundred and twenty people there, at the assembly. All of them were abiding…

Orthodox (speaker): Where is it written — the father asks: where is it written?

Baptist: Here — the first chapter. It is written. Here, even — these are the fourteenth, thirteenth verses… All of them… All… Having come to the upper room… after the Ascension of Jesus Christ there were altogether… they are enumerated, eleven, yes? And further: These all continued with one accord in prayer and supplication, with the women and Mary the mother of Jesus, and with His brothers. And we look: And in those days Peter stood up in the midst of the disciples (the number of names was about a hundred and twenty) (Acts 1:14–16). All of them, a hundred and twenty people… it is said about the same ones… When the day of Pentecost had fully come, they were all with one accord… (Acts 2:1)

Orthodox woman: Of another day…

Baptist: Of Pentecost… All of them…

Orthodox woman: All of them, eleven… And further — here, read… Peter stood up with the eleven. Peter (according to the context) stood up with the eleven.

Baptist: He stood up with the eleven, but the assembly was about a hundred and twenty.

Orthodox (speaker): That is just what we were saying: only upon the apostles in a special way…

Orthodox priest: Here it is — an excellent example. We have a clear text of Scripture, transparent. You understand it in your way and have a basis in the text. We understand it in our way and have a basis in the text. The question is fundamentally important for understanding the rights of the hierarchy. Is that not right?

Baptist: Well, for you, perhaps, and for the hierarchy…

Orthodox priest: And for you too. Because if only the apostles have the right to impart the Holy Spirit, and you have no succession from the apostles — direct, through the transmission of the gifts of the Holy Spirit from disciple to disciple — then you are strangers to the apostles. This is obvious. But if not only the apostles, but anyone can receive, apart from the apostles — well, then there is no question. Hence the question is fundamentally important. You understand in your way, we understand in ours… an impasse. Where to find the truth? The truth is very simple…

Baptist: Truth is Christ…

Orthodox priest: That will not do. Because Christ, of course, knows the Truth and can give it. But the thing is, Christ here, among us, does not sit, and He does not speak to us. He speaks to you in His way, to me in His way. Therefore someone is needed — an arbiter — who is above both me and you. Who will say: “Friend, you are mistaken, and you are right.” That is what is needed. The teaching authority of the Church is needed.

The church… the pillar and ground of the truth (1 Timothy 3:15). Not the texts of Scripture in which we are entangled together. Right? But the truth, the correct understanding. And you have a doctrine. Not only the Bible — which would be wonderful — but a doctrine, though one based on the Bible. But a doctrine nonetheless… That is precisely what we are speaking about.

And such a doctrine, which is a landmark, a norm, must exist in all ages — you understand? A doctrine is not enough. There is fundamentally one more important thing: the gifts of the Holy Spirit, passing in succession from teacher to disciple. We see — Alan quoted to us — that hands are laid, gifts are transmitted, apostolic hands are laid, transmitted to the disciples. Well, where do you have this? Hands were laid on you, Sergei, were they not?

Baptist pastor (speaker): They were…

Orthodox priest: Right. But for what?

Baptist pastor (speaker): To confirm that I am a missionary called by God and, subsequently, a pastor.

Orthodox (speaker): But you do not believe that…

Baptist pastor (speaker): It was an identification… through the laying on of the hands of ministers; these ministers showed that this person is a minister the same as we.

Orthodox priest: Excellent.

Baptist pastor (speaker): And he has the right to preach, to baptize, to celebrate weddings, to bury, and all the rest. This we acknowledge.

Orthodox priest: Excellent. But we have already established that, first, strictly speaking, if all are equal, everyone ought to lay hands — yet only the ministers lay hands, as you said — that is one thing. Second, this laying on of the hands of ministers ascends, like it or not, again to John Smyth. And John Smyth is his own chief.

That is, you understand the idea correctly, that the laying on of the hands of ministers is needed. And you say: but I have this. But when we lead the chain backward, unwind it, we come to John Smyth. And he waves his hand at us from the grave. But if we lead the chain — mine, or the father’s — we come to the apostle Andrew and to the day of Pentecost.

Baptist: We have already discussed that question. First, so that the awakening in Russia — if you remember, of course… The awakening in Russia was not based only on the Baptists.

Orthodox priest: I am speaking about the laying on of hands…

Baptist: You ascribe us to John Smyth, but let us simply recall. There were three independent, so to speak, hearths of awakening, when people began to read the Word of God. In southern Russia they were called Baptists. In Ukraine they were called Stundists. There they believed through the Mennonites altogether. In Petersburg they were called Evangelical Christians. Then, after some time there was, how to say it, a congress, or whatever it was called, I do not know — all the believers were invited.

Orthodox priest: Paul, I remember this well…

Baptist: And the Union of Evangelical Christians-Baptists was formed not only from the Baptists.

Orthodox priest: Once more. I am ready to trace you to Menno Simons. I am ready to trace you to Martin Luther. Both were priests, Catholic ones. A priest — like me, say, or this father here — we have no right to ordain. Consequently, you still, head-on or otherwise, do not have apostolic succession.

Baptist: Apostolic…

Baptist pastor (speaker): That succession which you treasure does not interest us at all.

Orthodox priest: Right… because you do not have it…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Because we have the Savior Jesus Christ. There are the twelve apostles who left the teaching of Christ on the pages of Holy Scripture, and for our salvation that is quite sufficient.

Orthodox priest: But do you not need the transmission of the gifts of the Holy Spirit?

Baptist pastor (speaker): We have the Holy Spirit, who is the third Person of the Holy Trinity. He entered our heart at faith in Christ, at repentance.

Orthodox (speaker): Then why did Paul ordain Timothy…

Baptist: That is for ministry already…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I personally have the Holy Spirit. At the moment of repentance I already received Him, and we do not believe that at the laying on of hands the Holy Spirit is transmitted — that is, we do not believe…

Orthodox priest: So, at the apostles it was transmitted…

Baptist: May I read?

Orthodox (speaker): Go ahead… Go ahead…

Baptist: It is written (Acts, chapter 2, from verse 38): Peter said to them: Repent, and let every one of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins; and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. For the promise is to you and to your children… (Acts 2:38–39)

Orthodox priest: Excellent… and to your children…

Baptist: And with many other words…, and further… Then those who gladly received his word were baptized, and that day about three thousand souls were added to them. And they continued steadfastly in the apostles’ doctrine and fellowship, in the breaking of bread, and in prayers (Acts 2:40–42)

We look: of those first disciples who believed, the three thousand, nowhere is it written that hands were laid on them. But they — it is written: repent and let every one be baptized… further — lay hands and receive the gift of the Holy Spirit — there is not; there is not…

Orthodox priest: No, no, no. For the remission of sins. So…

Baptist: And further… and you shall receive the gift of the Holy Spirit…

Orthodox priest: So, baptism grants the remission of sins, as we see.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Paul, you have exhausted your limit; we impose a penance on you.

Baptist: Well, that is it!

Orthodox priest: Oh — how close you are to Orthodoxy! As with whom you keep company, so you learn!

Baptist 2: You indulged them; now Paul would have opened the truth to all of them, and all would have believed in Christ!

Baptist pastor (speaker): In much speaking sin is not lacking… Yes… Because others want to take part; I always worry about this.

Orthodox (speaker): May I ask a question?

Baptist pastor (speaker): A question from your side.

Orthodox priest: I abstain.

Orthodox (speaker): Let me ask…

Orthodox: I have a heap of questions…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here — Priest Mikhail, perhaps, also wants to ask us something.

Orthodox (speaker): And here you said, Sergei — the father wanted to say…

Orthodox priest: Who knows — perhaps he will come to repentance, will come to us…

Orthodox (speaker): Sergei Antonovich, you said that ordination is of little interest to you and that you do not believe in the transmission of grace-bearing gifts, yes? I would like to hear the answer to such a question, concerning your hierarchy specifically — if one may call it that: does it have some sacramental side, or only the practical purpose of you as a pastor? You said in your report that your laypeople cannot celebrate the Eucharist — for what reason?

Baptist pastor (speaker): We have two Sacraments which we acknowledge: baptism and the breaking of bread. Only an ordained minister — a presbyter and a deacon — has the right to celebrate these sacraments.

Orthodox (speaker): And if he does not have…

Baptist pastor (speaker): And we have senior presbyters as well. Therefore we hold to this and try not to act on our own authority.

Orthodox priest: But why?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Because…

Orthodox (speaker): If there is no sacramental side at all… what is the point?

Orthodox priest: There are no intelligible restrictions of some kind… What is this connected with?

Orthodox (speaker): And where in the Bible is it written…

Orthodox priest: …that ordinary people may not break bread? They broke bread from house to house daily, it is said in the book of Acts — do you remember? (Acts 2:46)

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: But you forbid it… and only once a month besides… Note — contrary to the Bible…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here we agree with the teaching about the sacrament of the church — that the church is the Body of Christ, and we must all gather together. And there must be… I believe the church must be taught.

Orthodox priest: So…

Baptist pastor (speaker): And the church must be shepherded. Who must teach the church and shepherd it? The appointed minister — that is, a presbyter or a bishop. Or, if there is no presbyter, as a last resort a deacon. He must know the Word of God well, and he must teach. And only the person who shepherds those sheep has the right to commune them — that is, to pray over the Bread and the Cup. And he himself must be ordained.

Orthodox priest: Excellent…

Baptist pastor (speaker): We acknowledge that ordination is an important matter, but we do not believe that at the moment of ordination the Holy Spirit is transmitted.

Orthodox priest: I have heard you.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We accepted it earlier.

Orthodox priest: May I clarify — Alan, give me the floor. I want to clarify your thought. So, today, in 2024, you insist on the necessity of there being an ordained presbyter. A pastor, a deacon — no matter who, some minister… He would teach the people, because without teaching the Bible is not so clear. One must teach. This is his obligatory duty. More than that — he must not only teach, but he has the right, and he alone, to celebrate the breaking of bread, in particular…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: And more than that — this is not simply some beautiful, touching rite, but you even call it a Sacrament, that is, you ascribe to this action a certain mysterious significance, in which God Himself acts invisibly.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: But where do you see all this in Scripture? Excuse me, of course. Or conversely… Why, if it is so today, was it not so a thousand years ago? And again — a thousand years ago there must have been ministers with correct ordination, teaching the people the Word of God, who celebrated the breaking of bread.

The church of God is identical to itself, self-identical. If it is so today, it must have been the same two thousand years ago, with the apostles. That is what we hold. The church is self-identical — and with you it is not.

Baptist pastor (speaker): I do not know what it was like a thousand years ago.

Orthodox priest: I know it was not so…

Baptist pastor (speaker): …and how they did it there… But I know how Christ did it at the Last Supper. He, as the chief Minister, took, broke, and gave out so that they might eat, yes? And He then said: This do in remembrance of Me (Luke 22:19). And the apostles did the same. And the apostles afterward, in all the cities, in those churches they founded, established presbyters. They ordained them and bequeathed to them that they should do this. That is precisely what we believe.

Orthodox priest: So it must have been…

Baptist pastor (speaker): But we believe this not because the Orthodox church teaches it, but because it is written in the Gospel.

Orthodox priest: Right. And we agree with this. But why — if it was so with the apostles, and it is so with you — but in between, where is this very “glory to God through all ages…” (Ephesians 3:21)

Baptist pastor (speaker): I do not know. But it does not interest me greatly.

Orthodox priest: I know — I have liturgical books, and there it is written that as I, a priest, serve now, so also my spiritual forebears served five hundred, or a thousand, or a thousand five hundred years ago. That I know. And history knows it. But what you know, you say: “I cannot say.”

Baptist pastor (speaker): And is there among you such a holy father who could impose a penance on you?

Orthodox priest: He can. Here sits this father… But I will not submit…

Baptist pastor (speaker): So let us go on. I think I have answered.

Orthodox priest: Yes, yes.

Orthodox woman: A clarifying question… on this point…

Orthodox (speaker): And I have a clarifying one, literally a second.

Orthodox woman: Yes. Why do you call baptism and the Eucharist Sacraments, if it is all merely a symbol, and baptism too is a formality, like a funeral… What Sacraments? It is a formality… You told us exactly that…

Baptist pastor (speaker): The Sacraments concern not the outward rite, because we, in fact, believe that these are symbols of the Body of Christ even after the prayer. But we believe in the spiritual presence of Jesus Christ.

And at that moment, when our body receives the bread and the wine, at that same time our soul, by our faith, stretching directly by faith to Golgotha, touches and joins itself to the crucified Christ. And we experience co-crucifixion, and at that moment we especially feel the washing by the blood of Jesus Christ.

Orthodox woman: And the reading of the Bible turns out to be a sacrament too, yes?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes, if we do it with prayer…

Orthodox woman: So already three sacraments…

Baptist pastor (speaker): In our brotherhood this is not called such a special sacrament, although I believe that Christ said the words I am saying: they are spirit and life. If we read Scripture with prayer and with the cooperation of the Holy Spirit, then these words come alive for us and make our soul alive. I believe this.

Orthodox (speaker): Thank you, Sergei Antonovich — literally one clarification, two seconds. Concerning — again I return you to the theme of our meeting today, on ordination. You said that ordination means nothing to you. Simply…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I did not say that.

Orthodox (speaker): No — that no gifts are transmitted… the Holy Spirit…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I do not believe that the Holy Spirit is transmitted through ordination.

Orthodox (speaker): Give me, please, the Baptist interpretation of this verse which I cited. The apostle Paul writes to Timothy: do not neglect the gift that is in you, do not neglect…

Orthodox priest: Take care… for the gift…

Orthodox (speaker): …that is, take care of it, yes, take care, devote time to it, which was given to you by prophecy with the laying on of the hands of the eldership (1 Timothy 4:14).

In another place, literally one more second — I remind you to stir up the gift of God, that is, again, precisely to take care of it… which is in you through the laying on of my hands (2 Timothy 1:6). Please read it in the Baptist interpretation.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Nothing is said here about the Holy Spirit, and we do not believe this is spoken precisely of the transmission of the Holy Spirit. Here it speaks of the gift of ministry.

The gift of ministry — in the epistle to the Romans and in the epistle to the Corinthians, in chapter 12, they are listed; and he received a special gift of ministry, as he became a helper of the apostle.

Orthodox (speaker): Of the priesthood…

Baptist pastor (speaker): With the laying on of the hands of the eldership this gift — he himself no longer doubted that it was a gift… by prophecy it was also said to him that God had given him this gift. It is the gift of ministry, not the gift of the Holy Spirit.

Orthodox priest: Fine, I have heard. So it turns out this is a ministry which is a gift of God, transmitted through the laying on of hands and passed on in succession. From teacher to disciple — is that not right?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Not necessarily.

Orthodox priest: But how else can it be? You understand to what… to John Smyth…

Baptist pastor (speaker): What is primary is the calling… The calling from God is primary, as God called Jeremiah, and Ezekiel…

Orthodox priest: But the gift is transmitted through ordination…

Baptist pastor (speaker): …and other prophets… and He called Paul himself. Paul He called not through the twelve apostles, but directly Himself, and it was not an apostle who laid hands on him, but a certain disciple Ananias, of whom we know very little.

Orthodox priest: He was one of the apostles of the seventy…

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, we do not know that.

Orthodox priest: You do not know — we know…

Baptist pastor (speaker): There are only twelve apostles, but a certain disciple Ananias, who lived altogether in a pagan country, in Damascus, came, laid hands on him, and through the laying on of the hands not of an apostle but of an ordinary disciple, the apostle Paul received the Holy Spirit.

Orthodox (speaker): And washed away his sins…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here — this already contradicts what you said.

Orthodox (speaker): Well, thank you, fine.

Orthodox priest: We will not argue; we are not arguing, but finding out your opinion. Your question.

Baptist pastor (speaker): The question is this. If… did I understand correctly, that a church comes into being as a result of the ministry of an ordained minister only — that is, without the participation of an ordained minister, say, some pagan locality…

Orthodox priest: But the church — what is meant by that? A community?

Baptist pastor (speaker): A church? Yes, a community. These are people who believe in Christ. Here, for example: I fly to Yakutia, to the city of Mirny, 1992. Not one Orthodox church, not one priest. We flew to the frontier. Because the city had been formed recently; they had not yet had time to build churches. And we were among the first missionaries; the priests came only two years after us.

Orthodox priest: You were lucky…

Baptist pastor (speaker): So, for example: there is no one. Atheists altogether…

Orthodox priest: We have heard…

Baptist pastor (speaker): An ordained minister arrives, a priest. And he begins there to teach, to preach. He builds a church in parallel.

Orthodox priest: Yes…

Baptist pastor (speaker): The priests at once began to teach. There was no church building yet. They bought out a little wooden house, put up some kind of spire, a wooden cross as well. And that was it. And that was the Orthodox church in the first years, while the building was going up.

So then — without the participation of this priest. If the priest had not come, but a Baptist had come.

Orthodox priest: You came, in fact…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Not even ordained, say. And he began to preach the living word of God. And people came. One small announcement… sixty people, then eighty, then more than a hundred.

Orthodox priest: Fantastic…

Baptist pastor (speaker): At the third meeting — it was the nineties, you know, yes? A Bible school opened, people began to listen. These people repented, we baptized them and continued to teach. And we celebrated the Eucharist together with them. Is this a church or not a church? From your point of view.

Orthodox priest: That is easy to answer… I can even tell you more: there are whole countries where for centuries there was no Orthodox Church, and they were all outside the true Church. And likewise these unfortunate Yakut citizens, who did not know… were not baptized in the Orthodox Church and went to you — they were, of course, outside the Orthodox Church, outside the true Church of Christ.

Baptist pastor (speaker): That is, it was not a church?

Orthodox priest: They were outside the Body of Christ, outside the Church.

Baptist pastor (speaker): If it is not a church, then they are not saved…

Orthodox priest: Undoubtedly.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Let us take the eleventh chapter of Acts.

Orthodox priest: Yes, of course.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here the first church of the Gentiles was formed. Verse nineteen: Now those who were scattered after the persecution that arose over Stephen traveled as far as Phoenicia, Cyprus, and Antioch, preaching the word to no one but the Jews only. But some of them were men from Cyprus and Cyrene, who, when they had come to Antioch, spoke to the Hellenists, preaching the Lord Jesus. And the hand of the Lord was with them, and a great number believed and turned to the Lord… that is, received true salvation. Then news of these things came to the ears of the church in Jerusalem, and they sent out Barnabas to go as far as Antioch. When he came and had seen the grace of God… he did not bring them the grace of God through the laying on of hands, but had already seen the grace of God… he was glad, and encouraged them all that with purpose of heart they should continue with the Lord (Acts 11:19–23).

All. And there, in general, many more people were added to the Lord. Here these men from Cyprus and Cyrene who came to Antioch preached to the Gentiles; the first church of the Gentiles was formed. Did the grace of God act there? Were the people being saved there, or not?

Orthodox priest: May I answer?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: Fine. Let us read to the end what you passed over there hurriedly: And a great many people were added to the Lord (Acts 11:24). Barnabas is one of the apostles of the seventy. This is not written in Scripture; it is the tradition of the Church. Being one of the apostles of the seventy — that is why he is Paul’s companion… not some chance person, but precisely he. It is to him that the Holy Spirit says: “Be the companion.” So, he is one of the apostles of the seventy. Being such, he, like Ananias with Paul, has the right to lay on hands.

Therefore the grace of God — I already told you today — acts always and everywhere, leading people into the Church. But these scattered ones were different. Some, like Ananias — this was mentioned today as well — were also of the apostles of the seventy. And could lay on hands and baptize.

Others were laypeople and could not lay on hands. All sorts of things happened. In any case, in this place to which Barnabas went, we see that grace acted, leading people into the Church, and this is certainly the grace of God… Having come, having believed in Christ, they need baptism. When he came and laid hands on them, it is said, a great many people were added to the Lord.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Where does it say here that he laid on hands? I do not see it here.

Orthodox priest: And where does it say he walked on his feet, and did not fly on an airplane?

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, well…

Baptist: Ah, clear — you added it, further…

Orthodox priest: We did not add. We know. We know from other places that hands were laid and the grace of God was transmitted.

Baptist: We are analyzing only this passage now…

Baptist pastor (speaker): We believe only what is written here. But you add.

Orthodox priest: You said it very well. “We believe what is written only here.” And you say: “You add from another place.”

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: But you understand that Scripture, including this passage, is not any kind of textbook. Not of dogmatic theology, not of churchliness, not of anything else.

Scripture presupposes that we, like these architects, conduct excavations and say: “Aha — here is such a foundation, here such an element… The building was of such-and-such dimensions. And here is such a load-bearing wall… And the height was approximately such.” Right? No more can the architects say about the building… What the windows were like, what the ornament was inside, whether there was any at all — but something can be said.

So with us. If in one place it is said that hands must be laid, and in another it is not said that they were laid. Will they be laid or not? We hold that yes; you say no. But this is quite unserious.

Here you told me you are a pastor, and I say: “Very glad to see you.” But every time, shall I ask whether hands were laid on you at your appointment to the office? Well, I will not ask; it is obvious. So here too: there are things obvious to everyone.

Moreover, the book was written for people on all of whom hands had always been laid. It was not necessary to speak of this separately. They knew it already. That is what you need to be told…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Please clarify, Evgeny: you said just now — perhaps I did not hear quite correctly — that Holy Scripture is not a guide for the Church.

Orthodox priest: No, you have understood completely incorrectly…

Baptist pastor (speaker): May I hear it again?

Orthodox priest: In Scripture the truths — of faith and of church practice alike — are not set out at length and broadly, all at once in one place. They must be sought in different places of Scripture. And you too — in this report and in others — did not quote some book in a row, word for word, but brought quotations from different places. And that is right.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes.

Orthodox priest: Well, is that not exactly what I am saying? If in one place it is said that hands must be laid, and in another it is passed over in silence — does that deny the laying on of hands? Well, this is unserious.

Orthodox (speaker): Now let the question be from Alexei.

Orthodox: Listening to this whole discussion, one question arose in me… many arose in me; here is one of them… If historical succession is not needed and not important, if it does not matter what happened between the writing of the Bible and the present day… is such a model permitted — look, I am an ordinary person, I live, I find the Bible, I read — God so loved the world (John 3:16) — and then I understand: God loves me, Jesus is Lord; I tell this to him, he also believes — here the Lord is between us. We repent, we baptize one another, that is it — we are a church. And we begin to preach to others, we come to Yakutia and somewhere else; a hundred people come to us — that is it, hallelujah, and so on… Is this a workable model or not?

Orthodox priest: And it happened many times…

Baptist pastor (speaker): In our brotherhood this is not welcomed, but in exceptional cases it is allowed. If such a thing has already happened, we do not rebaptize these people afterward, even if they baptized themselves. If one of them, say (I cannot, of course, speak now for the whole brotherhood) — but I, if they believed according to Scripture, yes… If one of them, say, was baptized but not ordained, and baptized the others, then I would — having learned of their faith — if they believe correctly according to Scripture, I would not rebaptize them.

Orthodox: No, well — do we accept such a model as a church?

Orthodox priest: What significance is there in rebaptism at all? There is no sacrament there.

Orthodox (speaker): A good question.

Baptist pastor (speaker): No — I consider that if they believe in Jesus Christ as their Savior, if they stand firmly on Scripture and have the Holy Spirit — the signs of a person born again must be visible in their life — then I acknowledge them as my brother and sister.

Orthodox: Signs again… I recently listened, for example, to an American pastor; he read the text: Philip baptizes the eunuch. He himself is also of non-traditional orientation (the pastor), and he says, on the basis of this text of Scripture…

Baptist: “Also” — you mean that we too are of non-traditional orientation…

Orthodox: No, I did not mean that; I apologize…

Orthodox priest: You are quite all right, I hope…

Orthodox: Well, we know about the West, Europe… But can you listen to the end? Here, about two or three gathered and the Lord between us… And this understanding of his… there — what is the question? To baptize transgender people or not?

And he says: Philip baptized the eunuch… a eunuch… I can send this video to anyone interested. He states this quite seriously. That is how Holy Scripture was revealed to him, and now he baptizes all these perverts.

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, no, no.

Baptist: Well, not all Protestants teach soundly…

Orthodox: The concept “soundly” — on what do we base the concept “soundly”? All of them wave the same Bible. He has exactly the same Bible.

Baptist pastor (speaker): No — it is clearly written here that… Romans, the first chapter: these are perverts who commit abominations and all…

Orthodox: They think differently about all these malakoi…

Baptist: One must not build the whole doctrine on one verse…

Orthodox: Well, again, we take our own reason…

Orthodox priest: Allow me to clarify your words. Here Alan was directly inspired by your words, and — believe me — sometimes simple human sympathy speaks in me; this is not for the sake of currying favor, you understand that in faith we are strangers to each other, unfortunately, but human sympathy.

You have just spoken about rebaptism. I understand what it means with us. If one of you, not baptized in infancy, comes to us, we will baptize you, counting your Baptist baptism as nothing, because it is not a Sacrament for us.

But if with you a person believed, was reborn, in your own understanding, and then someone random baptized him — not an ordained pastor, but some random person baptized him — then, strictly speaking, he bore witness that he died to the world, and everything is well with him; everything seems in place.

But you say: but if he was not ordained, or earlier he was unbaptized, and they simply baptized themselves, then I will baptize him. That is, you speak of rebaptism. So what do I want to say here?

With your heart you feel that this is truly a Sacrament. And with your mind you say: “This is a sacred rite, and it does not matter who performs it or how.”

And you get a certain collision of your life experience, intuition, and religious feeling, on the one hand, and, on the other, the doctrines that Baptism offers you. And this human quality of yours is deeply sympathetic to me.

But from the point of view of faith this is nonsense: how can one baptize someone who has already declared that he died to the world and is saved?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes… I want to tell you: we had a sister in our church. She has now gone to live in the south, so she is not among us now. In the Irkutsk region she began to read the Gospel, believed with all her heart, considered herself Orthodox, and sought in the Orthodox church a temple and a priest who baptizes by full immersion. She had read that John thus baptized, that the apostles thus baptized. She found an Orthodox church, a priest, near Petersburg.

Orthodox priest: Far away…

Baptist pastor (speaker): She went there. She flew by plane; she was a businesswoman, she had enough money. She found this priest, spoke with him — said, I want to be baptized as Jesus Christ and the apostles were baptized. He gave her the go-ahead; she went through baptism. She returned there, lived a while, moved to Kostroma. She found our church, came, and told us of her baptism. And we did not rebaptize her, because she was baptized at a conscious age with living faith in Christ. The Holy Spirit dwells in her heart, and we acknowledged the Orthodox baptism. It was by full immersion, that is all. No questions.

Orthodox priest: No, I am not talking about that.

Orthodox (speaker): For you it is merely a symbol, after all…

Orthodox priest: I am talking about your words. About the fact that there is a certain person who believed by himself, baptized himself, or another like him baptized him — one who, in your view, is unbaptized. You will baptize him.

Orthodox (speaker): Why, if it is a symbol? Why do this at all? That is the question… For what purpose, if it is simply a symbol…

Orthodox priest: I was simply surprised how with you the doctrine is one thing, and the faith another.

A long pause.

Baptist pastor (speaker): I recall — did I say that?

Orthodox priest: Excellent!

Baptist pastor (speaker): If one, say, is baptized and the rest are not baptized, even if he is not ordained, and he baptizes them, then, on the contrary, I said I would not rebaptize them.

Orthodox priest: Correct. But if all of them are unbaptized and baptized one another…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Ah, they are not baptized?

Orthodox priest: Yes, I am speaking precisely of that…

Baptist pastor (speaker): That, yes — those we will rebaptize.

Orthodox priest: So I say — why?

Orthodox (speaker): If it is a symbol…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Because, well, here… yes, here there is succession, I agree, that…

Orthodox priest: From John Smyth…

Baptist pastor (speaker): No — I personally have not yet sorted it out, but our Baptist brotherhood too acknowledges succession here.

Orthodox priest: There — from John Smyth…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Well, I do not know, I do not know…

Orthodox priest: Who baptized himself…

Baptist: If the human side matters to you at all — as the apostle Paul says: “See — are you not carnal? ‘I am of Christ,’ ‘of Apollos,’ ‘I am of Paul’” (1 Corinthians 3:3–4), and so on — you know this yourselves; and he says this is altogether a carnal understanding.

But if it matters so much to you, count us as from John Smyth, even from Alexander the Third, whatever you like — we are neither hot nor cold about it; we understand that we believed through the word of God in Jesus Christ, in His shed blood. And precisely through this does salvation come. What do all the discussions, all the doctrine, and all the faith lead to, in the end?

Orthodox priest: Well, do understand…

Baptist: No. I asked the question. What does all this come to? To salvation? Or simply to squabble among ourselves over whether I know or do not know. Let us be honest.

Orthodox (speaker): So — the father remarks that in this case there are double standards.

Baptist: What double standards?

Orthodox priest: Honestly — but may I speak for myself? We are grown people; we are not children, right?

But you yourselves understand that we gather not to chatter; we are not bored — we are all grown people, we have things to do. Someone even came from a neighboring province. This is important for us. I hope it is important for you too. We are not playing with words; we are not joking here; we do not try to catch you in your word, and you do not try us. Well, is that not right?

We have met not the first, not the second time, and in a spirit of mutual understanding. We have no unanimity in faith, but at least human mutual understanding exists. So why do you speak like that?

Baptist: No — it is simply that many times you did it with mockery. You say it yourselves — “then you are from John Smyth”… Well, count it so.

Orthodox priest: Once more.

Baptist: We need to agree with you — we agree.

Orthodox priest: No — it is not about mockery, it is about something else. For the apostles it was necessary that the Church be apostolic, founded, among other things, on the transmission of grace-bearing gifts to their disciples.

And these gifts, as a river flows from its source to its mouth, are transmitted from the day of Pentecost to the Second Coming. The same gifts of the Holy Spirit are transmitted continuously — do you understand? If there is a break somewhere, the river has ended; there will be another river afterward, not this one. So: if with you the transmission of these baptisms and so on is from John Smyth, you have no gifts, no grace-bearing gifts, from the apostles. But if directly from them — then glory to God. That is what we say: this is important.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes — directly from the apostles, from Christ, directly, not from John Smyth. Hear us.

Baptist: Although I am under a penance, still…

Orthodox priest: Well, this is something…

Baptist: Listen, listen. It will not be I speaking, but the word of God… I will not speak.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Brothers, if you have questions, ask…

Baptist: It is from Matthew… chapter three… Just a moment.

Orthodox priest: Say what it is about — we will understand… We read it…

Baptist pastor 2: Verse eleven. Well, let us read it all the same… I indeed baptize you with water unto repentance, but He who is coming after me is mightier than I, whose sandals I am not worthy to carry. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire… (Matthew 3:11) John says elsewhere — I do not remember right now which place… He is the one who baptizes with the Holy Spirit.

You speak about the succession of the apostles and other people. Here it is stated directly — and very many places of Holy Scripture as well — that it is precisely Christ who is the Giver, the Baptizer with the Holy Spirit.

Orthodox (speaker): Without mediators…

Baptist: Without mediators. Therefore, when the apostles laid on hands, it was not the apostles who baptized with the Holy Spirit. And this is blasphemy — I am not afraid of the word… Why does this Simon the sorcerer, who brought money to the feet of the apostles, say: Give me this power also… that anyone on whom I lay hands may receive the Holy Spirit… (Acts 8:18–19) Blasphemy — that a man, any man — let him be a bishop, an archbishop — should govern the Holy Spirit, the living God.

Orthodox priest: Please formulate the question…

Baptist: A moment… So — a person who believed in Christ receives from Christ the baptism with the Holy Spirit, which does not manifest itself in some one gift, or in certain manifestations, but manifests itself in that Christ becomes manifest in that person.

Today, a moment — today I simply heard such a thing, and my heart was moved. A little boy stands on the platform holding toys, little blocks, and the train came in; everyone rushed (he even began to cry, I do not know)… they rushed, the blocks flew, and the little boy began to gather them… Everyone toward that train, but one gentleman took it, squatted down, and began gathering the blocks with him. He gathered them. He says: “Tell me — are you Jesus Christ?”

The spirit of Christ manifested itself in him. That is — this spirit, this kindness of Christ… and in the person who believed Christ, how does the baptism with the Holy Spirit manifest itself? By Christ’s love and kindness.

And whoever has this — it does not matter of what denomination he is. He is my brother and my sister, because… One more point I will say: as one argued and argued with a Christian — the other stood and simply listened, and then said, and these are two Christians — Baptists, by the way. And the one was proving something to him, and he says: “Tell me one question: why does my spirit not join with yours?”

The point is that all were together with one accord; he says: “that they may be one just as We are” (John 17:22), and whoever received the Holy Spirit, whomever Christ precisely baptized with the Holy Spirit — yes, He is within me — yes, understanding, say, of rites and such — there are different ones, and I am one hundred percent in agreement with the Baptists, with the doctrine… and with the Pentecostals, and with the Orthodox understanding — but as far as the Word of God is concerned, and where it is revealed that this teaching is according to the Word of God, I agree with it.

Well, I say this to myself. Therefore here we look: it is Christ who administers baptism — yes, He can transmit it through the apostles — here we say the first apostles did not lay on hands but simply said: repent, and be baptized, and receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. To someone — Cornelius — the Holy Spirit came before baptism; that is, we see that God… how to say it…

Baptist pastor (speaker): He is a sovereign God. As He wills, so He acts…

Baptist: Well yes, how to find that word… creative approach… even Jesus Christ, when He healed, He healed everyone differently… He has His own approach, and we see omnipotence — I do not know what word…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Speak more briefly, more quickly…

Baptist: Yes — therefore we want today to enclose the whole doctrine into a template, into the laying on of hands, into what… but we see, unambiguously, there is no other name who baptized with the Holy Spirit except Christ.

Orthodox (speaker): But we do not dispute this: the Lord baptizes — agreed — but through the apostles.

Orthodox priest: But still, it seems to me, I understand your thought. Look: you consider that the church, until the appearance of the Baptists in the seventeenth century, was accordingly invisible, and now the church has become visible — or do I not understand you? Are you a church or not a church?

Baptist pastor (speaker): No — there have always been people on earth, in all ages, who believed Jesus Christ and the Word of God…

Orthodox priest: But they had no pastors, they had no system of instruction, they had no correct breaking of bread, no correct baptism — yet they were always somewhere?

Baptist pastor (speaker): These people existed among them, and there was some possibility of touching the Word of God.

Orthodox priest: That is, they had Bibles, which were extremely rare and very expensive, and they had money with which to buy Bibles, to copy them for themselves. And they did this always and everywhere — as if our edition of the Bible… And, most important, they, not having — I repeat — pastors, a system of instruction, a system of the correct breaking of bread, a properly ordered community as with you, and everything else, were correctly believing. Do I understand your thought correctly?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Well, I believe they existed; how many there were, I do not know.

Orthodox priest: It is not the number that interests me. Here — the outward side, which you have; they, of course, did not have it and could not have had it — that is an obvious thing; there were no such communities. Individual believers… I will not argue here. You do not know their names, I do not know their names; I even believe they did not exist — but I will not argue with you. There were no communities.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Perhaps we did not explain this…

Orthodox priest: Yes, this is very important.

Baptist pastor (speaker): I want to clarify this… In the Catholic and in the Orthodox church, especially in the first centuries, when there was not yet so much apostasy, the Word of God was often preached directly within these churches; the priests taught the Word of God. Later they moved to various languages — say, with us in Russia, yes, when Christianity came here, it was taught in Church Slavonic. That is why the people were dark. But those priests, all the same, alongside the traditions, read the Word of God and taught. And in those Catholic and Orthodox churches there were reborn people; they belonged to the historical churches, but in spirit they were children of God — these are my brothers and sisters. And how many there were — perhaps even hundreds of thousands.

Orthodox priest: So you have different conditions of salvation. Here you are a pastor; some other pastor taught you; you accepted the correct faith, and you yourselves teach your hearers the correct faith; they feed on the spiritual word from you; you celebrate the breaking of bread for them; you teach them to be baptized correctly — everything is in place. But a thousand years ago (I say again), a thousand years ago, when everything is already bad, after icon veneration, when everything is destroyed, there is no true teaching (in your opinion) — and there, a thousand years ago… The church must be continuous, all days…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I think that such a bad one as today’s Catholic and Orthodox church, the church was not a thousand years ago.

Orthodox priest: How well you said it… Laughter. I do not even know what to answer…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I believe it was in a better state… “Bad,” in the sense of “sick,” because many different traditions, even heresies, entered the Orthodox church.

Baptist 2: My question was precisely at that point: if from the apostolic time to the present day — what is your measure, that precisely over these two thousand years, let us say figuratively, you have not departed from the truth either to the right or to the left at all? How do you verify this? What is the point?

Orthodox priest: Let us begin with the fact that the Head of the Church with us is the Lord Jesus Christ; the Church is filled with the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of truth, who promised to guide us into all truth — right? Since the Lord cannot deceive, and the Holy Spirit, being the Spirit of truth, cannot fall into error, the Lord cares for the Church, and the Holy Spirit establishes it in the truth, and it cannot be otherwise. Moreover, He also teaches it the truth.

Baptist 2: Further…

Orthodox priest: If certain church teachers deviate, like evil wolves, then they are expelled by the judgment of God, and the true teachers must always remain as teachers and teach correctly. I believe this. And I compared the teaching of the present church with the apostolic teaching, including on the question of salvation. You know that “those who were being saved” are added — you yourselves quoted it — and not “the saved”; you reread that place, you could not believe it, but it is true. “Those being saved” are added to the church. The apostle likewise says many times that he is not already saved, but that he is “being saved…”

Orthodox (speaker): Saved in hope…

Orthodox priest: Saved in hope, and so on. I do not dispute about salvation; I speak of something else; and reading these and similar places, we see the identity of our faith with the faith of the apostles. We see the succession of the Holy Spirit from the apostles even to us. We know…

Baptist 2: You read it where? More specifically…

Orthodox priest: In Scripture — our Scripture.

Baptist 2: In the Bible?

Orthodox priest: This Bible is the book of the Church, do you understand? You took it from us, but it is ours.

Baptist 2: Not in the traditions, but in the Bible?

Orthodox priest: In the Bible, and in church teaching — everywhere; we read it in both places.

Baptist 2: In tradition too… Well, I am clarifying… You answer, I clarify…

Orthodox (speaker): Of course… According to the teaching of the apostle Paul, yes…

Orthodox priest: I read it in Holy Scripture and in church books, which belong to the same church Tradition — because the apostle requires of me that I obey the Tradition of the Church.

Baptist 2: And your tradition agrees directly and identically with the Word of God…

Orthodox (speaker): According to the teaching of the apostle Paul, yes…

Baptist: Paul…

Orthodox priest: According to the teaching of the apostle Paul and by the action of the Holy Spirit, yes…

Baptist 2: But from Andrew — or have I failed to understand something…

Orthodox priest: We are unanimous with Paul and with Andrew — this is one Church.

Baptist 2: But first there was one, then several… ten more remained…

Orthodox priest: And with Peter, and with John the Theologian, and with Thomas, and with Matthew, and with the rest. With all of them we are completely unanimous.

Baptist 2: But I did not, in principle, hear how… but the main thing is what you said, how you…

Orthodox priest: Well, I did try, believe me.

Baptist: Well, what do you do if your tradition does not correspond to the Word of God…

Orthodox priest: I will answer easily.

Baptist: What — tradition or the Word of God is more important?

Orthodox priest: I will answer easily. When I had only begun to go to church, I remember I ended up in one church. There is a crowd of people, absolutely packed; people push me from behind and say: “Pass the candle to the icon.” Well, so as not to strain, I turned, took the candle, and pass it on. They say to me: “What are you doing — how can you, it is taken with the right hand!” I stand there and think: why the right hand, why not the left — “only with the right hand.” I remembered it; many years have passed; I remembered. I thought: why not, but this is a symbol of prayer, it is an offering to the church — what has the right or left hand to do with it? I took it with the left, and passed it with the left. There are unreasonable church customs; they are incorrect, they are not the teaching of the church, and they must be rejected. That already turns into some kind of magic. But correct church customs correspond fully to the apostolic faith.

Baptist: And here I am just asking my question: do you have a canon precisely of traditions? Or do the traditions just go on and on as they go, as it were historically, or is there some kind of canon?

Orthodox woman: But we have it — tell them… the consensus patrum…

Baptist: We will never learn from anyone except you.

Orthodox priest: I agree with you. Concerning the circle of things that enter church Tradition — have I understood your question correctly?

Baptist: Well, a canon, like… the Bible has a canon.

Orthodox priest: Yes.

Baptist: There are many there… the Gospel of Thomas, there… all of them…

Orthodox priest: …were excluded. Yes.

Baptist: But you have many traditions as well. How, where was this canon affirmed, all… this tradition — how did it all happen?

Orthodox priest: Unfortunately, in the way you would like — that there is a list, 25–26 points, and 27 will not do — we do not have such a list; it is a more complex concept.

We see this in Holy Scripture too. The apostle Paul, who requires of us to stand and hold the traditions, does not say “a list — 1, 2, 3, hold 25, 26, and not 27,” but he says “traditions” — what you have remembered, you heard; what you heard, do; and the Holy Spirit will guide you into all truth.

So with the Church. We have, of course, church canons — quite many — and a definite list of them, and no more. But at the same time there are customs which do not enter the circle of these canons, or enter other texts, which, of course, could easily be included in them. Say, I spoke about the Eucharist: the order of service of the Eucharist is not established precisely by a church canon adopted by a council, yet the Church honors it as a necessary rite of service — I do not know whether that is clear.

Baptist: You probably understood a little wrongly. You have written traditions, as the Word of God is written. There are written traditions which are indeed canonized — and is that all, all the traditions?

Orthodox (speaker): First, these are the decrees of the Ecumenical Councils…

Baptist: Written — not merely passed from mouth to mouth…

Orthodox (speaker): Yes, I say: first, these are the decrees of the Ecumenical Councils — that is the main, so to speak, landmark by which we square ourselves, our worldview, our doctrine, and so on.

The next point is the teaching of the holy fathers — that is, not the teaching of individual holy fathers, but we look at, say, one position… and we have such a concept as the “consensus patrum” (the agreement of the fathers): that is, we hold as absolute truth those positions in which all the fathers believed at different times…

Orthodox priest: All, always, and everywhere.

Baptist: But is it written?

Orthodox (speaker): It is written.

Baptist: “The teaching of the fathers” — is it a book, or is it simply, as one likes…

Orthodox priest: One must read this one, and that one, and a third, the twentieth, the twenty-fifth…

Baptist: So it is not collected in one book with you…

Orthodox priest: Yes, with us it is so… Well, all questions answered?

Baptist 2: No — the original question, though: if there is a discrepancy… clarify… if there is a discrepancy between Scripture — the Bible — and your tradition…

Orthodox (speaker): Between Holy Scripture and Tradition there can be no discrepancies. If there are some truly real, objective discrepancies, then that is human tradition, which we reject — that is all, yes. But between Holy Tradition and Scripture there can be no discrepancies.

Orthodox priest: Let me give an example. In Scripture it says the bishop must be the husband of one wife, and we have a church canon that the bishop must be unmarried.

Baptist: So.

Orthodox priest: So. Monks — only monks. So, if a bishop will have no wife at all, does that mean the apostolic norm about one wife is violated? No, of course not. This is not two, not three wives. Thus we have a somewhat stricter requirement than the apostle’s, but it does not violate the spirit of apostolic teaching. Why? If there is a wife and little children, attention is necessarily given to them, and less attention to the Church. That is precisely so that not a priest, but a bishop — as the head of a church district…

Baptist: Dedicated…

Orthodox priest: …would dedicate himself wholly to the Church — such is the rule, tightening the apostle’s requirement.

Baptist: With us pastors are likewise both married and unmarried…

Orthodox priest: Accordingly, you understand…

Baptist: Here, Sergei Antonovich too was unmarried when he was ordained; afterward he marries…

Orthodox: With us that is not allowed.

Orthodox priest: And there is no need for it, frankly speaking…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Here is a question about the priesthood, then… It turns out there is white clergy and black… the black clergy is — monks, yes, those who are not married.

Orthodox priest: Yes.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Must they all walk in black clothes, or is there some canon about that with you? I know you are a married man, but why are you in black clothes, if you belong to the white clergy — you should be in white clothes.

Orthodox priest: “White” and “black” is not by the color of the garment.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Really?

Orthodox priest: Yes, it is simply such a designation.

Baptist pastor (speaker): You have no such canon.

Baptist pastor 2: And what does it symbolize?

Orthodox priest 2: It is simply for simplicity.

Orthodox priest: For understanding, I will say: I am a white priest — everyone understands at once.

Baptist pastor (speaker): But can a priest come out in white clothes? I know the Catholics, it seems, come out in white.

Orthodox priest: Yes, and we have white cassocks too.

Baptist pastor (speaker): In green there are — I have seen.

Orthodox (speaker): There are red ones too.

Orthodox priest: Sergei, all sorts of things happen…

Baptist pastor (speaker): It is not so important…

Orthodox priest: In antiquity there were more colors; now it is more uniform. Simply, white is inconvenient — stains appear quickly.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Yes, understood.

Baptist: So black today is simply symbolic?

Orthodox priest: No — black, of course, is also important; it shows our freedom from the filth of this world.

Baptist pastor (speaker): On the contrary — white should show…

Baptist 2: And white shows dirt…

Orthodox priest: But white has somewhat different symbolism. White garments are placed on the one being baptized, as a symbol of purity and blamelessness in Christ.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We too baptize only in white garments.

Baptist pastor (speaker): By the way, we too baptize only in white garments…

Baptist: Oh, here we are united!… Thank God.

Orthodox: Pastor, here is what I wanted to ask — I remembered this example from your report. You gave the example of the mug. The mug is the form, and what is in it is the content. The content matters, not the form; nevertheless, all evening ninety percent of what you said was precisely about the form.

Baptist pastor (speaker): It seems to me that you, on the contrary, are speaking about the form.

Orthodox: We are precisely striving toward the content…

Baptist pastor (speaker): Succession and so on — all that is form. We believe not in historical succession but in spiritual succession, you understand? Spiritual succession ascending to the apostles — we take it directly from here and apply it in life, and that is all.

Orthodox: But this is pure subjectivism: I believe it is so, and I believe it is so, and he believes it is so — we all believe, all are based on the Bible, but this is subjective faith. It must have some foundation under it.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We will come to the Judgment Seat of Christ, and there He will say…

Orthodox: And if He says: you are the goats, go to the left side…

Baptist pastor (speaker): I believe He will not say that to me, because He saved me.

Baptist 2: Alexei, then ask us, and yourself too… Not only us…

Orthodox: So I ask myself… that is why I do not shout that I am saved…

Baptist 2: But suddenly He will say that to you too…

Orthodox priest 2: That is precisely why we hope for salvation.

Baptist pastor (speaker): But if I did not know Jesus Christ personally, if He did not dwell in my heart, if He had not freed me from the power of sin, had not given me His love, had not given me revulsion toward the world, toward the “goat”…. TO THE GOAT — not that I am a goat…

Laughter.

Baptist pastor 3: He caught himself!

We all laugh together!

Orthodox priest: Oh, how dangerously you walk…

Baptist pastor (speaker): This is not something I produced within myself. It is Christ, who dwells in me. And He sent me as a missionary from Western Ukraine to the east of our country. Directly from Western Ukraine, straight to Yakutia. And that is all. There I performed this missionary service, preached to people. People repented, were saved, were freed from the power of sin. Drug addicts were freed; we opened a rehab center — everything was there. If we had carried heresy, the people would not have been freed.

Comment: Whence this strange conviction? We did, after all, give him examples of liberation from addiction among the Jehovah’s Witnesses, the Muslims, and the Hare Krishnas. Does the pastor really acknowledge their faith as true as well? The devil will grant any liberation from addictions into which he himself had earlier plunged the person — if only the person would not come to God. Or does a secular rehab center also bear witness to the true faith of its owner — an atheist? So, healings and freedom from addiction do not guarantee true faith. God’s benefits are given not only to the faithful but also to ungrateful people, as is evident from Christ’s healing of the ten lepers.

Baptist 2: Unfortunately, at that last meeting, when Igor said all this… your Igor gave his testimony at the end. And, by the way, clarify — because there was no time that time, you said it as we were closing, we had already prayed. And at that time you said it and then began to testify about yourself, how the Lord led you — there, down the hill — and you then pointed at Igor, who was giving his testimony: clarify about the spirit of which you said… a different spirit, yes?

Baptist pastor (speaker): Simply a word sounded which…

Baptist 2: Some interesting word sounded from you.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Name that word once more.

Baptist 2: A strange spirit…

Baptist pastor (speaker): No, some word sounded…

Baptist pastor 3: You pointed at Igor, who was testifying about how God…

Orthodox 2: I cannot recall right now…

Baptist pastor (speaker): It was not the spirit of enchantment; the word sounded somehow different.

Baptist 2: You said something about the spirit somehow; I was even curious, thought to clarify.

Orthodox priest: But he did not want to offend him…

Orthodox 2: In any case, I meant the spirit of delusion.

Baptist pastor (speaker): But we understood that. But you called it by some word we had never heard.

Baptist 2: Well, fine… You say the spirit of delusion. So it turns out the spirit of delusion frees from evil. And Christ says precisely — if it were the spirit of delusion, how would satan then stand, if the house within is divided?

Orthodox 2: No, no, no — I remembered; let me… I was speaking…

Baptist pastor 3: No, no — we are now talking with the very person who said it.

Orthodox 2: I said the “crafty spirit” — the one that flatters.

Orthodox priest: That is the spirit of delusion in Russian.

Orthodox 2: That is the spirit of delusion. That is in Old Church Slavonic.

Baptist pastor (speaker): The spirit of flattery — understood.

Baptist 2: A question. That Igor who testified that God freed him from everything, even from his uncleanness — is that precisely the spirit of delusion?

Orthodox 2: Possibly. I say it cannot be denied.

Baptist 2: But then how does Christ speak, when they say to Him too that by the spirit of Beelzebub He casts out? He says — excuse me (Matthew 12:24–25).

Orthodox priest: Friends, but may we…

Orthodox 2: But we are speaking now about fruits, and there is no need to twist things here. This is the easiest option: when we say, here is Christ, and here am I. This is the simplest way to draw all the holiness of Christ onto oneself.

Orthodox priest: I propose not to argue over nothing.

Baptist pastor 3: We are not arguing — simply a clarification.

Orthodox 3: There is not a single sin in Igor, tell me? He has not a single passion now, tell me? If so, then he is like Christ. Then he…

Baptist 2: But He already told you…

Orthodox 2: What — he has not a single passion?

Baptist 2: The Lord freed him from slavery to sin…

Orthodox (speaker): Let me explain to you.

Baptist pastor 3: The matter is not in one or the other. He gave a testimony of the meeting with Christ, and at the same time of liberation; and you say — this is the spirit of flattery; I do not even want to comment further. I simply must also understand with what spirit we are dealing. That is all — thank you for the answer.

Orthodox priest: I ask you not to take offense now.

Baptist 2: But we are not taking offense; on the contrary, we clarified — for us this is very important.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We did not understand that word then. We discussed it at the brotherhood meeting.

Baptist 2: No — you have now clarified it.

Orthodox priest: The crafty spirit — in Slavonic; in Russian — the spirit of delusion.

Baptist 2: So, in Russian, the spirit of delusion was acting, you said.

Orthodox priest: Well, he said it in Slavonic. We sometimes speak in Slavonicisms. I would like, if I may, Sergei — perhaps to you or to our other friends — to address this question of mine. If we take the Church of the second century, after the death of John the Theologian. The church of the second century does not have the full canon of Scripture — we know this, first. Second, in the church of the second century almost no one has the complete set of the Old Testament. The New Testament exists only in the communities. Almost no one has it in hand. One must learn by the oral word, therefore. That very tradition, or teaching. This is obvious.

I told you about the veneration of relics in the second century as universally accepted. You say that is precisely a sign of apostasy. I heard you. I do not agree, but I heard. Other customs, incorrect ones, entered in the second century, you affirm to me. Again I heard. Again I do not agree, but I heard. So what does it come to? An ordinary person, like you or me, or them… An ordinary, rank-and-file person… Well, I am a priest; suppose I am an ordinary person. If he wishes to believe correctly.

He hears Scripture only in church, when he comes to the divine service. He has no book at home. Perhaps he cannot even read. Most were illiterate, you understand. And they teach him, as you say, incorrectly.

So it turns out they teach him incorrectly. He does not have Scripture. He trusts his church teachers, and they are in error — that very crafty spirit about which you argued among yourselves. They are in error, according to your own teaching. In the second century, among the church books of our successors of the apostles, nowhere is there the teaching of salvation by faith. Nowhere. I have read many of them. No one has such a teaching.

Baptist pastor (speaker): But did not blessed Augustine teach it?

Orthodox priest: He is in the fifth century; and first, in the West; second…

Baptist pastor (speaker): But the teaching by faith had reached him.

Orthodox priest: And, third, he is himself a bishop and requires, besides this, also the Sacraments and obedience to the hierarchy. He has no salvation by faith alone.

Orthodox (speaker): Moreover, he asserted that without baptism a person cannot be saved.

Orthodox priest: Yes, let us add that. That is, it is not only faith. So it turns out that, by your criteria, in the second century it was impossible to be saved. There was not, as with you, such a wonderful book, which one checked and said — here, it corresponds.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Thank you. So I will ask our holy apologists, who know history well, because I studied all this poorly. They have read all these fathers too.

Orthodox priest: Excellent.

Baptist pastor (speaker): And let them tell me: did they teach in the second century, in the third, about salvation by faith, by grace, or did they not teach? I will find out, and then we will continue.

Orthodox priest: It is a great pity that you do not know now; it would be interesting for me to learn.

Baptist pastor (speaker): We will continue. I have read little and speak as best I can, yes.

Orthodox (speaker): Well, that is all, dear friends — we have a time limit; it is already nine o’clock. One more last question, if there is one, and that is all.

Baptist pastor (speaker): Fine. Thank you for hearing us out today. We were, as never before, firm, hard.

Orthodox priest: You were?

Baptist pastor (speaker): We were, yes. Did you hear the end of my report? I ended it exactly as Alan did, so we were somewhere on the same level. We were always gentle like that, listened, condescended, and this time we decided… God laid it on my heart to do it thus. We strove to enlighten one another; we expressed our subjective opinions.

From the truth — from the fullness of the knowledge of the truth — we are still far away. Both we and you — we are not yet perfect. We acknowledge this; I hope you acknowledge it as well. Therefore we need Christ, His light, His word, His grace, in the action of the Holy Spirit, which dwells, I hope, in our hearts — and the presence of the Holy Spirit exists in yours as well — so that He may guide us into all truth, which is here, in the Gospel, and nowhere else.

Orthodox priest: We were glad today to speak with you, although we still do not have full mutual understanding; but there is the desire to understand one another, and that is very precious in our time — the time of division, the time of guile, the time when everyone tries to deceive one another. And amid such doctrinal and practical estrangement, the desire to understand one another seems to me a very important thing.

Baptist pastor (speaker): By 0.1 percent my love for you has increased.

Orthodox priest: And ours by two and a half.

Baptist 2: As always, you are ahead of us!

1
Ilichapishwa na mtumiaji: Rodion Vlasov
Tarehe ya kuunda ukurasa: 2026-11-19, Sasisha: 2026-11-19